Texas House Votes to Impeach Ken Paxton
Mr. Paxton, the state attorney general and a
conservative star, is immediately
removed from office, pending a trial in the Senate.
Pinned
Updated
May 27,
2023, 11:38 p.m. ET2 minutes ago
2 minutes
ago
J. David
Goodman, James Dobbins and Nicholas Bogel-Burroughs
https://www.nytimes.com/live/2023/05/27/us/texas-paxton-impeachment
The Texas attorney general is the first statewide
officeholder to be impeached in over a century.
Ken Paxton,
attorney general of Texas who was impeached by the Texas House on Saturday,
addressing the news media a day earlier at his office in Austin,
Texas.Credit...Eric Gay/Associated Press
Lawmakers
in the Texas House voted on Saturday to impeach Ken Paxton, the state’s
Republican attorney general, temporarily removing him from office over charges
that he had used his elected position to benefit himself and a campaign donor.
After a
four-hour proceeding before a packed gallery, the vote landed with titanic
force in the Texas Capitol, where a statewide office holder had not been
impeached in more than a century, since the Legislature voted to oust the
sitting governor, James E. Ferguson, in 1917, for embezzlement and misuse of
public funds.
Before the
vote, Representative Andrew Murr, the Republican chair of the House
investigating committee that recommended impeachment, closed by urging his
colleagues to impeach. “The evidence presented to you is compelling and is more
than sufficient to justify going to trial,” he said, adding: “Send this to
trial.”
The final
vote was 121 members in favor of impeachment — a bipartisan coalition that
included nearly every Democrat and a majority of the chamber’s Republicans —
and 23 against, with two abstaining. As they voted, the board in the front of
the chamber lit up in green lights signaling support. It went well beyond the
75 necessary.
“It was a
hard one, a hard one, really hard,” Representative Jeff Leach, a Dallas-area
Republican who voted in favor of impeachment, said after the vote.
According
to Texas law, Gov. Greg Abbott may appoint an interim attorney general, pending
the Senate trial, but he is not required to. A spokesman for his office did not
respond to a request for comment on what he intended to do.
With the
impeachment vote, Mr. Paxton was immediately removed from office, pending the
Senate trial. No date had been set for that to begin.
The Senate
trial will be presided over by the lieutenant governor, Dan Patrick, an arch
conservative aligned with many of Mr. Paxton’s supporters. Mr. Patrick has
maintained a neutral posture in public comments this week. A two-thirds vote is
necessary to convict in the Senate, where Republicans hold a 19-to-12
advantage.
The speed
with which events proceeded left legislators, Texas officials and other
political observers stunned and grasping: Just a few days ago, almost no one in
the Capitol had been even aware that such a significant investigation of Mr.
Paxton was underway, much less that an impeachment vote could be the result.
His fellow
Republicans, who introduced the 20 articles of impeachment, presented Mr.
Paxton as a rogue public official who could not be trusted in the office he
occupied. They did so in reference to Mr. Paxton’s actions, which they said in
many cases amounted to crimes, and contrasted them with the integrity of those
who stood up to him, many of them conservative Republicans.
“Attorney
General Paxton continuously and blatantly violated laws, rules, policies and
procedures,” said David Spiller, a Republican member of the investigating
committee, speaking to the House on Saturday. “As a body we should not be
complicit” in that behavior, he said. “Texas is better than that.”
Mr. Paxton
released a statement immediately after the vote, calling the process “illegal,
unethical and profoundly unjust.”
“I look
forward to a quick resolution in the Texas Senate, where I have full confidence
the process will be fair and just,” Mr. Paxton wrote. He has many allies in the
more conservative Senate, including his wife, Angela, and personal friends.
The
articles of impeachment charged Mr. Paxton with abusing his office in a range
of ways, including taking what amounted to bribes, disregarding his official
duty, obstructing justice in a separate securities fraud case pending against
him, making false statements on official documents and abusing the public
trust.
Many of the
articles focused on Mr. Paxton’s purported use of his office to benefit a
particular donor, Nate Paul, a real estate investor in Austin who has given $25,000
in political contributions to Mr. Paxton. Those included using the office to
intervene in a legal dispute that Mr. Paul was having with a nonprofit, and
hiring a lawyer on contract to work for the attorney general’s office, at Mr.
Paul’s request and over the objections of senior staff members at the attorney
general’s office, in order to look into a federal inquiry of Mr. Paul.
Mr. Paul
also provided other benefits to Mr. Paxton, the articles of impeachment said,
including giving a job to a woman described during the impeachment proceedings
as Mr. Paxton’s “mistress,” and providing expensive home renovations, including
countertops valued at around $20,000.
Mr. Paxton,
60, who has denied any wrongdoing, has been a strong supporter of conservative
legal causes and one of the chief antagonists of the Biden administration on a
range of issues, including the Affordable Care Act and immigration on the
southern border. Mr. Paxton also challenged the results of the 2020 election in
court, a losing fight that won him the support of former President Donald J.
Trump.
He was
elected to a third term last year even after the alleged offenses were
prominently raised during the campaign, including by Republicans who ran
against him in the primary election. He has accused the more moderate
Republican leadership of the House of acting in concert with Democrats to oust
him.
Scores of
supporters of Mr. Paxton packed the House gallery — urged to be there by a
public appeal from Mr. Paxton the night before — and watched the proceedings
mostly in silence. There were no outbursts or any efforts to disrupt the vote.
What
surprised many observers in the Texas Capitol was not the nature of the
allegations lodged against Mr. Paxton, but that they had finally caught up with
him. Much of the wrongdoing presented publicly to a House investigating
committee this week by its investigators had been known.
The
allegations of corruption and abuse of office were described in 2020 by several
of his top aides, who requested an investigation of Mr. Paxton. The aides who
spoke up either resigned or were forced out or fired. Four of them filed a
lawsuit over their firing. The Federal Bureau of Investigation also opened an
investigation and, in February, the Justice Department said that the inquiry
had been taken over by investigators in Washington.
What
changed this year was that Mr. Paxton sought state money to try to put the most
serious matter behind him, asking for $3.3 million in state funds for a
settlement that he had reached with the four aides. The Texas House responded
by initiating an investigation of the request and the underlying accusations.
Their findings that Mr. Paxton’s actions had been improper and possibly illegal
provided the first official condemnation of his behavior.
Many of the
most prominent national voices in the Republican Party, including Mr. Trump and
Senator Ted Cruz of Texas, came to Mr. Paxton’s defense, arguing that the
impeachment was motivated by politics and served the interests of Democrats.
“For the
last nine years, Ken has been the strongest conservative AG in the country,”
Mr. Cruz wrote on Saturday. “I understand that people are concerned about Ken’s
legal challenges. But the courts should sort them out.”
Mr. Trump
explicitly threatened Texas Republicans who backed Mr. Paxton’s impeachment
and, less than an hour before it started, urged them not to go forward with it.
“I will fight you if it does,” Mr. Trump wrote. “Free Ken Paxton!”
Mr. Paxton
himself was said to have been making similar threats, calling members directly
in a last-ditch attempt to avoid impeachment and “personally threatening them
with political consequences in their next election,” according to
Representative Charlie Geren, a Republican member of the investigating
committee.
During the
proceedings, Mr. Paxton’s Republican supporters did not defend his actions but
raised questions of fairness and due process. Several complained that they had
not been given enough time or information to reach a decision, or that they
were being asked to rely on “hearsay” in the form of testimony to the
investigating committee rather than being able to examine evidence against Mr.
Paxton on their own.
The
committee itself did not consider evidence directly. Instead it relied on
testimony from its investigators, who
had collected documents and interviewed employees of the attorney general's
office and others as part of their investigation, which began in March.
“I’m
opposed to this resolution, not because I’m convinced of the attorney general’s
innocence,” said one of the principal opponents, Brian Harrison, a Republican
member of the House’s ultraconservative Freedom Caucus. But, he said, the
process did not “adequately document his guilt” and he called it “a sham
railroading of a political enemy.”
Another
Republican opponent, John Smithee, tried to offer an alternative for
Republicans who might be on the fence: Vote no on Saturday, and come back for a
“one-day hearing” where evidence could be fully presented and Mr. Paxton would
have a chance to defend himself.
“If I’m
ever going to be a part of any impeachment proceeding that actually results in
the impeachment of an officer, I don’t want to look like a Saturday mob out for
an afternoon lynching,” said Mr. Smithee, After he completed his remarks, a large
portion of the public gallery erupted in applause.
Democrats
had largely remained quiet as the Republicans debated among themselves,
appearing to want to avoid making the impeachment a partisan issue.
“You keep
hearing, ‘Why now?’” said Representative Terry Canales, a Democrat whose
father, when he was a state representative, presented articles of impeachment
against a district judge in 1975, the last time such a vote was taken. “There’s
never a wrong time to do the right thing,” Mr. Canales said, pounding the
lectern at the front of the House chamber.
Outside the
Capitol, a small number of opponents and supporters of Mr. Paxton protested and
occasionally confronted one another. “What he’s doing is the right thing, and
the speaker is doing the wrong thing,” said a 76-year-old retired information
systems manager from Austin, who declined to give his name.
Ilan Levin,
54, an associate director at an Austin nonprofit, stood beside his bicycle
arguing with Mr. Paxton’s supporters. He held a cardboard sign that said,
“IMPEACH!!!” But he said he did not think the impeachment vote would have a big
impact.
“A lot of
Texans will forget about it by the next election cycle,” he said.
J. David
Goodman and James Dobbins reported from Austin, Texas, and Nicholas Bogel-Burroughs
from New York. David Montgomery in Austin and Anushka Patil in New York
contributed reporting.



Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário