America shuts down again -- choosing reality over
Trump's false claims
Stephen
Collinson Profile
Analysis by
Stephen Collinson, CNN
Updated
0439 GMT (1239 HKT) July 14, 2020
(CNN)While
President Donald Trump obsesses about his reelection hopes in his White House
bubble, state and local leaders are frantically reversing state reopenings that
he demanded, which turned America into the world's biggest coronavirus hotspot.
As
emergency rooms filled and the virus quickened its relentless march across
southern and Western states, Trump stuck to the fiction that the worst is
already over: "We had to close it down; now we're opening it up," the
President said of the economy at the White House, patting himself on the back
for saving "millions of lives."
As new
cases of the disease reach 60,000 a day nationwide, many leaders, including
those who supported Trump's aggressive approach, now have little choice but to
prioritize science over politics, leaving the President looking out of touch
with reality.
In Texas,
Houston's Democratic Mayor Sylvester Turner proposed a two-week shutdown, days
after Republican Gov. Greg Abbott raised the possibility of more stringent
measures after issuing a mask wearing mandate that offended conservative
orthodoxy. West Virginia called time's up in bars in the worst-hit county.
In California,
Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom ordered the closure of all indoor restaurants,
wineries, movie theaters, zoos, museums and shut all bars. Los Angeles and San
Diego said their kids would start the new school year online only. Oregon
banned gatherings of more than 10 people inside because of an "alarming
rise" of Covid-19 cases in the state. KFC encouraged franchises in
Florida, Texas, Oklahoma and California to stop dine-in service.
Florida,
which on Saturday set the record for any state in single day data on new
infections, now has more Covid-19 cases than all but eight entire countries.
The picture
is of a nation that is beginning to shut down again in defiance of the
President's triumphant but misleading claims that a "transition to
greatness" is under way. Restrictions imposed on cities as large as
Houston and Los Angeles could set back the surprising revival in the economy
last month.
Modest job
gains, trumpeted by the President, could turn into permanent job losses.
In remarks
likely to further infuriate Trump, who is grousing about Dr. Anthony Fauci's
press, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious
Diseases made what is unfortunately becoming an obvious point: fast openings
have triggered a disaster.
"It is
very clear -- and we know this from countries throughout the world -- that if
you physically separate people, to the point of not allowing the virus to
transmit ... we know that we can do that if we shut down," Fauci said on a
Stanford School of Medicine webinar.
"We
did not shut down entirely -- and that's the reason why, when we went up, we
started to come down, and then we plateaued at a level that was really quite
high -- about 20,000 infections a day," Fauci said. "Then, as we
started to reopen, we're seeing the surges that we're seeing today, as we
speak, in California ... in Arizona, in Texas, in Florida, and in several other
states."
There are a
few bright spots. For the first time in months, there were no Covid-19 deaths
in New York City in a 24-hour period, a moment of deliverance that Democratic
Mayor Bill de Blasio called "striking and moving." Massachusetts
announced that its seven-day average of positive tests had fallen to 1.7% --
down 94% since mid-April.
The lesson
for the states now in the center of the storm -- that jumped ahead of the US
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidelines on safe reopening -- are
sobering. New York and Massachusetts bought what may still be only a temporary
truce with the coronavirus by weeks of lockdowns and a strict reopening process
that waited for the curve of infections to be properly suppressed before
restrictions were lifted. Even now, there's no guarantee the virus won't return
at dangerous levels when normal life picks up.
None of
this seems to have filtered through to Trump. As always, the President was
fixated on what latest developments meant for him -- especially as he rammed
home his demand for all children to get back to school despite having no plan
for how to make their return safe.
In a fresh
sign of self-absorption on Monday, he turned perhaps the most acute current
social complication of the pandemic into a charge that his political enemies
wanted to keep kids stuck at home to hurt him.
"I
think they think they'll do better if they can keep the schools closed in the
election. I don't think it's going to help them, frankly, but I think they feel
that by keeping schools closed, that's a bad thing for the country and,
therefore, that's a good thing for them," Trump said.
What really matters for Trump
The
President did something similar earlier in the day, when he highlighted a tweet
by Chuck Woolery, the ex-host of dating show "Love Connection" who
warned "everyone is lying" about the seriousness of the current
crisis, just to "keep the "economy from coming back, which is about
the election."
It's not at
all clear that most Americans stuck in an endless national nightmare are most
concerned about an election -- especially one that's faded into the background
and is still more than three months away. Parents want to know if their kids
can begin learning again. The unemployed want their jobs back. The country
wants its pre-virus life back.
Trump's
obsession with his own political prospects has been the driving force of his
administration and is a recurrent theme. His domestic agenda is almost solely
designed to reward his most loyal and radical voters and his foreign policy is
geared to creating splashy photo ops with the President in the starring role.
It's an
Achilles' heel that led him to the ignominy of becoming only the third
President to be impeached, for abusing his power by trying to coerce a foreign
nation -- Ukraine -- into interfering in the 2020 to damage his opponent.
But now
it's possible that as he trails Biden in pre-election polls, the President's
impatience to get the economy roaring again may turn into a fatal political
flaw. And it's got the potential to doom his dreams of a second term since it
made the situation much worse.
The
reopening of schools is crucial to the return of the economy and to the
impression that America has bounced back to normal life that Trump is trying to
reshape into an election message of a "transition to greatness."
Until kids are in school full-time, many parents with child care issues cannot
return to work, depriving America's economic engine of its full capacity.
But
characteristically, Trump is ignoring complicated questions -- such as how to
ensure that a mass return to school doesn't supercharge the pandemic -- as he
considers what's best for himself.
Asked on
Monday what he thought about New York and Los Angeles delaying the start of a
new school year and the death of an Arizona teacher who died from Covid-19
after teaching at summer school, Trump replied: "Yeah. Schools should be
opened. Schools should be opened. ... You're losing a lot of lives by keeping
things closed."
Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário