White House and G.O.P. Strike Debt Limit Deal to
Avert Default
With the government on track to reach its borrowing
limit within days, negotiators sealed an agreement to raise the debt ceiling
for two years while cutting and capping certain federal programs.
Jim
Tankersley Catie Edmondson Luke Broadwater
By Jim
Tankersley, Catie Edmondson and Luke Broadwater
Reporting
from Washington
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/27/us/politics/debt-ceiling-deal.html
May 27,
2023
Updated
10:41 p.m. ET
President
Biden and Speaker Kevin McCarthy on Saturday reached an agreement in principle
to lift the debt limit for two years while cutting and capping some government
spending over the same period, a breakthrough after a marathon set of crisis
talks that has brought the nation within days of its first default in history.
Congressional
passage of the plan before June 5, when the Treasury is projected to exhaust
its ability to pay its obligations, is not assured, particularly in the House,
which plans to consider it on Wednesday. Republicans hold a narrow majority in
the chamber, and right-wing lawmakers who had demanded significantly larger
budget cuts in exchange for lifting the borrowing limit were already in revolt.
But the
compromise, which would effectively freeze federal spending that had been on
track to grow, had the blessing of both the Democratic president and the
Republican speaker, raising hopes that it could break the fiscal stalemate that
has gripped Washington and the nation for weeks, threatening an economic
crisis.
Mr. Biden
urged the House and Senate to pass the agreement in a late-night statement
issued by the White House, saying it would prevent a catastrophic default.
“It is an
important step forward that reduces spending while protecting critical programs
for working people and growing the economy for everyone,” Mr. Biden said. “And
the agreement protects my and congressional Democrats’ key priorities and
legislative accomplishments. The agreement represents a compromise, which means
not everyone gets what they want.”
The
president and Mr. McCarthy spoke by phone on Saturday evening to resolve final
sticking points.
In a
nighttime news conference outside his Capitol office that lasted just one
minute, Mr. McCarthy said the deal contained “historic reductions in spending,
consequential reforms that will lift people out of poverty into the work force,
rein in government overreach” and would add no new taxes. He declined to answer
questions or provide specifics, but said he planned to release legislative text
on Sunday.
“We still
have more work to do tonight to finish all the writing of it,” he said.
The plan
was structured with the aim of enticing votes from both parties, though it has
drawn the ire not only of conservative Republicans but also Democrats furious
at being asked to vote for cuts they oppose with the threat of default looming.
What is the
debt ceiling? The debt ceiling, also called the debt limit, is a cap on the
total amount of money that the federal government is authorized to borrow via
U.S. Treasury securities, such as bills and savings bonds, to fulfill its
financial obligations. Because the United States runs budget deficits (meaning
it spends more than it brings in through taxes and other revenue), it must
borrow huge sums of money to pay its bills.
The limit
has been hit. What now? America hit its technical debt limit on Jan. 19. The
Treasury Department has begun using “extraordinary measures” to continue paying
the government’s obligations. These measures are essentially fiscal accounting
tools that curb certain government investments so that the bills continue to be
paid. Those options could be exhausted by June.
What is at
stake? Once the government exhausts its extraordinary measures and runs out of
cash, it will be unable to issue new debt and pay its bills. The government may
wind up defaulting on its debt if it cannot make required payments to its
bondholders. Such an outcome would be economically devastating and could plunge
the world into a financial crisis.
How can the
government avert disaster? There is no official playbook for what Washington
can do. But options do exist. The Treasury could try to prioritize payments,
such as paying bondholders first. If the United States does default on its debt,
which would rattle the markets, the Federal Reserve could step in to buy some
of those Treasury bonds.
Why is
there a limit on U.S. borrowing? Congress must authorize borrowing, according
to the Constitution. The debt limit was instituted in the early 20th century so
that the Treasury would not need to ask for permission each time it had to
issue debt to pay bills.
Still, it
gives Republicans the ability to say that they succeeded in reducing some
federal spending — even as funding for the military and veterans’ programs
would continue to grow — while allowing Democrats to say they spared most
domestic programs from significant cuts.
The deal
would suspend the borrowing limit, which is currently $31.4 trillion, for two
years — enough to get past the next presidential election.
According
to a person familiar with the agreement, it also would impose new work
requirements for some recipients of government aid, including food stamps and
the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. It would place new limits
on how long certain recipients of food stamps — people under the age of 54, who
do not have children — could benefit from the program. But it also would expand
food stamp access for veterans and the homeless, said the person, who spoke on
condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss details of
the package.
The
tentative deal also claws back some unspent money from a previous pandemic
relief bill, and reduces by $10 billion — to $70 billion from $80 billion — new
enforcement funding for the I.R.S. to crack down on tax cheats. It includes
measures meant to speed environmental reviews of certain energy projects and a
provision meant to force the president to find budget savings to offset the
costs of a unilateral action, like forgiving student loans — though
administration officials could circumvent that requirement. It also includes an
enforcement measure that is meant to avert a government shutdown later this
year.
The work
requirements and the environmental review reforms were among the last details
the two sides worked out on Saturday.
White House
and congressional negotiators — working around the clock at the Capitol, in the
White House and virtually — pushed the resolution nearly to the last minute,
increasing pressure on lawmakers to accept a solution unpopular with activists
on both the right and left. Economists and Wall Street analysts warned that a
default would be devastating and potentially lead to a global economic
meltdown.
To avert a
default, the House and the Senate must pass the deal and send it to Mr. Biden
for his signature. That promises to be a heavy lift for both Mr. McCarthy and
Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York, the Democratic leader, who must now
cobble together a coalition of House Republicans and Democrats to push it
through.
Mr.
McCarthy has repeatedly said he believes a majority of his conference would
vote for the deal, but it is not clear yet how many Republicans will back the
compromise — and how many Democrats might be needed to vote for it to make up
for G.O.P. defections.
The path
also is likely to be rocky in the Senate, where quick action requires
bipartisan support and conservatives have signaled they are unwilling to go
along.
In a sign
of their displeasure, House Freedom Caucus members were huddling to identify
procedural tools to delay passage of the agreement or make the bill more
conservative.
Republicans
have refused for months to raise the debt limit unless Mr. Biden agreed to
spending cuts and reduce future debt — risking a default to wield their
leverage. The final agreement accomplishes their goal, but only modestly. A New
York Times analysis of the spending caps at the center of the agreement
suggests they will reduce federal spending by about $650 billion over a decade,
if spending grows at the expected rate of inflation after the caps lift in two
years.
The cuts in
the package are almost certainly both too modest to win the votes of hard-line
conservatives and too stringent to win the votes of progressives in the House.
Lawmakers in the House Freedom Caucus were privately pillorying the deal on
Saturday night, and the Congressional Progressive Caucus had already begun to
fume about it even before negotiators finalized the agreement.
But budget
hawks urged passage. “The process was tense, risky and ugly, but in the end, we
have a plan to enact savings and lift the debt ceiling, and that is what is
needed,” said Maya MacGuineas, president of the Committee for a Responsible
Federal Budget in Washington.
The deal
would impose caps on discretionary spending for two years, though those caps
would apply differently to spending on the military than to the rest of the
federal budget. Spending on the military would grow next year, as would
spending on some veterans’ care. Spending on other domestic programs would fall
slightly — or stay roughly flat — compared with this year’s levels.
The
announcement came after months of political brinkmanship. Mr. Biden and
congressional Democrats initially insisted that House Republicans raise the
debt ceiling without conditions, but relented after Mr. McCarthy marshaled his
conference to pass a bill to increase the nation’s borrowing limit in exchange
for cutting government programs by an average of 18 percent over a decade.
Republicans purposefully avoided laying out exactly which programs they planned
to cut, but the bill’s passage forced Mr. Biden to do what he had said he never
would: negotiate over raising the debt ceiling.
The deal
was ultimately struck by a group led by Mr. Biden’s counselor, Steve Ricchetti;
his budget director, Shalanda Young; and two of Mr. McCarthy’s closest
confidants, Representatives Patrick T. McHenry of North Carolina and Garret
Graves of Louisiana. They agreed to use some creative accounting maneuvers in
the deal to help provide both sides political cover.
But Mr.
McCarthy was still likely to face a revolt from the hard-right lawmakers in his
conference whom he empowered as part of the concessions he made to become
speaker in January, after a bruising 15-round election.
On a
private call to brief members of his conference on the emerging deal, Mr.
McCarthy sold the agreement as a victory, saying there was little in the
package that Democrats supported. But hard-right lawmakers in the Freedom
Caucus, who for days had been venting frustration with the emerging contours of
the deal, made their displeasure known.
Everything
“they fought for” in the House bill were omitted from the agreement,
Representative Bob Good of Virginia said, according to a person familiar with
the remarks who spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe a private call.
Mr. McCarthy and his deputies defended the deal, citing several wins, including
rolling back money for the I.R.S.
Progressives,
too, had vented their unhappiness before the deal was even announced.
Lindsay
Owens, the executive director of the liberal Groundwork Collaborative in
Washington, criticized the deal for forcing budget cuts in domestic programs —
and in particular, for reducing enforcement money for the I.R.S.
“Conceding
to Republican demands to hamstring the I.R.S.’s ability to go after wealthy tax
evaders is a losing proposition for Democrats,” she said. “It undermines an
important policy initiative, drains a good source of revenue and requires the
caucus to vote down a policy that is incredibly popular with the public.”
Peter Baker
contributed reporting.
Jim
Tankersley is a White House correspondent with a focus on economic policy. He
has written for more than a decade in Washington about the decline of
opportunity for American workers, and is the author of "The Riches of This
Land: The Untold, True Story of America's Middle Class." @jimtankersley
Catie
Edmondson is a reporter in the Washington bureau, covering Congress.
@CatieEdmondson
Luke
Broadwater covers Congress. He was the lead reporter on a series of
investigative articles at The Baltimore Sun that won a Pulitzer Prize and a
George Polk Award in 2020. @lukebroadwater


Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário