Greece
bailout talks – the main actors in a modern-day epic
The
Syriza-led coalition’s long fight to end years of austerity by
striking a deal with the troika is nearing its end. Here are the main
players of the eurozone crisis
Phillip Inman in
London Ian Traynor in Brussels Helena Smith in Athens
Tuesday 9 June 2015
22.03 BST /
http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/jun/09/greece-bailout-talks-the-main-actors-in-a-modern-day-epic
Greece is almost
entirely friendless as it enters the final phase of talks over a
multibillion-pound rescue deal. The prime minister, Alexis Tsipras,
was elected to end austerity, but he has no money and few allies.
Athens has tried for
the last four months to reverse six years of post-crash austerity
policies while extracting a better deal from the EU – and in the
process has upset almost everybody who might have had the power and
inclination to help.
If Tsipras has any
friends left in the eurozone, they are a diminishing bunch, and to be
found mainly in Brussels rather than in the national capitals.
Sympathy for the radical leftist Syriza-led government, which was
never overwhelming, has shrunk sharply and turned into undisguised
hostility.
Greece owes €320bn
(£234bn) to the European commission, the International Monetary Fund
and the European Central Bank following bailouts in 2010 and 2012.
The troika of lenders insisted on a broad set of reforms and public
spending cuts as the price for the loans under a programme that ran
out in February and was extended until the end of June.
Earlier this week,
world leaders joined their EU counterparts to demand that Athens
accept the need for painful sacrifices to secure further rescue
funds. They hinted that by not agreeing to most of the existing
demands, the economy could go bust and the country bundled out of the
eurozone.
This coordinated
attack by the US president, Barack Obama, the German chancellor,
Angela Merkel, and the French president, François Hollande, revealed
a new resolve to face down the radicals and leftists in Athens.
Tsipras, who leads a
loose collection of socialists, communists and Trotskyists propelled
into office on a wave of anti-austerity feeling, is running out of
options. All the signs are now that he will be forced to accept
during talks over the coming days much of what he rejected only last
weekend as “illogical”.
Last week, Athens
delayed loan payments to the IMF and the Greek leader now has until
the end of the month to negotiate a deal. But all the betting is that
it will come sooner rather than risk a late scramble that in turn
could trigger a bank run and an accidental “Grexit”.
If opinion polls are
to be believed, optimism is waning among the Greeks that Tsipras can
secure a worthwhile compromise. Greeks want an end to austerity while
remaining inside the eurozone. But the other 18 members of the
currency bloc want Athens to accept that it cannot continue with its
bloated public sector and generous pension system if new loans are to
be forthcoming. Not that Syriza’s support has declined since it won
the election in January with 35% of the vote.
It is this shift in
public opinion and a unified front by creditors that prompted Tsipras
to tell Syriza MPs on Tuesday that they must back whatever deal his
negotiators secure. Any sense that the 70 members of the Left
Platform faction within Syriza will vote against a deal is expected
to force Tsipras to call a general election.
The only chink in
the creditors’ resolve can be found in the European commission, the
most dovish part of the troika. The previous commission, in office
until last November, had been marginalised in the eurozone crisis and
treated with contempt by the Germans and the French, which ran
negotiations with Athens.
Jean-Claude Juncker,
the new commission chief, came into office determined to make himself
a player on the Greece crisis and has used the ascent of Syriza to
bolster that aim. The same applied to his monetary affairs
commissioner, Pierre Moscovici, a French socialist, who has
consistently taken a softer line on Greece.
That relationship
has gone sour, however, with Juncker accusing Tsipras at the weekend
of lying to him and reneging on their agreements.
Outside Brussels,
Tsipras has no friends. The frustration with the Greeks has only
grown over the past five months of talks that have rolled full circle
to an impasse.
Eastern European
leaders in Slovakia, Slovenia or the Baltic have become increasingly
critical and more outspoken about the Greeks, disinclined to listen
to Greek complaints of pay cuts and denuded public services when they
have gone through equally wrenching economic reforms themselves.
The conservative
Spanish government of Mariano Rajoy has grown increasingly hostile,
not least because it is running scared of Syriza’s lookalikes,
Podemos, in domestic politics and ahead of elections in November.
Critics of the Greek
negotiating stance have argued that it was naive to believe that –
even though austerity policies had failed to stabilise the economy or
spur growth – mainstream eurozone politicians were likely to make a
U-turn and hand political opponents in Greece a stunning political
victory.
Alexis Tsipras –
the Greek leader
The Greek prime
minister and leader of Syriza. Photograph: Alkis
Konstantinidis/Reuters
He has gone back on
almost every promise he made but even now Greece’s youngest premier
remains extraordinarily popular.
The robust defence
of Greece that his leftist-led government has put up since assuming
power in January has restored a sense of pride at a time of
extraordinary humiliation for the population.
A civil engineering
student who spent much of his college years organising sit-ins, the
Greek prime minister is variously referred to by his friends as
charming, charismatic and visionary. He plays good cop while his
emissary, the finance minister Yanis Varoufakis, plays the bad boy.
The leader’s demagogic skills – and canniness on the political
stage – are such that even opponents acknowledge he has made the
best of a weak hand.
The young leader has
managed to pull off the extraordinary feat of cosying up to the
German chancellor, Angela Merkel, while accusing creditors of seeking
a new deal that is “illogical” and “absurd”.
Panagiotis Lafazanis
– the Greek rebel
Panagiotis Lafazanis
Pro-Russian,
anti-capitalist and with a penchant for incendiary rhetoric,
Lafazanis is widely perceived as Alexis Tsipras’s greatest foe
domestically.
As head of Syriza’s
radical Left Platform, the 63-year-old hardliner rails frequently
against the ills of neoliberalism and capitalism itself.
Although he has
softened his view on a euro exit – adopting, if hesitantly, the
party’s official stance that Athens must remain in the single
currency – he has stepped up criticism of lenders, whom he has
accused of trying to “tear Greece apart”. Ideologically
unyielding, unpredictable and testy, Lafazanis, who is also energy
minister – is likely to become more vocal in his opposition to
policies being demanded of Greece.
When it comes to a
vote in parliament on a compromise deal, there is speculation that he
will lead a revolt, forcing Tsipras to rely on moderate and rightwing
parties to secure victory. Which is why Tsipras is considering a
general election as a better way to keep his party together and
resolve the dispute with Brussels.
Yanis Varoufakis –
the Greek finance minister
Academic-turned
politician Yanis Varoufakis. Photograph: Yannis Kolesidis/EPA
Just when everyone
thought Greece’s maverick finance minister had been sidelined for
good, Varoufakis is back, appearing as the public face of the
anti-austerity government abroad.
The rhetoric has
been toned down – along with the dress code: he now leans more
towards sombre suits than leather jacket. The Athens rumour mill says
Tsipras is enormously dependent on the academic-turned politician –
without doubt the government’s most prominent public intellectual.
The 54-year-old has
exerted considerable influence on reining in Tsipras – and changing
his views on the perils of eurozone exit. His purported expression of
support for “70% of the [troika’s] reform proposals” has earned
him enemies in Syriza – a party he does not officially belong to.
In talks with
eurozone finance ministers and Brussels officials, tolerance has worn
thin over his penchant for interminable lectures on the nature of
capitalism and Europe’s mistaken austerity experiment. Far from
capitulating to a mix of charm and Keynesian economic theory,
Brussels has stuck to its line: austerity is the only way.
Manolis Glezos –
the Greek conscience
At 93, he is by far
Europe’s oldest MP, but age has not daunted Glezos nor his status
as a legendary figurehead of the left.
After playing a
seminal role in Tsipras’s political coming-of-age, the second world
war hero who shot to fame tearing down the swastika from the
Acropolis has led the cry of resistance to austerity in the European
parliament.
Universally
respected, Glezos has openly criticised Syriza for making concessions
– criticism that is bound to get louder in the weeks ahead.
If the governing
party strays too far from its pre-electoral mandate the sprightly
white-haired nonagenarian will rally dissidents.
Yannis Dragasakis –
the righthand man
The deputy prime
minister, Yannis Dragasakis. Photograph: Aris Messinis/AFP/Getty
Images
A former Communist
party MP, Dragasakis, 67, is the only minister to have previous
experience in government. Outwardly mild-mannered, he hides a steely
demeanour that should not be mistaken for capitulation.
As deputy PM and the
politician overseeing economic policy, this low-key player is the
point man in negotiations with creditors.
Although he believes
that Greece has been stripped of its sovereignty after five years of
stewardship under the EU and IMF, Dragasakis is the man who pulls the
strings behind the scenes.
A blackboard,
depicting the (shifting) relationships between the various
negotiating teams, has pride of place in his office.
Euclid Tsakalotos –
the negotiator
Courteous and
courtly, the British-educated Tsakalotos has won plaudits for taking
the heat out of negotiations since becoming chief coordinator. Many
see him as the perfect antidote to the outspoken Varoufakis.
But, Tsakalotos, who
studied economics at Oxford and has written several books, is not
willing to compromise on what he regards as the “irrational”
demands of creditors.
A stickler for
detail, the economics professor regards austerity as the breeding
ground for the centrifugal forces that “in a straight re-run of the
1930s” could, he fears, tear Europe apart.
He leads the talks
with state minister Nikos Pappas, who is a close ally of Tsipras.
Panos Kammenos –
the coalition partner
Leader of the
Independent Greeks, Syriza’s coalition partners, Panos Kammenos is
a renowned populist.
Anti-euro,
anti-immigration and anti-German, one of his hobby horses is the need
for Berlin to pay war reparations. Only last week a parliamentary
committee backed claims that Germany should pay €279bn (£205bn)
compensation for Nazi war atrocities.
A former deputy
shipping minister who broke away from the New Democracy party of the
former prime minister Antonis Samaras in 2012, he has described the
2010 and 2012 financial bailouts as reducing Greece to the status of
a debt colony.
The Acropolis
A symbol of the
country’s glorious past and of modern democracy, the Acropolis
gives the Greek negotiating position huge moral strength. How,
pro-Europeans ask, could Greece be ejected from the federalist single
currency project and the eurozone still claim to be indivisible.
The eurozone’s
image and its cohesion would be irreparably damaged should the
Acropolis come to represent the failure of EU institutions and not
their success, say many observers.
Tsipras and
Varoufakis have always aimed for a political deal born of a deep
reluctance among the Brussels elite for letting go one of their
children, even if Athens currently suffers from an oppositional
disorder.
The Greek people
A general election
is looming in Greece only six months after the last one as the new
government in Athens is confronted by declining optimism in its
ability to secure a good deal.
In April a large
majority of Greeks wanted Athens to reach a compromise deal with its
foreign lenders to avoid being forced out of the eurozone. A poll
found that 72% wanted an agreement with Greece’s creditors, against
23% who said the government should refuse any compromise. A month
later and support for a compromise had plummeted to 45%.
But 75% still wanted
to stay in the eurozone, while almost two in five support early
elections to resolve the standoff over the cash-for-reforms deal.
IMF/Brussels staff
Plenty of senior
insiders have quietly voiced support for the Greek negotiating
position while rejecting the bull-in-a-china-shop negotiating
tactics.
Mostly, they concede
that economic arguments put by Varoufakis – that austerity has made
the situation worse and reforms will take time – are largely valid.
In April, Poul
Thomsen, head of the IMF’s European department, became one of the
few to openly voice his discontent at the stance taken by European
finance ministers, who he said should reduce and simplify their
demands on Greece.
Angela Merkel
Until recently the
German leader followed the hard line established by her finance
minister, Wolfgang Schäuble.
Now she stands
accused of wavering in her resolve. Her critics suggest thather
search for a peace deal with the radical leftists running Greece
could be intended to be part of establishing a legacy.
Alongside the
potential division of Ukraine and the possibility of Britain quitting
the European Union, a Grexit is something that must be averted to
preserve her reputation as one of Germany’s great chancellors.
President Barack
Obama
The US has hardened
its attitude to Greece over recent months. In February US Treasury
staff were berating Brussels for failing to make concessions and wrap
up a deal.
Officials, concerned
that jitters on international money markets would undermine business
confidence and hit exports, were desperate for European policymakers
to end austerity.
Lately, the US has
blamed Athens for much of the delay. In April, Obama met Varoufakis
and brusquely informed him that he needed to stop lecturing Brussels
and sign a deal.
At the G7 summit on
Monday, Obama said the Greeks needed to make sacrifices, “not only
to satisfy creditors, but also to create a platform where the Greek
economy can start growing again and prospering”.
He then gave Athens
a clear nudge: “The Greeks are going to have to follow through and
take some tough political choices that are going to be good in the
long term.”
Enda Kenny
The Irish prime
minister was considered a natural ally by Varoufakis as he entered
talks with Brussels back in February.
Ireland was one of
the three bust eurozone countries, with Portugal, to agree an EU/IMF
rescue deal and remains buried under a mountain of debt. But unlike
Greece, the centre-right coalition led by Kenny has secured a
sustained period of growth, mostly through higher exports.
Like Spain and
Portugal, Ireland’s ruling coalition fears a Syriza-style challenge
from the left.
In the Republic that
means Sinn Féin. In Spain, which continues to suffer high
unemployment and huge private indebtedness, Podemos is a challenger
in November elections.
Jeroen Dijsselbloem
The Dutch finance
minister, who made the mistake of travelling to Athens shortly after
Tsipras took power only to be lambasted by Varoufakis, has a deep
antipathy to the Syriza plan to reschedule, or if possible write
down, its debts.
That first meeting
with Varoufakis framed Dijsselbloem’s hostility, which has never
faded, although he is now more circumspect about articulating it. A
mild-mannered Labour MP, he was transformed into a hardliner seeking
detailed commitments from Athens for reform.
Wolfgang Schäuble
The German finance
minister and prominent Christian Democrat has worn his political
colours on his sleeve, objecting to virtually all concessions to the
new Greek government.
Recently he accused
the prime minister, Alexis Tsipras, of mendacity and reiterated that
Greece’s debt problems lay squarely with the fact that the
Mediterranean nation had lived far beyond its means.
At the time he said:
“The new Greek government has totally destroyed the trust of its
European partners … this is a serious setback.”
An architect of
German reunification, the veteran eurocrat has begun to appear more
relaxed as Varoufakis has upset one euro finance minister after
another, consolidating the German position that Greece must stick to
the austerity plan.
Jean-Claude Juncker
A peripheral figure
during debt talks with Greece only a few months ago, the calm and
diplomatic Juncker has moved centre stage.
To use a football
analogy, he was given the task during the G7 conference in Dresden of
man-marking Tsipras. And as any defender will tell you, man-marking
is a frustrating occupation. On Sunday Juncker was visibly angry.
He was told to
expect a redrafted compromise memo from Athens. He said: “Alexis
Tsipras promised that by Thursday evening he would present a second
proposal. Then he said he would present it on Friday.
“And then he said
he would call on Saturday. But I have never received that proposal,
so I hope I will receive it soon. I would like to have that Greek
proposal.”
The former prime
minister of Luxembourg is sure to be all smiles when Tsipras returns
to the negotiating table, though he is unlikely to be handed a
revised draft until near the end of the month.
Christine Lagarde
The boss of the IMF
has appeared to flip-flop lately after a return to espousing
neoliberal policies of labour market reform and privatisations as a
means to rebuilding the Greek government’s finances.
Only a few months
ago she adopted a more conciliatory tone, scaling down the demands
made on Athens and talking up an extension of the current bailout.
As one of three
major lenders, the organisation has admitted it made a major mistake
when Greece defaulted for a second time in 2012, when it replaced
Athens’ private-sector borrowing with its own loans, pushing up the
overall debt burden.
Mario Draghi
The attitude of the
president of the European Central Bank was partly formed by the way
his officials were treated in Athens.
At a late-night
session in Brussels a couple of months ago, he read Tsipras the riot
act, demanding respect and cooperation after his team in Athens was
confined to its hotel, refused access to Greek ministries, and
required bodyguards when faced with aggressive protesters.
More recently, in
his capacity as head of one third of the troika of lenders, he has
supplied Greek banks with much-needed loans to prevent them falling
over while talks continue.
Vladimir Putin
It is only a couple
of weeks since the Russian president took yet another opportunity to
foment unrest inside the eurozone by promising a better life for
Greece outside the eurozone.
He welcomed Tsipras
to Moscow a few weeks ago and hinted at aid for Greece should it
leave the currency union.
He has a war chest
from years of oil tax receipts and would be happy to offer guarantees
and loans for a deal that would upset Berlin and Washington, despite
a domestic recession and the clamour from struggling state
enterprises for extra cash.
Greece is also a key
Nato member and has a large army, which Putin would enjoy drawing
closer to his sphere of influence.
There are also ties
via Cyprus, where Russian oligarchs stashed large sums of cash and
then found themselves vulnerable when the island declared itself
bust.
Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário