Young
Aides Emerge as Enforcers in Musk’s Broadside Against Government
Much of the
billionaire’s handiwork — gaining access to internal systems and asking
employees to justify their jobs — is being driven by a group of engineers
operating in secrecy.
By Theodore
SchleiferNicholas NehamasKate Conger and Ryan Mac
Feb. 7, 2025
Updated 4:07
p.m. ET
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/07/us/politics/musk-doge-aides.html
At the end
of his third week bulldozing through the federal government, Elon Musk sat down
to give Vice President JD Vance a 90-minute briefing on his efforts to
dismantle the bureaucracy. Mr. Musk was not alone.
Invited to
join him on Thursday morning in Mr. Vance’s stately ceremonial office suite in
the Eisenhower Executive Office Building, next to the White House, were a
clutch of young aides whose presence at federal agencies has served as a
harbinger of the upheaval that would follow them.
Across the
federal government, civil servants have witnessed the sudden intrusion in the
last two weeks of these young members of the billionaire’s team, labeled the
Department of Government Efficiency. As Mr. Musk traipses through Washington,
bent on disruption, these aides have emerged as his enforcers, sweeping into
agency headquarters with black backpacks and ambitious marching orders.
While Mr.
Musk is flanked by some seasoned operatives, his dizzying blitz on the federal
bureaucracy is, in practice, largely being carried out by a group of male
engineers, including some recent college graduates and at least one as young as
19.
Unlike their
20-something peers in Washington, who are accustomed to doing the unglamorous
work ordered up by senior officials, these aides have been empowered to break
the system.
Of the
roughly 40 people on the team, just under half of them have some previous ties
to the billionaire — but many have little government experience, The New York
Times found. This account of their background and activities is based on public
records, internal government databases and more than 20 people familiar with
their roles, who spoke on the condition of anonymity out of fear of
retaliation.
Some on the
Musk team are former interns at his companies. Others are executives who have
served in his employ for as long as two decades. They all appear to have
channeled his shoot-first, aim-later approach to reform as they have
overwhelmed the bureaucracy.
A
23-year-old who once used artificial intelligence to decode the word “purple”
on an Ancient Greek scroll has swiftly gained entree to at least five federal
agencies, including the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, where he
has been seeking access to sensitive databases. He was part of a group that
helped effectively shutter the United States Agency for International
Development, joined by the 19-year-old, a onetime Northeastern student who has
worked at Neuralink, Mr. Musk’s brain-implant startup, according to an archived
version of his LinkedIn profile.
In the past
week, his aides have descended upon the Education, Housing and Urban
Development, Health and Human Services, and Veterans Affairs Departments, along
with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the Federal Emergency
Management Agency and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, according to
people familiar with their activities.
Mr. Musk has
praised his team as talented and relentless, defending its work as crucial to
rooting out what he perceives as wasteful spending and left-wing ideology in
the federal government.
“Time to
confess,” he wrote on X this week. “Media reports saying that @DOGE has some of
world’s best software engineers are in fact true.”
Mr. Musk did
not respond to a request for comment.
On Friday,
Mr. Trump told reporters that he was “very proud of the job that this group of
young people, generally young people, but very smart people, they’re doing.
“They’re
doing it at my insistence,” he added. “It would be a lot easier not to do it,
but we have to take some of these things apart to find the corruption.”
Even as Mr.
Musk’s team members upend the government, their identities have been closely
held, emerging only piecemeal when the new arrivals press career officials for
information and access to agency systems.
The opacity
with which they are operating is highly unusual for those working in
government. Aside from those conducting classified or intelligence work, the
names of public employees are not generally kept secret.
Harrison
Fields, a White House spokesman, said the cost-cutting team has gone through
the same vetting as other federal employees, but declined to say what the
vetting consisted of or whether Mr. Musk’s aides have security clearances.
The Times
identified members of Mr. Musk’s initiative through internal emails identifying
their roles and interviews with employees across the government who have
interacted with them. None of the Musk aides responded to requests for comment.
The secrecy,
Musk allies have said, is necessary so the team members do not become targets.
Several of
Mr. Musk’s aides have resisted being listed in government databases out of fear
of their names leaking out, according to people familiar with the situation.
Others have worked to remove information about themselves from the internet,
scrubbing résumés and social media accounts.
When their
names have been made public by news organizations such as Wired, they have been
scrutinized by online sleuths. Mr. Musk has asserted, falsely, that the
exposure of their roles is a “crime,” and X has removed some posts and issued
suspensions to those who publicize their identities.
One Musk
aide whose name surfaced, Marko Elez, a 25-year-old former employee of X,
resigned on Thursday, according to a White House official, after The Wall
Street Journal revealed that he had made racists posts on X, writing in one
message that “you could not pay me to marry outside of my ethnicity.” Mr. Elez,
a former employee at both X and xAI, Mr. Musk’s artificial intelligence
company, was one of two staff members affiliated with Mr. Musk’s team who had
gained access to the Treasury Department’s closely held payment system.
Mr. Elez was
among those who had been invited to attend Mr. Musk’s meeting with the vice
president before he resigned, according to documents seen by The Times. On
Friday, Mr. Musk called for The Journal reporter to be fired and said he was
reinstating Mr. Elez, a move that both the president and the vice president
said they supported. “We shouldn’t reward journalists who try to destroy
people,” Mr. Vance posted on X.
A spokesman
for Mr. Vance declined to comment.
Some of Mr.
Musk’s top advisers are more seasoned. Senior players include Brad Smith, a
health care entrepreneur and an official during President Trump’s first term;
Amy Gleason, a former U.S. Digital Service official who has been helping at the
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services; and Chris Young, a top Republican
field operative whom Mr. Musk hired as a political adviser last year. Others
bring extensive private sector backgrounds, including from firms like McKinsey
and Morgan Stanley.
But
Washington is a town where much is run by twentysomethings. And much of Mr.
Musk’s handiwork — gutting federal websites, demanding access to internal
systems, sending late-night all-staff emails and asking veteran employees to
justify their jobs — is being executed by young aides, some of them pulling
all-nighters as they burrow into agencies.
Last week,
young representatives of Mr. Musk’s team with backpacks stuffed with a
half-dozen laptops and phones arrived at the headquarters of U.S.A.I.D.,
demanding access to financial and personnel records. On Friday, a dozen stayed
into the night, powered by a bulk order of coffee. The next day, the agency’s
website went dark.
At the
Education Department alone, as many as 16 team members are listed in an
employee directory, including Jehn Balajadia, who has effectively served as Mr.
Musk’s assistant for years.
At the
Office of Personnel Management, the nerve center of the federal government’s
human resources operation, a small group of coders on Mr. Musk’s team sometimes
sleep in the building overnight. They survive on deliveries of pizza, Mountain
Dew, Red Bull and Doritos, working what Mr. Musk has described as 120-hour
weeks.
At the
General Services Administration, another central hub for Mr. Musk’s aides, beds
have been installed on the sixth floor, with a security guard keeping people
from entering the area.
While most
senior employees wear suits, the aides favor jeans, sneakers and T-shirts,
sometimes under a blazer, with one sporting a navy-blue baseball cap with white
lettering reading “DOGE.”
The culture
clash is evident. Perhaps unsurprisingly, career employees who have worked for
decades in the government have bristled at taking orders from the young
newcomers. One coder has openly referred to federal workers as “dinosaurs.”
Some staff members at the personnel office, in turn, derisively call the young
men “Muskrats.”
As they
assess the workings of the government, Mr. Musk’s aides have been conducting
15-minute video interviews with federal workers. Some of their questions have
been pointed, such as querying employees about whom they would choose to fire
from their teams if they had to pick one person. At times, the aides have not
turned on their cameras or given their last names, feeding suspicion.
In one video
interview heard by The Times, a young team representative who introduced
himself by his first name said he was an “adviser” to government leadership and
a startup founder. He pressed the interviewee to describe their contributions
with “highest impact” and to list any technical “superpowers.”
It is not
always clear which employees are formally part of the team. Even the putative
head of the department, Steve Davis, a decades-long lieutenant of Mr. Musk who
has accompanied the billionaire on his meetings in Washington, has not been
formally announced.
Many of Mr.
Musk’s aides, including Mr. Davis, hold multiple roles simultaneously, working
for one of the team’s central hubs — the personnel office or the General
Services Administration — while also maintaining email addresses and offices at
other agencies.
Luke
Farritor, who won the award for using artificial intelligence to decipher an
ancient scroll, joined Mr. Musk’s initiative after dropping out of the
University of Nebraska-Lincoln to pursue a fellowship funded by the billionaire
PayPal founder Peter Thiel. A former SpaceX intern, Mr. Farritor, in
preparation to join the team, started learning COBOL, a coding language
considered retrograde in Silicon Valley but common in government.
He and
Rachel Riley, a former McKinsey consultant who works closely with Mr. Smith,
are now both listed as employees in the Office of the Secretary at the
Department of Health and Human Services. This week, they requested access to
payment systems at the Medicare agency, according to a document seen by The
Times.
Mr.
Farritor, who also has email accounts at the General Services Administration,
the Education Department and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
was at the Energy Department on Wednesday, and has told others that he is
getting deployed to additional agencies. He is one of about a half-dozen aides
who are holed up in a corner around the G.S.A. administrator’s offices,
interviewing tech staff members about their work.
Other
figures often on hand include Ethan Shaotran and Edward Coristine, who have
been accompanying a top Musk ally, Thomas Shedd, who oversees the agency’s tech
division. Mr. Shaotran, a 22-year-old Harvard student, was part of a team that
was the runner-up in a hackathon competition run by xAI last year.
Mr.
Coristine, 19, graduated from high school in Rye, N.Y., last year, according to
a school magazine that noted his outstanding performance on the Advanced
Placement exams. Nowadays, he has an email address at the Education Department.
One Musk
acolyte has leaned into his new status as a Washington celebrity.
Gavin
Kliger, a newly minted senior adviser at the personnel office, wrote a Substack
post this week titled “Why DOGE: Why I gave up a seven-figure salary to save
America” — and asked users to pay a $1,000-per-month subscription fee to read
it.
The post
behind the paywall appeared to have been left intentionally blank, according to
users who saw it.
Mr. Kliger,
25, a software engineer, amplified a message posted on X in December by Nick
Fuentes, one of the country’s most prominent young white supremacists, which
mocked those who celebrate their interracial families. The post was removed
from Mr. Kliger’s page after The Times inquired about it. He did not respond to
requests for comment.
Mr. Kliger
and Mr. Farritor were among those who obtained access to U.S.A.I.D. websites
and tried to get into a secure area at the agency before being turned away by
security last week, according to people familiar with the matter. After
midnight on Monday, Mr. Kliger sent an email from a U.S.A.I.D. email account
informing thousands of staff members that the agency’s headquarters would be
closed.
On X, Mr.
Kliger has defended cuts to the agency. He also responded to one person who
criticized him as “one of the men carrying out Musk’s coup.”
“A ‘coup’ is
when a duly elected president wins a democratic election and delivers on
campaign promises,” Mr. Kliger wrote on X on Monday. “Got it.”
Reporting
was contributed by Maggie Haberman, Mattathias Schwartz, Edward Wong, Erica L.
Green, Madeleine Ngo, Zach Montague, Christopher Flavelle, Andrew Duehren, Brad
Plumer, Kellen Browning and Aric Toler. Kitty Bennett contributed research.
Theodore
Schleifer is a Times reporter covering billionaires and their impact on the
world. More about Theodore Schleifer
Nicholas
Nehamas is a Times political reporter covering the presidential campaign of
Vice President Kamala Harris. More about Nicholas Nehamas
Kate Conger
is a technology reporter based in San Francisco. She can be reached at
kate.conger@nytimes.com. More about Kate Conger
Ryan Mac
covers corporate accountability across the global technology industry. More
about Ryan Mac
Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário