Speaking on
the floor after the vote, Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell blamed the
government shutdown on a “cynical decision by the Democrats”. However, his
counterpart, minority leader Chuck Schumer, blamed Donald Trump, saying the
president had “walked away from two bipartisan deals” and that “a Trump
shutdown will serve as a perfect encapsulation for the chaos he has unleashed”.
US
government goes into shutdown after Senate rejects funding bill
White House
calls Democrats ‘obstructionist losers’ as federal agencies head into the first
closure for five years
Sabrina
Siddiqui, Ben Jacobs and Lauren Gambino in Washington
Sat 20 Jan
2018 08.00 GMT First published on Sat 20 Jan 2018 03.33 GMT
The United
States has its first government shutdown in nearly five years after senators
failed to reach a deal to keep the lights on.
An effort
by Republicans to keep the government open for one month was rejected in a vote
on Friday night after they failed to address Democratic concerns about young
undocumented immigrants known as Dreamers.
Republicans
needed 60 votes to make the bill filibuster-proof, but the legislation only
received the support of 50 senators. Five red state Democrats broke ranks to
support the bill while four Republicans voted against.
A
filibuster allows a senator, or a series of senators, to speak for as long as
they wish, and on any topic they choose, unless “three-fifths of the senators
duly chosen and sworn” (60 out of 100 senators) vote for the bill.
But 12.00am
ET came and went without a deal, causing funding for the federal government to
lapse. Federal law requires agencies to shut down if Congress has not
appropriated money to fund them. Hundreds of thousands of “non-essential”
federal employees will be put on temporary unpaid leave. In previous shutdowns,
services deemed “essential”, such as the work of the homeland security and the
FBI, have continued.
Speaking on
the floor after the vote, Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell assailed the
shutdown as the result of a “cynical decision by the Democrats”. His opposite
number, minority leader Chuck Schumer, delivered a scathing rebuke of Donald
Trump, blaming the president for the shutdown. The New York Democrat said Trump
“walked away from two bipartisan deals” and that “a Trump shutdown will serve
as a perfect encapsulation for the chaos he has unleashed”.
A White
House statement issued just before midnight said “this is the behavior of
obstructionist losers, not legislators”.
Democrats
earlier blamed Republican divisions for the failure of the vote. Senator Ron
Wyden, a Democrat from Oregon, said lawmakers from his rival party were not on
the same page as president Donald Trump.
“You’ve got
the three branches of government – everything,” Wyden said. “Can these folks
organize a two-car parade?”
On
Thursday, the House had voted by a margin of 230-197 to advance the bill after
speaker Paul Ryan made concessions to conservative Republicans in the Freedom
Caucus. These included a vote on increased military funding, a potential vote
on a hardline immigration bill and other “subplots”, which Mark Meadows, the
head of the Freedom Caucus, declined to share with reporters. The vote was
almost entirely along party lines, with only six Democrats and 11 Republicans
breaking ranks.
The bill
did not contain any provisions to protect Dreamers, which has been a key
Democratic priority since Donald Trump announced in September that he was
rescinding an Obama-era program, known as Daca. The program enabled young,
undocumented immigrants brought to the US as children to obtain temporary legal
status.
After the
bill passed the House, Ryan preemptively tried to blame Democrats for any
government shutdown, telling reporters: “The only people standing in the way of
keeping the government open are Senate Democrats.”
The Ohio Clock strikes midnight in the Senate,
marking the beginning of the federal shutdown. Photograph: Shawn Thew/EPA
In a final
dash to avert a shutdown, Trump cancelled plans to depart for his Mar-a-lago
resort in Florida, where the president was due to celebrate the anniversary of
his first year in office. Instead, Trump spent the day negotiating with
congressional leaders.
But despite
hosting Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer in the Oval Office on Friday
afternoon, the sides were unable to reach an agreement.
Trump and
Schumer, who both hail from New York, negotiated over cheeseburgers in a small
dining room adjacent to the Oval Office.
A source
briefed on the meeting said Schumer offered not only to meet Trump’s full
funding request for a border wall, but also agreed to boosting defense spending
“far above” what the White House had requested.
In
exchange, Schumer requested a short-term measure that would keep the government
open for just a few days, in the hopes of keeping pressure on lawmakers to
reach a broader compromise. The president even seemed amenable to Schumer’s
approach, the source said, and told the Democratic leader he would broach the
topic with Republican leaders.
But not
long after Schumer returned to the Capitol, he received a phone call from John
Kelly, the White House chief of staff. Kelly, who emerged as an unexpected
hardliner on immigration, informed Schumer the contours of the deal he
discussed with Trump were too liberal.
As
lawmakers scrambled to chart a path forward, progressive activists and Dreamers
held a rally against the illuminated backdrop of the US Capitol. They implored
lawmakers to reject any funding measure that did not include a pathway to
citizenship for the nearly 700,000 Dreamers whose protections will expire in
March barring intervention from Congress.
“For all
those Dreamers out there, our message for each and every one of you: there are
those in our government that see you, that hear you, that believe and know that
this country belongs to you,” said Congressman Joe Kennedy III, a Democrat of
Massachusetts, who repeated the message in Spanish.
Funding for
the government was initially due to expire in September, but lawmakers have
since passed a series of stopgap measures to keep operations running in the
absence of a long-term spending deal.
The last
short-term extension, which was passed in December, pushed the deadline to 19
January while leaving the fate of Dreamers in limbo. Democrats subsequently
faced backlash from immigration advocates and their base for failing to hold
the line on Daca after having vowed not to adjourn for the new year without a
solution.
Trump gave
Congress until 5 March to replace the program. But Democrats have insisted the
only way to resolve the deep partisan divide over immigration is by tying it to
a must-pass bill that would simultaneously avert a shutdown and enshrine
protections for Dreamers into law.
Trump
showed a brief willingness to compromise last week by engaging lawmakers from
both parties on a potential deal to legalize Dreamers in return for beefing up
border security and changes to certain visa programs. But the president
dramatically undermined bipartisan talks by questioning the need to admit
immigrants from places such as Haiti and El Salvador, dismissing them “shithole
countries” in a private meeting with lawmakers.
Republicans
meanwhile chose to move ahead with a short-term bill to fund the government,
arguing that immigration was a separate issue to be dealt with at a later time.
In a bid to apply pressure on Democrats, they also included in their measure a
six-year authorization of the popular child health insurance program (Chip),
which provides healthcare coverage to 9 million children.
With
government shutdown, Republicans reap what they sow
Richard
Wolffe
It takes a
special type of hypocrite to accuse your opponents of hypocrisy for following
in your footsteps
@richardwolffedc
Sat 20 Jan
2018 04.45 GMT Last modified on Sat 20 Jan 2018 06.28 GMT
For
Christian conservatives, Donald Trump may be a sinner but he’s really doing
God’s work.
Today’s
Republican party is built on principle. As a matter of principle, the GOP
believes it is the only party that can shut down government as a negotiating
tactic. The Democrats’ job is to keep that government open and to cave in to
its demands.
These
truths we hold to be self-evident, after watching several rounds of this sad
kabuki theater through the Clinton and Obama years.
Now that
the Democrats have triggered a government shutdown, Republicans are outraged.
Because of their principles, you know.
The
ideologue responsible for Trump’s budget, Mick Mulvaney, put it best to
reporters at the White House on Friday. Mulvaney, now director of the Office of
Management and Budget, was previously a South Carolina congressman. In that
role, he was one of the chief proponents of the last government shutdown
because he opposed Planned Parenthood and Obamacare.
Now he says
the Democrats have no right to do what he did because, well, that would make
them unprincipled.
“Keep in
mind, go back and watch what they said about folks during the 2013 shutdown who
wanted to talk about things like the Obamacare repeal at that time,” he said.
“One of the criticisms they made of folks like me is that I was inserting
non-financial issues into an appropriations process, which is exactly what’s
happening now. So I recognize the fact that Washington does not understand the
meaning of the word hypocrisy and irony. The truth of the matter is they’re
doing the exact same thing they accused the Republicans of doing in 2013.”
Ah yes, the
irony of it all. It takes a special type of hypocrite to accuse your opponents
of hypocrisy for following in your footsteps.
As a matter
of principle, it’s Republicans like Mulvaney who are the deficit hawks, caring
deeply about the fiscal rectitude of the federal government. Right up to the
point when one of them says the words “tax cuts”, which turn out to be far more
important than balancing the budget or the national debt.
Thank
goodness we have the Republicans in total control of Washington, after all
those years of the Democrats failing to pass a real budget. Now we can watch
the Republicans create an even more dysfunctional budget process with
continuing resolutions that last just a few weeks at a time.
This is not
the only principled issue that defines today’s GOP.
As a matter
of principle, Republicans are the party closest to God, rallying the faithful
at the March for Life rally by anti-abortion activists, who also love to rail
against Planned Parenthood. Thank God for the leadership of a conservative
president whose lawyer paid tens of thousands of dollars to a porn star, through
a shell company and false names.
Before she
signed a non-disclosure agreement, the porn star disclosed the sordid details
of her affair with the current president soon after his third wife gave birth
to his third son.
For
Christian conservatives, Donald Trump may be a sinner but he’s really doing
God’s work. That’s a whole new definition of family values right there.
This is the
kind of irony that Republicans ought to understand. After all, the first real
shutdowns of the current era – the shutdown that set the tone for all that
followed – was the product of Newt Gingrich’s war against Bill Clinton. The
1995 and 1996 debacles were ideological clashes over the size of government by
a flame-throwing House Speaker who wanted to cut the president down to size.
That was
the first salvo in a war over family values that led to Clinton’s impeachment
for an affair with an unpaid intern that began during that same shutdown. Of
course Gingrich himself had been unfaithful with another woman for a couple of
years before that shutdown. Callista Bisek became his third wife, and is now
Donald Trump’s ambassador to the Vatican. So there’s no irony or hypocrisy
there at all.
At least
the 1990s shutdowns were about the budget. The next government shutdown in 2013
was simply about defunding Obamacare and destroying Barack Obama. For some Tea
Party-infused Republicans, this was a principled stand. For every Republican
senator other than Ted Cruz, it was madness.
Now Republicans
are perfectly entitled to say Democrats are copying them. We can argue about
whether their principles about Obamacare are more or less important than the
Democratic efforts to stop the deportation of children brought to the country
as undocumented immigrants.
We can
surely all agree that shutdowns are an insane way to manage political disputes
at any time, by any party. Democrats should take no pride in shutting down the
government.
But
Republicans cannot, as a matter of principle, pretend to be outraged that
Democrats are following them. And they cannot, as a matter of political good
sense, pretend like the electoral damage is all going to fall on their
opponents.
Like some
political goldfish swimming in a bowl of amnesia, Republicans have forgotten
they picked up seats in the mid-term elections following their own 2013
shutdown. In fact they picked up control of the Senate, and with it, blocked
everything Obama wanted to do, including his nomination of a supreme court
justice.
The GOP
believes it has set a brilliant trap for Democrats with a cunning ploy of
pretending to care about children’s health insurance. “Who could vote against
children?” says the party that allowed the insurance to lapse in October.
And who
could support the deportation of children? The one thing Republicans didn’t
count on was their own president, whose racist rant about “shithole” countries
blew up a hard-fought bipartisan deal on immigration.
This is a
shithole of the Republicans’ own making. They control all sides of Washington
and have now made history by presiding over their own shutdown, under a
president who prided himself on knowing the art of the deal.
No deal, no
sympathy: polls suggest most voters blame both Trump and the Republicans for
the open sewer that stretches all the way down Pennsylvania Avenue.
During
previous shutdowns, calm heads ultimately prevailed: people who cared about
good government, or at least worried about the polls that pointed to widespread
public disgust. But this is now Donald Trump’s Washington and there are no calm
heads to be found.
As a matter
of principle, Republicans cannot come together to agree a deal on immigration.
As a matter of sanity, Donald Trump cannot stop his racist belching or
surrender the fantasy about his Mexican wall. This shutdown shit-show
could run and run.
Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário