" Le
carnaval, disait Goethe en parcourant les rues de Rome, est une fête que le
peuple se donne à lui-même". Un peu partout, en Europe et ailleurs, la
montée des populismes se présente sous la forme d'une danse effrénée qui
renverse toutes les règles établies et les transforme en leur contraire. Aux
yeux de leurs électeurs, les défauts des leaders populistes se muent en
qualités. Leur inexpérience est la preuve qu'ils n'appartiennent pas au cercle
corrompu des élites et leur incompétence, le gage de leur authenticité. Les
tensions qu'ils produisent au niveau international sont l'illustration de leur
indépendance et les fake news, qui jalonnent leur propagande, la marque de leur
liberté de penser. Dans le monde de Donald Trump, de Boris Johnson et de Matteo
Salvini, chaque jour porte sa gaffe, sa polémique, son coup d'éclat. Pourtant,
derrière les apparences débridées du carnaval populiste, se cache le travail
acharné de dizaines de spin-doctors, d'idéologues et, de plus en plus souvent,
de scientifiques et d'experts du Big Data, sans lesquels ces leaders populistes
ne seraient jamais parvenus au pouvoir. Ce sont ces ingénieurs du chaos, dont
Giuliano da Empoli brosse le portrait. Du récit incroyable de la petite
entreprise de web-marketing devenue le premier parti italien, en passant par
les physiciens qui ont assuré la victoire du Brexit et par les communicants qui
ont changé le visage de l'Europe de l'Est, jusqu'aux théoriciens de la droite
américaine qui ont propulsé Donald Trump à la Maison Blanche, cette enquête
passionnante et inédite dévoile les coulisses du mouvement populiste global. Il
en résulte une galerie de personnages hauts en couleur, presque tous inconnus
du grand public, et qui sont pourtant en train de changer les règles du jeu
politique et le visage de nos sociétés.
"Carnival,"
said Goethe as he walked through the streets of Rome, "is a feast that the
people give to themselves." Everywhere, in Europe and elsewhere, the rise
of populism is in the form of a frantic dance that overturns all established
rules and transforms them into their opposite. In the eyes of their voters, the
shortcomings of populist leaders are turning into qualities. Their inexperience
is proof that they do not belong to the corrupt circle of elites and their
incompetence is the guarantee of their authenticity. The tensions they produce
at the international level are the illustration of their independence and the
fake news, which punctuates their propaganda, the mark of their freedom of
thought. In the world of Donald Trump, Boris Johnson and Matteo Salvini, every
day carries its blunder, its polemic, its coup d'éclat. Yet behind the
unbridled appearances of the populist carnival lies the hard work of dozens of
spin-doctors, ideologues and, increasingly, scientists and big data experts,
without whom these populist leaders would never have come to power. It is these
engineers of chaos, whose portrait Giuliano da Empoli paints. From the
incredible story of the small web-marketing company that became Italy's leading
party, to the physicists who ensured the victory of Brexit and the
communicators who changed the face of Eastern Europe, to the theorists of the
American right who propelled Donald Trump to the White House, this exciting and
unprecedented investigation reveals the backstage of the global populist
movement. The result is a gallery of colorful characters, almost all unknown to
the general public, and yet who are changing the rules of the political game
and the face of our societies.
A Review of “the Engineers of Chaos”, by Giuliano
Da Empoli
How technology is weakening democracy.
Aure's
Notes
·Oct 14,
2020
This
article is divided into several parts: The summary hosts The origin of
political anger, the Italian story, the US story, the Hungarian story and the
Conclusion. The second part is about the critic of the book.
The Context
In a book
published in 2006, Peter Sloterdijk explains the origin of political anger.
According to him, it originates from a feeling of injustice, exclusion, or
discrimination spreading throughout society.
Historically,
the Catholic Church had been the first institution to focus on these social
groups and channeled their anger. Left-wing political parties took over amid
the industrial revolution. In 2006, Sloterdijk declared that no institution was
there to welcome and channel the rage of the people, which could have
unforeseen consequences. In 2018, the author explained that populist parties
had taken over the role.
If the rage
felt by the populations is empirically justified (social-economic inequalities,
among other things), it is also built on an unarguable fact.
Society has
changed. A lot.
People have
changed. The elites have changed.
The cause
of this evolution, according to the author, is the new communication
technologies. Internet, smartphones, and social media.
The Consequences of Technology
Technology
impacted society in two different ways. The first one concerns the speed of technology.
Its immediacy accustomed users to have their desires immediately fulfilled.
Whether it
is to inquire about the train schedule, shop online, access free entertainment
to kill boredom, or verifying that the prof got that fact right in the middle
of a lecture, smartphones gratify us with instant satisfaction.
As
technology spread, people became less tolerant of slowness and inefficiencies
(such as public policies, for example). As a result, the attention span has
decreased from 15 seconds in 2000, down to 8 seconds in 2015. The brain needs
constant stimulation.
The second
aspect to consider regarding technology concerns social media.
Human
beings are social creatures. We want to be liked. Signs of affection trigger
dopamine in the brain as they inform the individual about a higher likelihood
of survival within the group. Those signs can be a compliment, a hug, a kiss…or
a like on social media.
Validation
from social media has been so abundant that users became hooked. They want
more.
Social
media subsequently appear as a second online “reality” where users experience
kindness and affection.
This
creates a paradox. Users feel successful online yet their “normal” lives remain
mediocre. This duality creates frustration and incomprehension.
To evacuate
this frustration, users subsequently tend to end up on two different websites:
porn, to release the tension, and conspiracy theories.
Both, in
their own ways, serve as a loophole.
Conspiracy
theories discharge us of the responsibility of our misery by designating an
exterior cause responsible for the status quo. If our lives are so mediocre,
it’s because of x, y, z.
They are
written in such a way that trigger emotional responses, which explains their
popularity on social networks.
They
produce clicks and shares and keep users stuck to their screen in an endless
cycle of emotional amplification.
This
pattern was spotted in the case of the genocide of the Rohingyas in Myanmar and
to a lesser extent, in the movement of the Gilets Jaunes in France. Calls to
murder (in Myanmar) and hate were amplified by social media.
To
summarize, hate emerges out of two simultaneous events: the decadence of the
institutions charged to canalize it and the emergence of new media that spread
and amplify it.
The
intelligence of the populist has been to place themselves at this crossroad and
harness the power of hate and social media to accomplish their political
objectives.
Populism in Italy
Beginning
in 2000, Gianroberto Casaleggio, an Italian marketing expert, understood how
the Internet was going to revolutionize politics. Yet he felt society was not
yet ready for the constitution of a purely digital political party.
To give his
idea a human dimension, Casaleggio decided to hire an Italian stand-up
comedian, Beppe Grillo, to be the figure of his movement. In 2005, both
launched a blog, beppegrillo.it.
The
marketing background of Casaleggio encouraged him to treat voters like
consumers and to apply sales theories to political engagement. The important
stream of data harvested on the blog allowed him to get precise and abundant
feedback on users’ experiences, wishes, fears, and desires.
These data
were then used to build the content of the blog based on users’ comments and
different popular themes of the time: governmental incompetence, banks stealing
the honest citizen, and more.
Each post
uploaded sparked reactions that provided feedback and better targeting for the
next post in a never-ending cycle.
The
popularity of the blog exploded up to a peak reached during the organization of
the “V-day” in 2007, which saw hundreds of thousands of Italians protesting
after a call issued by Beppe Grillo.
Neither
classic politicians nor the media had seen it coming.
Confident
in their popularity, Casaleggio and Grillo decided to launch the Five Star
Movement, a political party based on the functioning of the blog.
The structure
was simple: The Five Star Movement was built as a political platform on which
members expressed their opinions.
The drastic
rules implemented and the legal structure that identified the movement as a
private entity belonging to Casaleggio allowed him to expel any member that did
not respect the rules.
The
declarations of the political figures of the party that Casaleggio had chosen
for their youth, lack of charisma, and lack of experience, were based on the
data harvested through the platform and social media.
Early on,
Casaleggio used emotionally investing content to increase engagement with his
lieutenants’ speeches.
The
constant stream of data allowed him to micro-adjust the party’s messages to
always be in phase with the population. The program, purpose, and ideology of
the party did not exist, as it reflected at all instants the desires of its
members.
In 2013,
the Five Star Movement became the first party of Italy. In 2018, it governed
the country.
Populism in the United States
As Barack
Obama was celebrating his victory for the 2008 presidential election,
newspapers and experts around the world saluted the end of racism in the USA.
That same night, Google registered a peak of the search term “first n*****
president”.
The first
to foster a movement opposed to the likes of Barack Obama was (out of all
people) Donald Trump. He quickly gained support among the white working class,
starting by questioning if Barack Obama was American.
Through
this act, it was not so much the citizenship of the President he was
questioning, but the rightfulness of the idea to have a Black person sitting
for president.
To this
story was added the conspiracy theory that Obama had been placed at the head of
the US against the wish and interest of the American people. Finally, the last
ingredient of Trump’s recipe was the fake news claiming that Obama was not born
in the US, which Trump later recognized as a lie.
At the time
when Trump started his non-official political campaign, the US social and
political climate was politically correct and established on the traditional
meritocracy.
However,
under all appearances, people were unhappy. One man at that time had felt that
something was about to happen in the US. That’s how Steve Bannon entered the
picture.
In 2005,
Steve Bannon participated in the launching of a video game company in
Hong-Kong. The idea was to sell gaming artifacts earned by professional Chinese
players to lazier players around the world.
The
unfairness of the practice triggered a torrent of anger in the gamer community.
The violence of then reactions considerably surprised Steve Bannon. That’s how
he learned of these “invisible communities” and of the power he could harness
from them.
Entered Milo Yiannopoulos.
After
several scandals in the gamer community made Yiannopoulos a political
commentator, Steve Bannon who, by that time in 2015, had started working for
Breitbart, decided to offer Yiannopoulos a job as editor of the Breitbart tech
section.
The purpose
was for Bannon to mobilize the gamer community through tech news, and slowly
lure them into politics to make them Trump supporters.
The message
was clear: democrats are muzzling freedom of speech and anonymity online (which
are the core of the gamer community). Trump is the only one there to defend it.
During that
time, Trump was jumping from one scandal to the next campaigning in the
country, under the disapproving look of the democrats.
The
ridicule, vulgarity, and rudeness of the character comforted the democrats that
he could not win because someone such as him could just…not win.
While Trump
was talking to “the forgotten of the country” and leveraging communities
usually ignored in political campaigns, the democrats were untiringly repeating
to themselves that a Trump presidency was impossible.
The rest
was history.
Populism in Hungary
To
understand the story of Hungary (and almost all of Eastern and Central European
states), we need to contextualize the position of these ex-Soviet satellites.
When the
Berlin wall fell, the elites of the East started a process of “westernization”
based on imitation.
However,
the problem of imitation is not so much that the imitator is worth less than
the original, but that it gives the right to the originals to judge the success
or failure of the imitation. For the imitators, this led to a feeling of loss
of sovereignty.
While
ex-Soviet countries lived in fear to be criticized by the West until 2010, the
paradigm unversed: “27 years ago, we thought Europe was our future, declared
Orban in 2017. Today, we realized we are the future of Europe”.
This all
started with Arthur Finkelstein. As he was not even 20 years old, this Jew from
New York started militating in the right-wing of the Republican party.
He rapidly
became an expert at electoral campaigns based on denigrating the candidates
he’d play against.
His craft
made him known outside of the US to lead campaigns in Europe and Israel, and he
eventually met Orban in 2009.
At the
time, Orban had already been prime minister but had lost the election after a
financial crisis had propelled his country into the arms of the IMF and the EU.
The two men
decided to organize Orban’s next political campaign based on a backlash against
the “elites from Brussels”, despite Orban originally winning with a
pro-European campaign.
In 2010,
Orban won with more than 50%.
From there
on, Orban signed the beginning of a new era for Hungary. To gain popularity, he
surfed on an anti-western sentiment inherited from the end of WWI (which saw
Hungary amputated from about 70% of its territory).
Later on,
corruption scandals tied to personalities closed to Orban sent his political
party in limbo at 20%.
Their
attempt at reviving the Fidesz with debates on capital punishment did not work.
They needed a new enemy, which the refugee crisis was going to give them.
As millions
of Syrian refugees entered Europe, banderoles and ad banners started to appear
in the streets of Hungary with messages denigrating refugees.
Orban
opposed the homogeneity of the Hungarian culture and people to immigrants that
were coming “to steal the work of Hungarians”.
Later, the
plan of the EU to impose quotas of migrants to each country became a
benediction for Orban which declared war on the “diktats of Brussels”.
Orban has
been ruling Hungary ever since.
Conclusion
The author
tells the story of a director of refuge for cats.
For a
couple of years, the director had been noticing that black cats got more often
abandoned and less often chosen by customers.
After some
research, he realized that the phenomenon was countrywide.
One day, a
young lady explained to him why: “black cats do not appear well on selfies, the
camera has trouble capturing them well. But white and ginger cats appear the
cutest”.
The extreme
narcissistic period into which we live coupled with new technological
communication and the immediate satisfaction phenomenon risks seeing the
representative democracy abolished.
Smartphones
have allowed users to interact and decide directly and immediately, rendering
representative democracy “useless”.
When the
Trump campaign team was testing its 5.9 million different online messages, it
was testing messages targeted at the scale of the individual.
The
individual wants to think it is in command, but the reality is that what the
individual perceives is a hyperreality designed for him/herself. Not for anyone
else.
On top of
breaking communities, smartphones and social media have split people from each
other.
Even if the
community still existed, it could not function well because everyone lives in
their reality, their bubble, complicating the experiences of sharing and
exchanging about one common reality.
As such, it
is not power, money, safety or materialism that people desire most. It is human
connection.
While the
media portrayed scenes of extreme violence during the Gilets Jaunes movement,
many did not have the chance to see the scenes of joy and happiness. Most of
the protesters were not fighting the police but danced and assembled on
roundabouts and in the street.
The Gilets
Jaunes movement may not have been so much a protest movement than an event to
share some time with friends, families, and neighbors. An event to rejoice.
In the
press, one journalist observed that “roundabouts and the street have replaced
bars and cafés”.
The
rhetoric of both the Five Star Movement and of Trump politics borrows to the
personal development community the idea that their movement is about freeing
people’s energy far too long reprimanded by the traditional elite.
Each member
in their separate reality subsequently gets the feeling to be part of something
historical, something grandiose.
The slogan
of the Brexit campaign “Take back control” is echoing this feeling.
These
slogans work because humans have a dire need for control.
Psychologists
have discovered that dying patients in retirement houses were living longer
when they had the right to decide about the place of a painting, a frame, a
chair, a picture.
There is
something in the human instinct that makes us want to take control of our own
lives.
The lack of
control, or worse, the feeling our control is in the hands of others, is deeply
disturbing.
Populists
have managed to harness this fear and give the people exactly what they desire:
control over their own lives.
Or at
least, the feeling thereof.
In Italy,
the engineers of chaos managed to dynamite the center of the political spectrum
to divide and push voters towards extremes.
Extreme-right
populism ended up governing with the extreme-left populism.
It was the
pinnacle of the achievement of populism, its the exact raison d’être.
Yet, in
this chaos, someone seemed to have achieved the impossible.
In France,
Emmanuel Macron managed to assemble both the right and the left in the center
and to govern with everyone.
Doing so,
he dynamited both the traditional right and the left parties.
While most
of the electors moved to the center, the rest fueled the populist extreme-left
and the populist extreme-right.
These
changes and new paradigms have dynamited the political landscape of 2010 and
before. It’s dead, and it’s not coming back.
The code
and rules have been rewritten.
Traditional
parties and the representative democracies themselves will have to adapt if
they wish to keep the current democratic model.
Even though
many have predicted the near end of populism due to the emptiness of their
politics and political programs, populists have proven they can adapt to
circumstances.
Liberal
democracies have a lot to worry about.
Critic
The
engineer of chaos is a remarkable book.
It attempts
at reconstructing from a scientific, political, and historical perspective the
genesis of the data scientists, physicians, and political strategists that led
populist parties to rise to the power of the biggest economies in the world.
However,
the author does not stop at telling this story.
Through an
intelligent mix of history, sociology, and psychology, he explains the societal
changes that established the base for populist parties to rise after a decade
of liberalism.
His book,
almost written like a scientific novel, follows a logical and geographical
path. It explains the atypical careers of all these scientists hiding behind
their computer screen, almost controlling the politicians they placed to power.
The book
reveals several political paradigm shifts, fractures, and divides in society.
The connector of those three is technology, used as a vehicle by the engineers
of chaos to fulfill their political purposes.
It is not
about one type of technology only, but about several that, by chance or
opportunism, appeared at the same moment.
The first
one is social media, whose business model is based on clicks on ads and time
spent on the platform.
To do so,
social media have made their use compulsive thanks to a smart system of likes
equal to social achievement and hence delivering dopamine at each hit,
reinforcing the addiction cycle.
The user is
presented with content he/she agrees based on psychological profiling
individually built with streams of data taken from the clicks, content read, and
searched terms.
The unique
content the user is exposed to participates in the creation of a digital
reality into which the user is alone to live, hence creating needs of social
connections assured by social media themselves.
When those
needs are too high, the user ends up on pornographic and conspiracy sites,
releasing him/her from responsibilities of the mediocrity of his/her life by
blaming an external agent.
This
phenomenon is one of the interactions linking social media and smartphones.
The second
does not especially concern smartphones, but social media alone. Science (and
marketeers) uncovered that emotional content received more clicks and attention
from users, which sparked their use.
But
emotional content also amplifies real-life emotions, among which anger, often
targeted by the engineers of chaos.
Indeed,
anger is an emotion that calls to action (vote) and can mobilize crowds for
political support.
Finally,
the third manner social media influence populations is with data and targeted
messages.
As we said,
social networking sites can build profiles of users thanks to their data.
Similarly,
a company or a party can send targeted messages to influence users based on
their psychological profile.
This
technique was used to leverage an important number of people in the UK for the
Brexit vote, people that would have not normally gone to vote.
The
interaction of these technological components, coupled with psychology and data
science, may be the greatest political hold-up in history. And the worse may be
on its way.
The
traditional media, guarantors of democracy, have neither seen nor anticipated
the populist rise.
Worse,
faced against it, they became incapable of defending themselves.
While the
book is remarkable for its precision, simplicity, and details it brings, it
fails at time to talk about elements that would have been interesting to the
investigation.
The first
one is the Russian disinformation campaign led both in the US and in the UK.
The second
is the concept of the filter bubble.
Central to
the theories of the author, the term was never mentioned in the book.
Besides
that, the book remains more relevant than ever, for policymakers, parents or
journalists, and all citizens that vote.
The
engineers of chaos have managed to orchestrate a revolution through mass
manipulation without anyone realizing so.
They have
done it already many times, in many different countries, and keep their
algorithms ready for the next elections.
This may be
what sets them apart from dictators.
Everyone
living in a dictatorship is aware of its nature.
In our
present case, the instigators stayed in the shadow, no one knows their names or
faces, and voters get manipulated while being persuaded of the opposite.
In the part
on Italy, Casaleggio’s son compares the users of his platform to ants.
They must
continually move, obeying orders, but cannot question the established rules and
must not know that other ants work less than them, or they’ll want to do like
these ants.
To continue
with the animal metaphors, these engineers are similar to parasites.
They
colonize the brain of their host without them knowing so.
They take
control in the shadow.
The result
becomes particularly deadly.



Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário