While BMW and Volkswagen are both facing heavy industry headwinds, Volkswagen is undergoing a deeper existential crisis, whereas BMW is on comparatively more solid financial footing.

 

Top of Form

Bottom of Form

While BMW and Volkswagen are both facing heavy industry headwinds, Volkswagen is undergoing a deeper existential crisis, whereas BMW is on comparatively more solid financial footing. 

The root challenges affecting both German automakers include:

• The China Slump: Both manufacturers rely heavily on China, where local competitors (like BYD) now dominate the market for affordable electric vehicles. Deliveries for both brands have seen sharp double-digit drops in the region. 
• EV Transitions: Struggling to match cheaper Chinese EV technology and software has cut deeply into the profit margins of legacy German brands. 

However, the severity of their respective crises differs significantly: 

• Volkswagen: VW is facing an existential crisis marked by plummeting sales and dropping profits. The company is reportedly planning massive workforce cuts of up to 100,000 jobs and the potential closure of multiple factories in Germany. 
• BMW: BMW has fared better than most of its European peers. Thanks to a more flexible manufacturing strategy—allowing them to produce a mix of combustion, hybrid, and electric engines on the same platforms—BMW is better positioned to navigate wavering global EV demand. While they are still dealing with dropping profits in China and issuing overall profit warnings, they are not facing the same scale of imminent factory closures and mass layoffs as VW.