Trump’s Trial Features Fierce Debate Over What He
Can Say: 5 Takeaways
Donald J. Trump’s lawyer was harshly questioned as he
tried to avoid a contempt citation. And a publisher testified about how he put
The National Enquirer to work for Mr. Trump’s campaign.
Jesse
McKinley Kate Christobek
By Jesse
McKinley and Kate Christobek
April 23,
2024
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/23/nyregion/trump-trial-takeaways-pecker-gag-order.html
Tuesday’s
session of Donald J. Trump’s criminal trial began with a heated clash between
Justice Juan M. Merchan and Mr. Trump’s lead lawyer over a gag order. It ended
with an insider’s look into a tabloid newspaper practice known as “catch and
kill.”
Prosecutors
said that Mr. Trump had “willfully and blatantly” violated a gag order barring
him from attacking jurors and witnesses, among others. They said he had done so
in comments outside the courtroom and online and should be found in contempt of
court.
Mr. Trump’s
top lawyer said in response that Mr. Trump was simply defending himself from
political attacks. Justice Merchan did not rule, but he scolded the lawyer,
Todd Blanche, saying, “you’re losing all credibility with the court.”
A former
ally of Mr. Trump, David Pecker, the ex-publisher of The National Enquirer,
later testified to buying and burying unflattering stories about Mr. Trump
during his 2016 run for president, an arrangement he called “highly, highly
confidential.”
Mr. Trump,
77, faces 34 felony counts of falsifying business records to hide a payment to
a porn star, Stormy Daniels, made to cover up a sex scandal that threatened to
derail his campaign. Ms. Daniels, who may testify, has said that she and Mr.
Trump had a brief sexual encounter in 2006, something the former president
denies.
Mr. Trump
has pleaded not guilty. If convicted, the former president — and presumptive
Republican nominee — could face probation or up to four years in prison.
A historic
trial begins. Donald Trump, who faces 34 felony counts of falsifying business
records in the first degree to cover up a sex scandal, is on trial in
Manhattan. He is the first former U.S. president to be criminally prosecuted.
Here are answers to some key questions about the case:
What is
Trump accused of? The charges trace back to a $130,000 hush-money payment that
Trump’s fixer, Michael Cohen, made to the porn actress Stormy Daniels in 2016
to suppress her story of a sexual liaison with Trump in 2006. While serving as
president, Trump reimbursed Cohen, and how he did so constituted fraud,
prosecutors say.
Why did
prosecutors cite other hush-money payments? Although the charges relate to the
payment to Daniels, Alvin Bragg, the Manhattan district attorney, is expected
to highlight two other hush-money deals. Prosecutors say that the deals show
that Trump had orchestrated a wide-ranging scheme to influence the 2016
presidential election.
Who will
the key witnesses be? Cohen is expected to be a crucial witness for
prosecutors. Bragg is also expected to call David Pecker, the former publisher
of The National Enquirer, as well as Hope Hicks, a former Trump aide, to shed
light on the tumultuous period surrounding the payments. Trump said he plans to
testify in his own defense.
Who is the
judge? Juan Merchan, the judge, is a veteran of the bench known as a
no-nonsense, drama-averse jurist. During the trial, Justice Merchan will be in
charge of keeping order in the courtroom and ruling on objections made by
prosecutors and Trump’s lawyers. The jury will decide whether Trump is guilty.
What
happens if Trump is convicted? The charges against Trump are all Class E
felonies, the least severe felony category in New York. If convicted, Trump
faces a prison sentence of four years or less, or he could receive probation.
How is The
New York Times covering the trial? The Times will provide comprehensive
coverage of the trial, which is set to last six to eight weeks. Expect live
updates from the courtroom in Manhattan, daily takeaways, explainers and
analysis from our reporting team.
Here are five takeaways from Mr. Trump’s sixth
day on trial:
Pecker describes “catch-and-kill.”
Taking the
stand for a second day, Mr. Pecker outlined a decades-old friendship with Mr.
Trump, a relationship that he said deepened in 2015.
It was
then, Mr. Pecker said, that he, Mr. Trump and Michael D. Cohen, Mr. Trump’s
former lawyer and fixer, met at Trump Tower in Manhattan to hatch a plan to
write promotional stories about Mr. Trump and negative stories about his
political opponents.
Mr. Pecker
said he acted as the campaign’s “eyes and ears,” notifying Mr. Cohen about
possible scandals, particularly regarding women in Mr. Trump’s life.
Mr. Pecker
on Tuesday walked through one of the “catch-and-kill” deals. He said that The
National Enquirer learned that a doorman who had worked at a Trump building was
looking to sell a story about Mr. Trump fathering a child out of wedlock. The
tabloid discovered that the story was apparently false, but paid $30,000
anyway, “because of the potential embarrassment” it could have caused Mr.
Trump, Mr. Pecker said.
Who Are Key
Players in the Trump Manhattan Criminal Trial?
The first
criminal trial of former President Donald J. Trump is underway. Take a closer
look at central figures related to the case.
Pecker paints a portrait of a bygone era.
Mr.
Pecker’s testimony depicted an anachronistic New York, with landlines, powerful
supermarket tabloids and must-see network television, including “The
Apprentice,” which made Mr. Trump nationally famous.
It also
shed light on Mr. Pecker’s editorial tactics, including getting tips from Mr.
Trump about who was getting kicked off “The Apprentice,” in line with Mr.
Trump’s penchant for feeding dirt to tabloids.
Mr. Pecker
said that he called Mr. Trump “Donald,” and that they had “a great
relationship,” adding that he went so far as to start a magazine called Trump
Style. When he proposed the magazine, Mr. Pecker said, Mr. Trump’s biggest
question was, “Who’s going to pay for it?”
Trump’s short leash could get shorter.
Christopher
Conroy, a prosecutor with the Manhattan district attorney’s office, argued that
Mr. Trump had repeatedly violated the gag order that the court imposed on him.
One alleged violation included a nine-minute diatribe outside the courtroom on
Monday during which he attacked Michael Cohen, his former fixer and a key
witness against him.
“He did it
right here,” Mr. Conroy said.
But Mr.
Blanche said that the former president was “facing a barrage of political
attacks” from several potential witnesses and needed to strike back.
“He’s
running for president,” Mr. Blanche said. “He has to be able to respond to
that.”
Justice
Merchan has chastised Trump once so far, for muttering in front of a
prospective juror. If he holds him in criminal contempt, it will mark a serious
escalation. For their part, prosecutors said they were not seeking to jail Mr.
Trump, but wanted him to be fined.
A frustrated Trump
Mr. Trump
sat stoically while prosecutors argued that he violated the gag order. But he
grew animated during the interplay between Mr. Blanche and Justice Merchan. On
several occasions, the former president sharply turned to his other lawyers and
whispered.
When Mr.
Blanche finished his argument, Mr. Trump immediately beckoned him over before
he snatched a piece of paper off the defense table.
Mr. Trump
posted on Truth Social right after the hearing, accusing Justice Merchan of
taking away his “right to free speech” and claiming that he was “not allowed to
defend myself.”
Thursday will be a big day for Trump in two courts.
Court is
not in session on Wednesday, but prosecutors will continue their direct
examination of Mr. Pecker on Thursday.
While Mr.
Trump is expected to be in court in Manhattan that day, he may be a little
preoccupied: In Washington, some of his other lawyers will be arguing in front
of the Supreme Court that Mr. Trump should receive presidential immunity from
prosecution in a federal election interference case.
Mr. Trump
had sought to take a day away from his New York case to watch those arguments,
but Justice Merchan denied his request.
Jesse
McKinley is a Times reporter covering upstate New York, courts and politics.
More about Jesse McKinley
Kate
Christobek is a reporter covering the civil and criminal cases against former
president Donald J. Trump for The Times. More about Kate
Christobek
Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário