THE FRIDAY
READ
How I Won $5 Million From the MyPillow Guy and
Saved Democracy
Mike Lindell dared anyone to disprove his claim that
the 2020 election was stolen. For this software forensics expert, it was almost
too easy.
By BOB
ZEIDMAN
05/26/2023
04:30 AM EDT
https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/05/26/my-pillow-mike-lindell-investigation-00097903
Bob Zeidman
is the creator of the field of software forensics and the founder of several
successful high-tech Silicon Valley firms including Zeidman Consulting and Software
Analysis and Forensic Engineering. His latest venture is Good Beat Poker, a new
way to play and watch poker online. He is the author of textbooks on
engineering and intellectual property as well as award-winning screenplays and
novels. His latest novel is Animal Lab, an update of George Orwell’s Animal
Farm.
If you
watch TV, especially conservative TV, you know Mike Lindell. He’s the guy who
comes on every 10 minutes or so to sell his pillows for “the best night’s sleep
in the whole wide world.” He’s also the guy who has sunk tens of millions of
dollars into supporting investigations and lawsuits that claim the 2020
presidential election was stolen from Donald Trump.
And I just
took him for $5 million.
Want to
read more stories like this? POLITICO Weekend delivers gripping reads, smart
analysis and a bit of high-minded fun every Friday. Sign up for the newsletter.
You may
have read a little about it. In the summer of 2021, Lindell announced that he
was going to hold a “Cyber Symposium” in Sioux Falls, S.D., to release data
that proved that U.S. voting machines were hacked by China. He said he would
even pay $5 million to anyone who could disprove his data.
Right away,
friends started calling to ask me if I was planning to go. After all, I invented
the field of software forensics, the science of analyzing software source code
for intellectual property infringement or theft. Still, I wasn’t sure. There
are a lot of experts that could analyze data. And no one in their right mind
would offer $5 million if the data wasn’t real and verified, right? Anyway, the
symposium ran three days — not nearly long enough to analyze and verify any
data.
But I’m
also a tournament poker player. I love a good challenge. And as the calls and
emails kept coming in, I started to think, I should go, just to be there when
history was made. I voted for Trump twice. If Lindell’s data was correct, maybe
a presidential election would be overturned. I’d at least get to meet some
really interesting people. So I flew to Sioux Falls.
Mike
Lindell at his Cyber Symposium
In the
summer of 2021, Lindell announced that he was going to hold a “Cyber Symposium”
in Sioux Falls, S.D., to release data that proved U.S. voting machines were
hacked by China. | Bob Zeidman
At the
symposium, I saw the competition, about 40 or 50 of them. Some were highly
qualified hackers and experienced cyber experts like me. Others were just
interested parties with some experience in information technology.
We gathered
in two small rooms that looked like stark public-school classrooms. After
introducing ourselves, we began downloading Lindell’s Holy Grail — his “proof
of election fraud” that came from an unspecified source — which consisted of
seven files comprising over 23 gigabytes of data.
Two of the
files were generic information about voting machines. Another file was a
meaningless one minute, 20 second silent video of a computer screen showing
some unknown program being debugged. A fourth file was a 23 gigabyte binary
file containing ones and zeroes, allegedly containing packet capture data, or
“PCAPs.”
If you’re
not familiar with any of that language, packets are the small chunks of
information that are sent over a network like the Internet and then reassembled
at the receiving end as pictures of your grandkids or cute cat movies from
YouTube. PCAPs are records of those packets as they flew around a network.
In numerous
interviews, Lindell had claimed that his data showed packet captures of votes
flowing outside the U.S. to China where they were modified to switch votes from
Trump to Biden, and then sent back to U.S. voting machines.
We used a
variety of forensic tools designed to understand and analyze PCAPs, but found
this mysterious file didn’t contain any of the 37 standard PCAP formats. I even
used the CodeSuite forensics tool I had developed to try to gain any
information from the file. Nada.
So I
decided to focus on the three remaining files, which were simple text files
that could be opened up with any text editor like Notepad that comes
preinstalled on every Windows computer. The contents were text representations
of hex numbers, which are base 16 numbers used by computers as opposed to base
10 numbers, decimal, used by people.
I started
with the ominously named file Chinese_SourceIP_HEX.txt. Having programmed
computers for about 50 years, I recognized that each of these hex numbers
seemed to represent a code for alphanumeric characters known as ASCII code. So
I took a software tool I’d written years ago and ran this text file through it
to turn the text representation of numbers into actual numbers.
Next, I
opened the resulting file in the Notepad text editor. Sure enough, I saw
letters and numbers representing some other kind of code — Rich Text Format
code, a very old and simple way of coding word processor documents. (It turns
out that it’s sometimes good to be old, wise, and experienced like me.)
I opened
this converted file with Microsoft Word and… voila... a table with hundreds of
rows of numbers appeared — numbers that looked like IP addresses (that is, the
numbers associated with devices connected to a network).
With no
other information, they were about as meaningful as a list of random words. At
that point, it was obvious that the data in these text files were not anything
related to the 2020 election. That’s when I knew I had stumbled onto the key.
Not the key to showing election fraud, but the key to showing Lindell’s
nonsense.
I repeated
the same process on the other text files and found even stranger stuff. These
files were also obfuscated word processor documents, but contained thousands of
lines of gibberish — nothing more than random characters and numbers.
My eureka
moment had arrived. While everyone else was looking at the sky, I had found the
golden ticket on the ground; while they were trying to find packet data in the
files, the truth was that it wasn’t packet data at all. I said something out
loud like, “I’m going to take this back to my hotel room and work on it there,”
to no one in particular. I quietly and deliberately packed up my laptop and
strolled out of the room and out of the venue. On the way back to the hotel, I
called my wife. “Start thinking about what you want to do with 5 million
dollars,” I told her.
Back in my
room, I wrote up my report and registered a copy online with the U.S. Copyright
Office as proof that I had written it by the contest deadline. Just in case.
But
Lindell’s game wasn’t over yet. The next day, a little before noon, I strolled
into the cyber workroom and found everyone still going at it. It turns out
there was more data to analyze — Lindell had given us about 50 gigabytes of
additional data to plow through. There were four new files, but when I looked
at them, they were essentially the same types as the first day’s files except
with a spreadsheet containing 121,128 lines of generic information about
internet service providers around the world plus their locations, their
latitudes and longitudes, their IP addresses, and other miscellaneous
information. I determined that nothing in the file was related to the 2020
presidential election, and wondered what my competitors were seeing.
Then came
another giant batch of 509 files, comprising many more gigabytes. This was how
Lindell planned to keep anyone from winning the challenge, I figured. Just
inundate us with files and not nearly enough time to analyze them. That $5
million suddenly seemed to have slipped through my fingers in a way that felt
very unfair.
But I had
come too far to give up. On the third and final day of the symposium, an idea
hit me. I decided to scan the file modification dates for all of the latest
files we’d been given and, lo and behold, most of the dates were August 2021,
right before the symposium.
In other
words, the data were obviously modified right before we examined them. They
could not possibly accurately represent data from the November 2020 election.
My flight
was leaving early that evening, so I needed to be quick. I ran back to the
hotel, added this new information to my report, double checked it, triple
checked it, and saved it onto a flash drive. I hurriedly packed my things,
rushed to the symposium as it was ending, handed my report on a flash drive to
an official-looking person, and ran out to the Uber or Lyft waiting for me by
the door. I made it to the airport just in time for my flight home to Vegas.
I guess the
rest is history, as they say. I never talked to Lindell after the symposium; he
never responded to my findings. So I hired great lawyers at Bailey Glasser and
filed an arbitration lawsuit against him. It dragged on for a year and a half,
during which his law firm quit and he hired a new one. During the leadup to the
hearing with the three-person arbitration panel, his witnesses gave conflicting
answers to critical questions like “What exactly was in the data you provided
to the experts and how was it related to the November 2020 U.S. presidential
election?”
In January
2023, the hearing was finally held. We presented our case. Lindell presented
his case, though he only was there for about one hour — to testify — out of the
four-day hearing. In April 2023, the decision was handed down, awarding me $5
million.
“Mr.
Zeidman,” the arbitrators stated, “proved the data Lindell LLC provided …
unequivocally did not reflect November 2020 election data.”
Last week,
Lindell filed an appeal of the decision, though to win that appeal he needs to
show that the arbitrators were corrupt. He also claimed that I was part of “a
big cover-up to a much bigger picture” and should never have been allowed to
enter the contest. My lawyers and I will continue to fight him in court. When
and if I see the money, I plan to donate to a nonprofit to legitimately support
voter integrity laws and processes.
.jpg)

Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário