domingo, 2 de abril de 2017

O Novo Banco foi despachado como um carro velho / Novo Banco: Ainda bem que se fez este péssimo negócio


O Novo Banco foi despachado como um carro velho

Podemos ter despachado o Novo Banco — mas não nos despachámos dos problemas do Novo Banco.

RUI TAVARES
3 de Abril de 2017, 6:55

O pensamento que presidiu ao negócio do Novo Banco, fechado pelo governo na passada sexta, tem muitas semelhanças com a maneira com que lidamos com um carro velho: despachá-lo, não para dar lucro, mas para que deixe de dar problemas. Numa analogia deste tipo, o carro velho é aquele ativo do qual ignoramos se nos dará mais problemas ou soluções. Nunca sabemos se cada reparação que temos de pagar é mesmo a última nem se a despesa de manter o carro compensa. Nessa situação, o que muita gente faz é procurar alguém que fique com o carro velho em troca de lhe pagar o seguro e lhe fazer a inspeção, de lhe encher o tanque com combustível, e de o levar para onde não incomode.

Não admira muito que, depois de anos em que os problemas da banca nacional nos puxaram sempre para baixo, haja quem olhe para o Novo Banco assim. Mas é um erro sério que o governo tenha decidido desta forma. Vejamos porquê.

Em primeiro lugar, é óbvio que o Novo Banco não é um carro velho. O antigo BES, de que o Novo Banco saiu, era um banco com uma enorme presença na economia portuguesa, grande prestador de crédito às empresas e destinatário de uma boa parte da poupança nacional. O banco foi sugado por dentro pelos negócios da família Espírito Santo, que no processo ainda conseguiu afundar a Portugal Telecom, e tem sido muito difícil separar a parte saudável da parte doente do BES. No entanto, aquilo que sobra tem um papel a desempenhar no desenvolvimento do país e seria decisivo que o governo estribasse no Novo Banco uma parte das suas ações no relançamento económico de Portugal. Isto aconselharia à nacionalização do banco, tendo em vista a sua reconversão e uma eventual venda num período de completo restabelecimento da economia pós-crise.

O segundo problema não é só o da privatização em geral, mas desta privatização em particular, em que o novo dono do Novo Banco passa a ser John Grayken, da Lone Star. Escrevi em janeiro que “países avisados não deixam John Grayken entrar no seu sistema bancário”, e mantenho. John Grayken enriqueceu a comprar bancos falidos, a desfazê-los e a vender os pedaços lucrativos. O estado português sabe isso, e a Lone Star sabe que sabemos. Por isso ambos se precaveram contra o outro numa teia de obrigações que permanece para lá da privatização.

Como é evidente, a nacionalização teria um custo orçamental e um custo político. O custo orçamental imediato não se sabe se contaria para o défice mas contaria certamente para a dívida pública. E o custo político seria interno e externo, ao que poderemos acrescentar a dificuldade de encontrar uma gestão estratégica para o Novo Banco complementar à da Caixa Geral de Depósitos (e enfermando de todos os problemas que esta tem: todas as decisões de gestão, do fecho de balcões aos possíveis despedimentos, passam a ser também decisões políticas). Mas convém não esquecer as vantagens da nacionalização: o estado manteria mais poder sobre o setor bancário nacional, o Novo Banco poderia tornar-se lucrativo a prazo e teríamos mais certeza de que o seu papel na economia nacional não seria desvirtuado.


Se tivéssemos tratado o Novo Banco como um ativo de que valeria a pena cuidar, ele daria trabalho no presente mas seria útil no futuro próximo e lucrativo lá mais para a frente. Se, por outro lado, tratamos o Novo Banco como um carro velho, o seu novo dono vai querer o habitual: que nos responsabilizemos por qualquer avaria que apareça enquanto ele desmonta as peças e vende pelo melhor dinheiro. Sendo assim, podemos ter despachado o Novo Banco — mas não nos despachámos dos problemas do Novo Banco.

Novo Banco: Ainda bem que se fez este péssimo negócio
António Costa
Ontem

O acordo de cedência do Novo Banco ao Lone Star é um péssimo negócio. É o possível, não há melhor, e poderia ser pior. Só falta que o expliquem de forma verdadeira e para que toda a gente o entenda.

A venda (?) do Novo Banco ao fundo Lone Star tem o mérito de resolver mais um problema do sistema financeiro português, mas os termos deste acordo – ainda condicionado à imposição de novas perdas a obrigacionistas seniores… outra vez – têm outro virtude: põem fim a um conjunto de mitos sobre a resolução do BES, a qualidade do balanço do Novo Banco, a ausência de garantias do Estado, as alternativas a uma venda e a força do governo, deste ou de outro, perante as instâncias europeias. Vamos falar em português corrente, para que todos possam entender um negócio em que o Lone Star fica com 75% do capital e injeta mil milhões no Novo Banco, o Estado com 25% através do Fundo de Resolução e, depois, presta uma garantia pública no valor de 3,9 mil milhões de euros para cobrir os riscos de créditos problemáticos.

Comecemos pela resolução do BES no dia 3 de agosto de 2014. A resolução foi uma experiência europeia imposta a Portugal, pela primeira vez num banco de caráter sistémico na zona euro. E o governo de Passos Coelho, porque tinha sido o campeão da saída limpa, alinhou na festa. Deixou o governador do Banco de Portugal à frente do carro, a conduzir sozinho, e depois daqueles prejuízos gigantescos – de 3,5 mil milhões – o BES estava à beira do precipício e deu um passo em frente. Resolvido num fim de semana, pré-anunciado por Marques Mendes, do BES, nasceu um Novo Banco e ficou um ‘BES mau’ para trás. Hoje, sabe-se, ‘para trás’ é uma força de expressão. Desde a sua criação e até setembro de 2016, últimos dados disponíveis, o Novo Banco acumulou prejuízos de 1.800 milhões de euros.

Depois, nesse fim de semana, foi decidido capitalizar o Novo Banco com 4,9 mil milhões de euros. Supunha-se, o capital suficiente para permitir uma nova vida ao Novo Banco. Mentira. Deveriam explicar-nos, hoje, o que justificou aquele balanço, aquela avaliação de ativos e passivos. Quase três anos depois, já se arranjaram várias soluções para ‘meter’ dinheiro no Novo Banco. Os lesados do Grupo Espírito Santo (GES) perderam a ‘almofada financeira’ que lhes tinha sido prometida, os obrigacionistas seniores perderam mais de dois mil milhões de euros e o Novo Banco foi fazendo, neste período, a venda de ativos problemáticos que ajudaram a ‘limpar’ um balanço de um Novo Banco com créditos velhos e de difícil cobrança. Sempre a somar.

Já tinha havido uma primeira tentativa de venda do Novo Banco. Falhou, e verdadeiramente não se sabem as razões. Mas uma coisa ficou clara, o Banco de Portugal não estava nem está talhado para vender bancos, coisa que lhe está cometida por ser (ainda) a entidade de resolução bancária em Portugal. Deve concentrar-se na supervisão, e como se percebe pelos sucessivos problemas de bancos em Portugal, não é coisa pouca, nem coisa fácil. Foi isso, aliás, que levou Carlos Costa a contratar Sérgio Monteiro para coordenar o segundo processo de venda do Novo Banco. Foi a melhor decisão.

Passados quase 15 meses sobre a abertura de um novo concurso, ficou um candidato firme à compra do Novo Banco. E não foi nenhum banco do sistema, nem sequer uma instituição financeira de outro país. Foi um fundo de private equity norte-americano especializado na gestão de ativos imobiliários. Este é o primeiro ponto relevante desta negociação e dá a ideia das condições desfavoráveis desta negociação. Do ponto de partida. Mostra, também, que o Novo Banco não era propriamente um tesouro, nem sequer escondido, mas um banco a tentar fazer pela vida, em circunstâncias muito difíceis, com um passado recente traumático, e não apenas financeiro.

O acordo com o Lone Star é um péssimo negócio para o Estado. Mas não há melhor, e poderia ser pior. As alternativas também. Não é péssimo para todos, é bom para o Lone Star, mas por alguma razão o fundo ficou sozinho. Só quem estava iludido, pode estar desiludido. O que está implícito nos termos deste acordo é uma resolução do Novo Banco, uma nova divisão entre banco bom e banco mau, embora debaixo da mesma marca. Para falar em bom português, com este negócio, o governo deu a parte boa do Novo Banco ao Lone Star, contra uma capitalização de mil milhões de euros, e pôs o Estado, através do Fundo de Resolução, a assumir o risco financeiro e de gestão dos créditos problemáticos que o Novo Banco ainda tem. E são muitos.

Deu uma garantia de 3,9 mil milhões de euros – chamemos as coisas pelo seu nome próprio, mesmo com nome de família diferente – e vai ganhar tempo na gestão destes créditos, com a secreta esperança de que se recupere o valor desses empréstimos de forma a limitar as perdas desta garantia, que tem o nome pomposo de ‘mecanismo de capital contingente’. A diferença tem também a ver com a forma como esta garantia vai impactar as contas públicas. Ao longo do tempo, em função da sua utilização, e não já em 2017, quando é constituída.

Há alguma defesa do Estado? Há, e reforçada face às garantias clássicas. Os créditos que estão protegidos são decididos pelo Fundo de Resolução, que pode ceder a sua gestão a terceiros. Por outro lado, a utilização desta garantia, criativa e engenhosa – mérito de Sérgio Monteiro – tem um conjunto de regras que limita os riscos. Por exemplo, só pode ser usada se os rácios de capital do Novo Banco baixarem de um determinado nível e não em função de um crédito isolado. . O novo dono está proibido de distribuir dividendos durante oito anos, os mesmos da validade deste garantia, o mecanismo de capital contigente. Ou seja, os incentivos, do Estado e do Lone Star, estão alinhados no mesmo sentido. Dito isto, só existe porque existe risco e acreditar que o Estado se livrará deste contingente sem custos é uma ingenuidade. Ou outra coisa.

Sim, a garantia é do Estado através do Fundo de Resolução, que é financiado pelos bancos do sistema, mas como este fundo não tem dinheiro, serão os contribuintes a assumir o primeiro risco, o de emprestarem o dinheiro necessário para fazer face às perdas que aí vêm. O Estado, todos nós, vai endividar-se para o fazer, e vai fazê-lo agora, mas se os créditos se perderam ao ponto de ser necessária a utilização dos 3,9 mil milhões de euros, cenário mais do que possível, os bancos vão começar a devolver este empréstimo a partir de… 2046. Sim, leu bem, com um período de carência de 30 anos. Até lá, estão a pagar cerca de 200 milhões por ano do empréstimo anterior. A perpetuidade é o limite. É o equilíbrio possível para não não rebentar com os bancos e os respetivos acionistas.

É por estas razões, e por outras, que o primeiro-ministro deveria poupar-nos a afirmações que fez no anúncio do acordo. “Não há garantia, nem direta nem indireta”, diz Costa. Quer mesmo manter a afirmação!? É justo reconhecer-lhe, a ele e a Mário Centeno, a perseverança nos processos do sistema financeiro, com trambolhões aqui e ali pelo meio, nas negociações com Bruxelas. Mas também se exige respeito pelos contribuintes e pelos eleitores. A política não justifica tudo. Há dois anos, o uso do Fundo de Resolução tinha custos para os contribuintes, agora já não há riscos nenhuns. Pedro Passos Coelho e Assunção Cristas cometem o mesmo pecado. A diferença? Mudaram de lado. (Mais) coerentes neste ponto são o BE e o PCP. Mas, também estes, falam muito, para os seus eleitores, mas não vão fazer nada. O poder é o que é… e é melhor tê-lo, não é?

E alternativas, há? Há, mas são… inviáveis. Se os termos deste negócio são o que são, a nacionalização seria assumir estes riscos já à cabeça – o primeiro-ministro falou em 4,7 mil milhões de euros – e arriscar outros, pesados, no futuro. Alguém pode dizer que a fatura ficaria fechada aqui? Não nos esquecemos do que ainda há a pagar do BPN, um banco que tinha uma quota reduzida no mercado, incomparável com a posição do Novo Banco, que, nas empresas, domina cerca de 20% do mercado. E a CGD, que ainda agora recebeu mais 2,5 mil milhões em capital público.

Além disso, há outro ‘pormaior’: quem disse que a Comissão Europeia, e as Direção-Geral da Concorrência (DGComp) aceitaria tal decisão? Se impôs tantos entraves e limitações à posição de 25% no capital, isto é, sem votos e sem administradores, o que leva a considerar que aceitaria a nacionalização? Nada.

Se ninguém quer falar da liquidação, com data marcada a 3 de agosto, regra geral porque o país ainda não está preparado para isso e, com toda a certeza, seria feita à pressa, como sucedeu com a resolução do Banif, há quem defenda dois outros caminhos:

O governo deveria ter vendido 100% e não deveria ter assumidos riscos e garantias;
O governo deveria ter negociado um alargamento do prazo de venda do Novo Banco.
Quer uma, quer outra solução partem de pressupostos errados. Mas se só houve um candidato e com tantas garantias dadas, seria possível encontrar compradores sem o Estado assumir riscos e a parte má do Novo Banco? Não. E, quanto ao tempo, a história mostra-nos que o Novo Banco perderia valor se estivesse mais tempo numa situação de indefinição, os problemas que já tem agravar-se-iam, os que não tem apareceriam por falta de capital.

O governo de Costa fechou este negócio, Passos Coelho e Assunção Cristas não teriam feito melhor. Poderiam vender o negócio de outra forma, poderiam ter feito uma ou outra opção diferentes, mas no que é essencial, a última decisão não é portuguesa, é de Bruxelas. Foi o que se viu nos poderes conferidos ao Fundo de Resolução decorrentes da participação de 25%. Também seriam obrigados a dar garantias públicas através do Fundo de Resolução, porque, no essencial, o Novo Banco tem duas caras, a de uma equipa comercial junto das empresas do melhor que os bancos têm, uma carteira de empréstimos e de participações que são uma fonte de perdas, presentes e futuras. Parecem características contraditórias, não são.

O governo foi a jogo, já tinha ido com a CGD, foi outra vez com o Novo Banco. Cometeu erros, passou linhas que nos recordaram outro tipo de intervenções passadas com tão maus resultados, assumiu os resultados. Pedro Passos Coelho perdeu por falta de comparência no sistema financeiro. Não entrou sequer em campo, apostou tudo na saída limpa e no esforço, esse feito, nas contas públicas, deixou a banca para outras rondas, convencido de que o sistema teria capacidade para se regenerar à medida da economia. Não teve.

O que falta fazer para o acordo passar a negócio? Impor perdas a obrigacionistas que, de uma maneira ou de outra, resultem em 500 milhões de euros no rácio ‘common equity tier 1’. Uma troca de dívida que o Banco de Portugal e a gestão do Novo Banco puseram em cima da mesa, o Lone Star agradeceu e o BCE elogiou. Por redução dos prazos e dos juros, ou de ambos. É um modelo voluntário, ao contrário do que sucedeu no final de 2015. Os investidores, alguns, não vão gostar, vão desconfiar, e só não vão fugir se não puderem. Provavelmente, não vão ter alternativa, porque a alternativa é a liquidação. E aí, vão perder muito mais. Esta operação, aliás, tem de estar fechada para que o negócio com o Lone Star avance.

Finalmente, vamos saber com detalhe o que o Lone Star quer fazer do Novo Banco. O plano de reestruturação imposto por Bruxelas tem de passar para o business plan do Novo Banco, exatamente como aconteceu com a CGD. Para já há uma aprovação informal, a formal vai depender do plano que vier a ser feito. E, aqui, a exigência de Bruxelas e a agressividade do Lone Star vão no mesmo sentido. Uma reestruturação rápida e profunda.

Tudo somado, ainda bem que se fez este péssimo negócio. Amanhã, provavelmente, seria pior.

Diplomacy rocks / Brexit talks turn ugly over Gibraltar



Diplomacy rocks
                By Jim Brunsden
April 3, 2017
Financial Times / Brussels Briefing

We cannot know for certain what Alfonso Dastis, Spain’s foreign minister, thought to himself on Sunday when he switched on the television and saw that Michael Howard, a former British minister, was talking about war to protect Gibraltar, but he might well have permitted himself a smile.

The past few days have been a diplomatic masterclass from Madrid.

When it comes to the Gibraltar row, Spain secured a mention of the territory in the EU’s draft Brexit negotiating guidelines that has little legal relevance but that amounts to a political coup: it means other capitals are being publicly respectful of Madrid’s sensitivities when it comes to the British overseas territory.

In contrast to José Manuel García-Margallo, his combative predecessor as Spain’s foreign minister, Mr Dastis, has shown a subtle touch that is good at winning friends without requiring any ceding of precious diplomatic ground.

That was fully on display last week, when he signalled a softening of Madrid’s reservations about an independent Scotland joining the EU.

Speaking to El País, Mr Dastis, a former Spanish ambassador to the EU, said that “at first glance” he “did not foresee” any need to block a Scottish application.

Pro-Union politicians in London, from Theresa May downwards, have cited inevitable Spanish resistance as a crucial stumbling block for an independent Scotland trying to join the EU. The argument wasn’t without merit: Madrid was vocally against Scottish secession during the 2014 independence referendum - a position linked to its concerns about any precedent that could embolden separatists in Catalonia.

In his comments to El País, Mr Dastis sounded reasonable without really giving anything away: Scotland could apply, but there’s no guarantee what would come of the accession talks. Also, the holy grail for Scottish nationalists has always been fast-tracked EU membership, not the meagre right to start the process from square one.

Similarly, in the Gibraltar row, Madrid is the capital that has come out looking reasonable; the bellicose language has been emanating from London.

Madrid can bask in a diplomatic success, without having demanded, or secured, any change in the situation on the ground. In fact, the main people talking about a threat to British sovereignty are British and Gibraltarian politicians and newspapers.

Mr Dastis, in his El País interview, could content himself with acknowledging a new political reality:

“We have talked with our partners and the [EU] institutions in recent weeks and we have made the Spanish position clear,” he said.

“When the United Kingdom leaves the EU, then the EU’s partner is Spain, and that when it comes to Gibraltar the EU is obliged, as a result, to take the side of Spain.”

Email: jim.brunsden@ft.com Twitter: @jimbrunsden

Brexit in the Med

Rock bottom Those looking for evidence that Gibraltar occupies a special space in the British psyche need look no further than the, in some quarters utterly bonkers, reactions to the reference to Gibraltar included in the EU’s draft Brexit negotiating guidelines.

The offending sentence simply says that once Britain has left the EU, no deal between the EU and the UK “may apply to the territory of Gibraltar without the agreement between the Kingdom of Spain and the United Kingdom”.

The statement has little, if any, legal meaning (see our explainer here) but this hasn’t prevented British politicians reaching for a sabre to rattle:

The tensions were laid bare when Michael Howard, former Tory leader, recalled how Margaret Thatcher sent troops to the Falklands in 1982 “to defend the freedom of another small group of British people against another Spanish-speaking country”.

Lord Howard yesterday told Sky News he was “absolutely certain” Mrs May would “show the same resolve in standing by the people of Gibraltar”. Defence secretary Michael Fallon said Britain would go “all the way” to defend its 300-year-old territory.

Gunboat diplomacy While war over a draft EU document prepared by a centrist politician from Poland is not immediately on the cards, that didn’t stop the Telegraph getting into the spirit of things:

Britain's Royal Navy is substantially weaker than it was during the Falklands War but could still "cripple" Spain, military experts have said.


Rear-Adml Chris Parry, a former director of operational capability at the Ministry of Defence,  has called on the Government to "appropriately" invest in Britain's military capacity if it wants to "talk big" over Gibraltar.



Brexit talks turn ugly over Gibraltar

By ANDREW RETTMAN
BRUSSELS, TODAY, 09:21

Britain has said Spain can have no new powers over Gibraltar, as Brexit prompts hard talk on sovereignty, security, and borders.
“We will never enter into arrangements under which the people of Gibraltar would pass under the sovereignty of another state against their freely and democratically expressed wishes”, the British prime minister’s office said in a statement on Sunday (2 April).

The British defence minister, foreign minister, and the chief minister of Gibraltar issued similar comments in a debate prompted by the start of Brexit talks last week.
“Gibraltar is going to be protected all the way,” Michael Fallon, the defence chief, told the BBC on Sunday.

Boris Johnson, the foreign minister, said on Facebook: “The UK remains implacable and rock-like in our support for Gibraltar.”

Fabian Picardo, the Gibraltar chief, told the BBC that life under Spain would be “absolutely ­awful”. He told the Financial Times newspaper that the UK should stand up to EU “bullies” and “blackmail”.

The Gibraltar issue came up after the EU published its draft guidelines for Brexit talks last Friday.

The draft said “no agreement” on a future EU-UK trade deal “may apply to the territory of Gibraltar without the agreement between the Kingdom of Spain and the United Kingdom”.


The text indicates that Spain would have a veto over Gibraltar’s economic future.

It might amount to little more than trying to force the British outpost to change its super-low corporate tax rate.

Hard talk
But the rock, which Britain seized from Spain in 1704, has a history of provoking tensions over status and territorial zones.

Michael Howard, a former leader of the ruling Conservative Party in the UK, told the Sky News broadcaster on Sunday that Britain would go to war with Spain over Gibraltar the same way it did with Argentina over the Falkland Islands in 1983.

“Thirty-five years ago this week, another woman prime minister sent a taskforce halfway across the world to defend the freedom of another small group of British people against another Spanish-speaking country, and I’m absolutely certain that our current prime minister will show the same resolve in standing by the people of Gibraltar,” he said.

“I can see no harm in reminding them [the EU] what kind of people we are,” he said.

British anti-EU tabloids, such as The Sun and The Express, cited a former British military commander in saying the UK could crush the Spanish navy.

The Brexit talks will also have to deal with thorny questions on Scotland, Ireland, and security cooperation as well as trade and freedom of movement for EU workers.

Scotland has said it wants to hold a second referendum on independence in order to remain in the EU.

Irish politicians have said there should be a referendum on Irish unification with Northern Ireland to prevent the reimposition of a hard border after Brexit.

The UK, last week, also indicated it might hold back on security cooperation with the EU if the trade talks go badly.

Scottish question
The Scottish question risks further enflaming tensions with Spain after Madrid said at the weekend that it would not stand in the way of an independent Scotland joining the EU.

Alfonso Dastis, the Spanish foreign minister, told the El Pais newspaper on Saturday that he did “not foresee that we would block” Scottish membership.

Spain had previously indicated it would block Scotland in order not to create a precedent for separatists in the Spanish region of Catalonia, but Dastis said the two cases were “not comparable” on constitutional grounds.

Fallon, the British defence chief, indicated on Sunday that the UK wanted to maintain security cooperation with Europe despite the nasty rhetoric.

“What we’re now looking for is a deep and special partnership which covers both economic and security cooperation,” he told the BBC.


“We need to make sure that cooperation continues because Europe faces threats not only from Russian aggression but, as we’ve seen in recent weeks, from terrorism as well,” he said, referring to last month's terrorist attack in London.

Theresa May would go to war to protect Gibraltar, Michael Howard says







Theresa May would go to war to protect Gibraltar, Michael Howard says

Former Tory leader suggests PM would act to protect Gibraltar’s sovereignty as Margaret Thatcher did for the Falklands

Anushka Asthana Political editor
Sunday 2 April 2017 13.15 BST First published on Sunday 2 April 2017 11.17 BST

Theresa May would be prepared to go to war to protect Gibraltar as Margaret Thatcher once did for the Falklands, former Conservative leader Michael Howard has suggested, in comments that were immediately criticised as inflammatory.

Lord Howard’s suggestion that the prime minister would be ready to follow in the footsteps of her predecessor 35 years ago came alongside a government pledge to protect the sovereignty of Britain’s overseas territory.

Downing Street said May had called Fabian Picardo, the chief minister of Gibraltar, on Sunday morning to say the UK remained “steadfastly committed to our support for Gibraltar, its people and its economy”.

She said Britain would never enter into arrangements that would bring the territory under Spanish rule against the “freely and democratically expressed wishes” of its residents, and promised to include the local administration in the Brexit process.

Sir Michael Fallon, the defence secretary, also used robust language. “We’re going to look after Gibraltar. Gibraltar is going to be protected all the way because the sovereignty cannot be changed without the agreement of the people of Gibraltar ,” he said.

Although the question of Gibraltar had been included in the EU’s draft negotiating guidelines, circulated on Friday, Fallon attempted to ratchet down the controversy, on the BBC’s Andrew Marr Show, by stressing that Spain had not specifically raised any issue of sovereignty.

‘Gibraltar is going to be protected all the way’, says UK defence secretary
Speaking minutes later, Howard used a broadcast interview to ramp up the rhetoric after saying there was “no question” of Britain weakening its stance with regards to the sovereignty of one of its overseas territories.

 “Thirty-five years ago this week, another woman prime minister sent a taskforce halfway across the world to defend the freedom of another small group of British people against another Spanish-speaking country, and I’m absolutely certain that our current prime minister will show the same resolve in standing by the people of Gibraltar,” Howard told Sophy Ridge on Sunday on Sky News.

The comments triggered an immediate response from Liberal Democrat leader, Tim Farron. “It is unbelievable that within a week of triggering article 50 there are Conservatives already discussing potential wars with our European neighbours.

“In only a few days the Conservative right are turning long term allies into potential enemies. I hope this isn’t a sign of the government’s approach to the long negotiations to come.”

He claimed Brexite rs had gone from cheering to “sabre-rattling for war” within four days. “It is absolutely ludicrous and totally inflammatory.”

Earlier, Picardo had flown to the UK to appear on Marr . He told presenter Eddie Mair that the government had included Gibraltar in its preparations for Brexit talks, and included the issue in a white paper, even if it was not specifically referred to in May’s article 50 notification letter.

Admitting he was n ot thrilled about Brexit after people in Gibraltar voted 96% in favour of remain, he said he was now energetically supporting the prime minister.

“Therein lies the rub. When we get the deal on Brexit, it must be a deal that applies across the United Kingdom in respect of future trade and if there is such a deal, it is only fair, proper and right that it should also apply to Gibraltar.”

In his interview, Fallon also said Britain and the remaining members of the EU would all be “worse off” if negotiators failed to secure a deal, as he reiterated a warning that the UK could withdraw security cooperation if Brexit talks fail.

Asked about the controversy surrounding May’s apparent threat to weaken security cooperation if Brexit talks turn sour, Fallon said the negotiations had to cover both a trade deal and issues such as counter-terrorism and police cooperation.

“It is very important to link trade and security because what we are now looking for is a deep and special relationship that covers both economic and security cooperation. Those two things go together,” he said.

“It is very important that we go on committed to the security of the continent.”

Fallon then talked about sending 800 troops to Estonia, others to Poland, and RAF Typhoons to Romania, which are all under Britain’s Nato commitments not linked to EU membership.

“We are stepping up security because it remains our continent and this is a very uncertain time for Europe and right we should be playing our time on that. We’d all be worse off if there wasn’t a deal – we are expecting to have a deal.”

The defence secretary admitted some issues were inside the European treaties, and others (including Nato) not.

“The letter refers to our ambition to have a completely new partnership on the economic side but also on security side,” he said, arguing that stating a fact about defence capabilities wasn’t a threat.

 “This isn’t a bargaining process. We happen to have the biggest defence budget in Europe, we have the biggest navy in Europe.”

In admitting the government would do everything it could to avoid a “cliff edge”, he would not give full assurances that his party would enter a 2020 election having secured controls on free movement.

“We have made it clear that we are leaving the European Union, we are leaving the single market, we are leaving the customs union, and we will no longer be a part of the ambit of the ECJ. But it is also clear that we have to avoid a cliff edge – we need to give businesses the certainty that they need that there won’t suddenly be a difference the day after we leave and day before.

“We will do everything we can to avoid a cliff edge so there will be for some sectors inevitably implementation periods,” he said.


Asked if free movement could then continue beyond 2020, he added: “You are speculating about the course of the negotiations. We are not expecting to take advantage of the four great freedoms – our object is to regain control of migration.”

How the return of traditional skills is boosting Italy's economy

UM EXEMPLO A TER EM CONTA EM PORTUGAL !?
How the return of traditional skills is boosting Italy's economy
Artisan revival proves a boon for sluggish economy that has unemployment rate of 12%


A marketing campaign has reignited interest in artisan careers. Photograph: FabioBalbi/Getty Images/iStockphoto

Angela Giuffrida in Penne
Saturday 1 April 2017 14.58 BST Last modified on Saturday 1 April 2017 15.53 BST

There aren’t any smartphones distracting the budding couturiers at the tailoring school run by Brioni, the venerable menswear company, in Penne, a medieval town nestled in the heart of Italy’s mountainous Abruzzo region.

Instead, their nimble fingers are delicately sewing stitches on to jacket sleeves. They are nurturing the skills that could lead to a job in a fashion house whose sleek suits have been worn by kings, presidents and 007s Pierce Brosnan and Daniel Craig in their roles as James Bond.

The teenagers are the lucky group of 16 to have made the cut for the latest four-year programme at Brioni’s Scuola Di Alta Sartoria (High School of Tailoring), which in recent years has seen an uptick in applications from young Italians keen to learn the trade.

They are among a generation in Italy who are turning to industries that formed the backbone of the country’s post-world war two economy, with some skipping university in the process, amid a lacklustre job market.

“They join aged 13 or 14,” said Emidio Fonticoli, the school’s coordinator. “It’s important that they start young, due to the sensitivity of their hands and fingers. It’s an important time for them to develop manual skills, so much so they reach such a level of tactility, they can work without looking.”

But it’s not all blazers, belt loops and buttonholes: the aspiring tailors study maths, English and history as part of a combined school curriculum also aimed at readying them for the world of work in case they decide not to pursue tailoring.

Upon completion, the best are selected to work in the local factory, or in one of the company’s boutiques around the world. The most passionate ones succeed.


Italians are rediscovering their entrepreneurial spirit. Photograph: seraficus/Getty Images

“The artisanal tradition is a cultural legacy that takes decades to transmit from a seasoned master to a young talent and despite common thoughts, a large number of young people continue to express their desire and will to learn the secrets of those crafts,” added Fonticoli.

Concerned about its ageing needle workers, Brioni opened the tailoring school in 1985 to ensure their skills were passed on. But it is not the only firm helping to revive the image of the traditional artisan, thus piquing the interest of young Italians.

“Working with your hands is becoming interesting,” Stefano Micelli, a professor at Venice’s Ca’ Foscari university and author of the book Future Craftsman, said, pointing to the allure of the “Made in Italy” brand and advertising campaigns by the likes of the fashion house Pucci and Brunello Cucinelli, famous for its cashmere jumpers, promoting a fresh image of the artisan.

“This [the advertising campaign] made a very important impact on a new generation who are thinking about craftsmanship in a different way.”

The revival has also filtered down to small businesses, with Italians rediscovering their entrepreneurial spirit, whether it be in shoe-making, hairdressing, tailoring or making pasta.

“This is a very Italian thing, we do have this long tradition in the small business area, it’s part of our culture,” added Micelli.

New technology and a push by regional and local level governments to help facilitate the growth of startups, particularly in the business hub of Milan, are also playing their part.

“The policies that are relevant to this new way of doing business don’t necessarily belong to the state government, but rather the local and regional municipalities,” said Micelli. “But I would stress that it’s not about being nostalgic and going back to the past, it’s about the future, technology, and being innovative.”

Driven both by curiosity and the need to find a job in a country where youth unemployment has almost doubled to 37.9% within the last 10 years, Federico Badia is an example of someone who set out to learn the secrets of his craft – but without the help of an esteemed school.

The 29-year-old shoemaker, who owns a shop in Orvieto, a hilltop town in Umbria, didn’t go to university and instead travelled across Italy in his early 20s looking for an apprenticeship.

He developed a passion for the craft while working for a cobbler in his teens, after stumbling across a pair of shoes that a customer had left for repair 38 years before.

The shop closed after the cobbler retired, and so he set out on a journey that took him to Turin, Florence and Milan in search of a master. Earning his keep by waiting on tables, he was rejected by all until he walked into a shoemaker’s shop in Rome and offered to work for free in exchange for being taught.

“By the time I got to Rome, I realised that I didn’t need a job, I needed to learn,” he said. “I worked for free for almost two years. Spending money on going to a school or university is easy but if you’re really passionate, you will find a way.”

Italy has one of the most sluggish economies in the European Union, with the overall unemployment rate standing at 11.7% in January, figures from Istat, the national statistics agency, showed.

But there are some signs of recovery among small artisanal businesses, with hiring among them rising 2.3% in 2016, according to data from CNA, the national confederation of artisans and small businesses.

Claudio Giovine, a chief economist at CNA, said this is partly due to the economy in general performing mildly better and firms having more flexibility with work contracts.

There has been a trend among school leavers veering towards traditional trades, but also among graduates striking out alone, he added.

“They are starting to rediscover the sartorial value in products, providing something custom-made, as well as the importance of Italy, which is at the forefront of things that are well made.”

Badia, who now sells shoes from upwards of €1,000, learnt from his shoe master that the most important requirement of an artisan was to be humble, which is also part of the Brioni tailoring school philosophy.


“Then, if you become a great artisan, it doesn’t matter where the shop is, if you’re humble and make a good product, the customers will come.”

Salmon farming in crisis: 'We are seeing a chemical arms race in the seas'


Salmon farming in crisis: 'We are seeing a chemical arms race in the seas'
Rare only 40 years ago, farmed salmon is now taken for granted in our kitchens. But the growth of the industry has come at great cost

John Vidal
Saturday 1 April 2017 11.00 BST Last modified on Saturday 1 April 2017 11.15 BST

Every day, salmon farmers across the world walk into steel cages – in the seas off Scotland or Norway or Iceland – and throw in food. Lots of food; they must feed tens of thousands of fish before the day is over. They must also check if there are problems, and there is one particular problem they are coming across more and more often. Six months ago, I met one of these salmon farmers, on the Isle of Skye. He looked at me and held out a palm – in it was a small, ugly-looking creature, all articulated shell and tentacles: a sea louse. He could crush it between his fingers, but said he was impressed that this parasite, which lives by attaching itself to a fish and eating its blood and skin, was threatening not just his own job, but could potentially wipe out a global multibillion-dollar industry that feeds millions of people.

“For a wee creature, it is impressive. But what can we do?” he asks. “Sometimes it seems nature is against us and we are fighting a losing battle. They are everywhere now, and just a few can kill a fish. When I started in fish farming 30 years ago, there were barely any. Now they are causing great problems.”

Lepeophtheirus salmonis, or the common salmon louse, now infests nearly half of Scotland’s salmon farms. Last year lice killed thousands of tonnes of farmed fish, caused skin lesions and secondary infections in millions more, and cost the Scottish industry alone around £300m in trying to control them.

Scotland has some of the worst lice infestations in the world, and last year saw production fall for the first time in years. But in the past few weeks it has become clear that the lice problem is growing worldwide and is far more resistant than the industry thought. Norway produced 60,000 tonnes less than expected last year because of lice, and Canada and a dozen other countries were all hit badly. Together, it is estimated that companies across the world must spend more than £1bn a year on trying to eradicate lice, and the viruses and diseases they bring.

As a result of the lice infestations, the global price of salmon has soared, and world production fallen. Earlier this year freedom of information [FoI] requests of the Scottish government showed that 45 lochs had been badly polluted by the antibiotics and pesticides used to control lice – and that more and more toxic chemicals were being used.

The salmon-farming industry, which has grown at breakneck speed since the 1970s, knows it has a huge problem, but insists it sees the lice as unwelcome guests that will soon be evicted rather than permanent residents. Rather than dwell on the lice, industry leaders point to the fact that in just 40 years, aquaculture has gone from providing 5% of the world’s fish to nearly 50%, and in Scotland, from a few hundred tonnes of salmon a year to more than 177,000 tonnes in 2015. They argue that new methods to control infestations are being developed and the chemicals being used are safe and degrade quickly, adding that they expect to have found a solution within a few years.

“Sea lice are a natural phenomenon,” says Scott Landsburgh, chief executive of the Scottish salmon producers association. “All livestock on farms, terrestrial or marine, are encountering some kind of parasite or tick, and they’re dealt with. And that’s part of livestock farming. We are no different to terrestrial farms. Problems come and go, depending on biology and the environment. The louse is a hardy parasite. It’s a challenge for Chile and Norway, too. We are spending a lot on all sorts of things.”

The global companies that dominate ownership of the farms, buoyed by high prices and growing worldwide demand, are confident that they will find solutions. Marine Harvest, the giant Norwegian multinational that grows 40,000 tonnes of salmon in its many Scottish farms, said this week that it needs to develop more effective ways to combat lice. “As a relatively young industry, we hope that through industry collaboration, research, transparency and sharing of knowledge, we can make the necessary changes to do better, and keep getting better,” says Alf-Helge Aarskog, CEO. “One company alone cannot solve all sustainability challenges.”

Meanwhile, they urge the public to celebrate the fact that the Atlantic salmon, which used to complete an extraordinary journey across oceans to breed in British rivers, is now taken for granted in our kitchens and, in an act of ecological democratisation, has been transformed from something special enjoyed by the few into the most popular fish eaten in Britain.

‘They are everywhere now, and just a few can kill a fish’ … the Lepeophtheirus salmonis, or the common salmon louse. Photograph: Alamy
If the nemesis of the farmed Atlantic salmon is the sea louse, then Don Staniford, who runs the small Global Alliance Against Industrial Aquaculture, is the industry’s persecutor-in-chief. The former University of East Anglia scientist turned activist and investigator has spent 20 years tracking the industry, seeing it grow from a shrimp into a shark, which, he says, is now close to destroying itself.

I last heard Staniford talk in London in 2012, when he gave a lecture at the National Geographic Society, calling fish farms “toxic toilets” and warning that diseases were rife, waste was out of control and the use of chemicals was growing fast. Not only were fish farms getting bigger, he said, they were also becoming reservoirs for infectious diseases and parasites. It was a shocking, revealing talk. I did not know that farmed salmon were fed partly on fishmeal and fish oil, often derived from ocean fish such as anchovies, herring and sardines. Despite industry claims that industrial aquaculture feeds the world’s poor, it seemed that the big farms were adding to the pressure on the depletion of the oceans.

Staniford, a Liverpudlian who has lived in Scotland for many years, argued that cramming carnivorous, migratory fish into crowded tanks and releasing toxins, diseases and parasites into the surrounding waters was inherently unsustainable. Unless the global salmon farming industry drastically changed course, he said, it would collapse.

This week I asked Staniford what had changed since then. Little, he replied, except that the farms had got bigger, the industry was spending even more heavily to control the lice, more fish were dying in appalling conditions and the pollution caused by their waste and the use of chemicals was becoming more serious. He has spent the past five years labelled an “eco-terrorist”, a “troublemaker”, an “exaggerator” and “a prophet of doom”. He has been sued by the industry for defamation, lost a high-profile Canadian high court battle, been heavily fined, been threatened many times, and been ordered never to repeat statements such as “wild salmon don’t do drugs” and “salmon farming spreads diseases”.

“He is an ace troublemaker. He annoys everyone … but he uses freedom of information requests to get his data and 99 times out of 100 he is right”, says Scottish investigative journalist Rob Edwards. “I am a trained scientist. I use peer-reviewed science and use the industry’s own figures,” says Staniford.

“What we are seeing now is a chemical arms race in the seas, just like on the land farms, where the resistance of plants to chemicals is growing. In fish farms, the parasites are increasing resistance to chemicals and antibiotics. There has been a 10-fold increase in the use of some chemicals in the past 18 months.” The farms are now turning to mechanical ways to delouse the fish, he says. “They are using hydro-dousers, like huge carwashes, and thermal lousing, which heats them up.” There is also the spectre of GM salmon, with companies engineering GM plants for their omega-3 to feed the fish, and a US company given permission to develop GM salmon.

 “Whichever way you look, the breeding of carnivorous fish is a nightmare. It is environmentally, socially and economically bankrupt. It’s coming to a crisis point for the industry. Some chemicals will be banned soon, and unless something significant happens, the industry will have to invest very heavily.”

The use of chemicals, especially, worries him. Last month Staniford unearthed the fact that not only was the use of the toxic drug emamectin rising fast, but also that the industry had persuaded the Scottish environmental protection agency to withdraw a ban planned for next year. Other papers showed that the levels of chemicals used to kill sea lice have breached environmental safety limits more than 100 times in the last 10 years. The chemicals have been discharged into the waters by 70 fish farms run by seven companies.

Support is growing for an investigation into the links between the industry and government. Richard Luxmoore, senior nature conservation adviser to the National Trust for Scotland, told the Daily Record in February: “The environmental standards have been put there for a good reason. It is highly worrying that they have been breached so many times. This is yet more evidence that the chemical warfare waged by fish farms against sea lice has essentially been lost, and the application of toxins to kill them is spiralling out of control.”

Meanwhile, FoI documents obtained by Stanimore show that the Scottish industry wants to “innovate” by building the world’s biggest salmon farm, which would triple the size of the largest now in operation. It could farm 2m fish at a time, and create as much waste as a city the size of Glasgow. “It would be an ecological disaster,” says Stanimore.
The answer to the inevitable lice problems, say environmentalists, is to move the farms further offshore into deeper, colder waters, where lice are less able to survive, or to even put them on land, where they could be better controlled. But this would add greatly to industry costs and require investments of billions of pounds. In the meantime, the companies are using mechanical ways to trim the lice from the fish. These range from pumping the fish through water hot enough to make the lice let go of their hosts, to churning them as if in a washing machine. Both are condemned by animal welfare group Compassion in World Farming, and are known to be expensive and not always effective. Last year the heating of the water on a Skye fish farm led to the accidental slaughter of 95,000 fish. Another 20,000 died in another incident.

“Many farmed fish are fed largely on wild fish. To produce farmed fish such as salmon, it takes about three times the weight of wild-caught fish. This is not only unsustainable, but adds to the serious welfare concerns about how wild fish are caught and slaughtered,” said a spokesman.

The smart money is now on breeding wrasse, a small fish that eats lice. It is being widely piloted and is highly promising, says Landsburgh. “We have about 100,000 fish and the wrasse have cut our losses enormously. We haven’t had to use chemicals since August 2014. Most fish farms are overcrowded, but we are not. We find lice very occasionally but 99% of the time we are completely clean,” said Pete Robinson, a worker at the Wester Ross salmon company in Ullapool. But even using wrasse is not a complete answer. New scientific studies showed this week that fish farms may be depleting wild wrasse numbers too, and to breed enough for all Scottish farms could take four or more years, says Landsburgh. “But we have to keep at it. The louse is a hardy parasite. We are doing our damnedest to eradicate it,” he said.

“There’s no right way to do the wrong thing,” says Stanimore. “The simple solution is to just stop.”

Salmon: the facts
• Salmon is the biggest-selling seafood in the UK. Most UK production is carried out by six Norwegian companies. There are about 250 salmon farms off the west coast of Scotland and its islands

• 60% of Scottish farmed salmon is sold to British consumers. Export markets are led by the US, which bought 30,000 tonnes in 2015. UK sales are more than £700m a year

food ­weekly
What's for dinner?
Sign-up for our new weekly food email and you’ll get recipes, restaurant reviews and the best of all things culinary. Whether you’re a full-on foodie or a budding gastronaut, we’ve something to sate your appetite
Sign up
• Farmed salmon are fed on oil and smaller fish, ground-up feathers, GM yeast, soybeans and chicken fat

• Wild salmon get their colour from eating krill and shrimp. The flesh of farmed salmon is grey, and is coloured by astaxanthin, a manufactured copy of the pigment that wild salmon eat in nature

• Fish is an important part of a healthy diet, and salmon are a good source of omega-3 fatty acids that can reduce the risk of cardiovascular diseases

• Farmed salmon is still good for the health. Buy from the smaller, sea-based farms that are not under pressure to overstock. There are a few good organic ones that claim to have addressed all the problems. People have to judge carefully the environmental and health issues. The good news is that both farmed and wild salmon have very low levels of m

May’s Battle of Britain truly begins


May’s Battle of Britain truly begins

PM is under pressure from hardcore Euroskeptics as well as Tory rebels who threaten to make common cause with Labour centrists.

By           TOM MCTAGUE AND CHARLIE COOPER 3/30/17, 4:09 AM CET Updated 3/31/17, 10:30 AM CET

LONDON — With Article 50 triggered, the phony war over Brexit has come to an end. Now, the real fight in Westminster begins.

So far, British Prime Minister Theresa May has had it easy. Last year’s referendum on leaving the European Union united her Conservative Party behind her, resigning all but the most Europhile Tories to the inevitability of departure. Meanwhile, the opposition Labour Party was in disarray — split in two by Brexit.

Now that dynamic is set to reverse, as the internal divisions in the Conservative Party that pushed May’s predecessor David Cameron to call the Brexit referendum in the first place begin to resurface.

On one side, May is under pressure from hardcore Euroskeptics pushing for the cleanest possible break. On the other, she’s facing for the first time an opposition with a semblance of unity, with a small, but potentially influential, band of rebels in her own ranks threatening to make common cause with centrists in the Labour Party.

As long as Article 50 remained untriggered, May could hold off debate with claims of a democratic mandate and an explanation that “Brexit means Brexit.” As negotiations with the EU begin over the shape and pace of the U.K.’s withdrawal, the battle over what Brexit really means is about to kick off — and nowhere more so than among Conservative members of the British parliament.

Labour’s Brexit spokesman Keir Starmer, who will spearhead parliamentary scrutiny of May’s negotiation, said that the job of the opposition had entered a new phase.

May’s challenge  will be to extract an outcome from her negotiations with Brussels that can survive a vote in the British parliament.

“The question now is of what future relationship we have with the EU,” he told POLITICO. “We can’t be members but we can be partners. Labour is very united on that, whereas the Conservative Party has a schism — on the backbenches and in the cabinet — between those who have always wanted to leave and those who want a closer relationship.

“The Prime Minister is now going to have to manage that over the next two years. If the PM wants to deliver a close, collaborative future she is going to have face down Brexiteers on her own side to do it.”

Narrow majority

May’s challenge will be to extract an outcome from her negotiations with Brussels that can survive a vote in the British parliament, where she has a working majority of 17.

That gives her little room to maneuver.

Euroskeptic MPs who once held Cameron to ransom over Europe have coalesced into a 59-strong faction called the European Research Group, who organize on WhatsApp. Their goal: a clean divorce from the EU, even at the cost of failing to come to an agreement and crashing out of the Union.

So far, May’s stance has kept them happy. However, members are now watching the government’s negotiating position closely. A major issue for them is the Brexit divorce bill.

Continued membership of some EU programs would be tolerated, one senior Brexiteer said, while another confirmed that limited payments to the EU budget would be acceptable to Brexiteers.

However, a large Brexit bill, closer to the European Commission’s estimate of £50 billion, is unlikely to be tolerated. One senior Brexiteer suggested that even a bill as low as £20 billion would be rejected. “She’d never get it through parliament,” the MP said.

On May’s other flank, as many as 30 Tory MPs could vote against a final deal that did not avoid a “cliff-edge” scenario for the economy, according to pro-European Conservative officials who spoke to POLITICO on condition of anonymity.

Ahead of the formal start of the Brexit negotiations, Dominic Grieve, named by one minister as the leading intellectual light of the pro-EU Tory movement, fired a warning shot at the government. “It’s important in this process that the government should be able to carry the support of the entire Conservative Party,” he said.

‘The Blair proposition’

Advocates of soft Brexit were given a new lease of life two weeks ago when, of all people, Tony Blair offered up a simple formula for opposition. The former prime minister pointed to a commitment made by Brexit Secretary David Davis in the House of Commons in January that a post-Brexit free-trade and customs agreement will deliver “the exact same benefits” the U.K. already has, and urged the opposition to hold him to account for it.

 “The Labour Party should have a very, very simple position on Brexit and I really don’t think it’s difficult at all,” an exasperated Blair told the BBC’s Andrew Marr show.

Since then, the attack line — which has come to be known as “the Blair proposition” — has been deployed prominently by Labour’s Brexit spokesman Starmer and by Nicky Morgan, a former Tory education secretary who is a leading figure in the pro-EU group Open Britain.

“Labour seems to have come to a position, which is good,” said a source close to the former prime minister, acknowledging that Blair’s attack on Davis may have been an “inspiration” to other groups.

Alastair Campbell, Tony Blair’s former director of communications who remains in regular contact with the former leader, said the resistance to May’s government was more organized than ever before.

“What we’re seeing now is a whole lot more communication and coordination between people from different parties,” he said. “I’ve had Tory MPs and even cabinet ministers coming up to me saying ‘you’ve got to keep going with this, it’s going to be a catastrophe’ and telling me debate in Cabinet is slapped down if they raise any problems.

“There is definitely a feeling this can be stopped. Everyone is talking to everyone. After months of people flailing around, we’ve got a real sense of strategic purpose and confidence.”

Starmer had deploying the “exact same benefits” line before Blair’s intervention, but it has gained more traction in recent weeks, and on Monday he included it as one of six tests which the government must meet in its Brexit deal, or lose the support of Labour MPs.

A senior Labour source confirmed to POLITICO that the party intended to vote against the government rather than abstaining if it judges the deal to be unacceptable. Starmer — in a high-stakes game of bluff — does not believe May will be able to keep insisting that, if MPs reject her deal, the U.K. will leave the EU without one.

“It’s a political inevitability that rather than leave with no deal, May would have to go back to the negotiating table in that scenario,” insisted a senior Labour official.

Since the Scottish National Party and the Liberal Democrats are almost certain to vote against the government, that would leave May dependent on pro-EU Conservatives swinging behind her Brexit deal.

Middle ground

The prime minister has long expected the real battle to begin after Article 50, one senior government official said. “It’s been clear from the start that there would be a group of people who don’t agree with the direction of travel who would coalesce.”

The scale of the challenge has sparked high-level speculation about the need for a snap general election in late 2018 or early 2019 to give May the mandate to force through the final deal before Britain leaves the EU on March 29, 2019, according to senior Conservative MPs and officials. One Tory MP close to Philip Hammond said the chancellor himself has made the case in private that an election before 2020 might be needed.

In what is both an implicit acknowledgment of weakness and an olive branch extended to May’s pro-EU critics, the government has softened its messaging.
According to one well-placed Whitehall official familiar with the government’s thinking on Brexit, May will beat the path for the U.K.’s departure with a series of votes on individual issues including customs arrangements, immigration and the Great Repeal Bill transferring EU legislation into U.K. law, which would take the sting out of the final crunch vote.

Meanwhile, the government is trying to navigate a middle course. In what is both an implicit acknowledgment of weakness and an olive branch extended to May’s pro-EU critics, the government has softened its messaging.

Faced with evidence from focus groups that the word “Brexit” has started to poll badly, officials are being told to use the much softer “new partnership with Europe,” according to the official “Brexit Narrative” guidebook produced by David Davis’ department and distributed throughout government.


On Wednesday that was upped by the prime minister to a “deep and special partnership.” It is a phrase remarkably similar to the line now deployed by Labour, which is calling for a new deal with Brussels — “not a member of the EU, but a partnership alongside it.”

Spain drops plan to impose veto if Scotland tries to join EU


Spain drops plan to impose veto if Scotland tries to join EU

Foreign minister says Madrid remains opposed to an independent Scotland, but would not block any EU application

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels
Sunday 2 April 2017 07.00 BST Last modified on Sunday 2 April 2017 08.47 BST

Spain has said it would not veto an attempt by an independent Scotland to join the EU, in a boost to Nicola Sturgeon’s campaign for a second independence referendum and the clearest sign yet that Brexit has softened Madrid’s longstanding opposition.

Alfonso Dastis, the Spanish foreign minister, made it clear that the government would not block an independent Scotland’s EU hopes, although he stressed that Madrid would not welcome the disintegration of the UK.

He also said Edinburgh would have to apply for membership, a process fraught with uncertainty that is likely to take several years. But asked directly whether Spain would veto an independent Scotland joining the EU, Dastis said: “No, we wouldn’t.”

Madrid is keen not to fuel Catalonia’s desire for independence. “We don’t want it [Scottish independence] to happen,” he said. “But if it happens legally and constitutionally, we would not block it. We don’t encourage the breakup of any member states, because we think the future goes in a different direction.”

The change in tone could prove a significant boon to Scotland’s first minister, who has repeatedly demanded the right from Westminster to hold a second independence referendum before Brexit. Scotland voted overwhelmingly to remain in the EU during the referendum last year, but it has been believed Spain would block it from rejoining if independent from the UK.

The softening stance this weekend reflects the new approach being taken by Dastis, a career diplomat, who was promoted to foreign minister last November after the centre-right prime minister, Mariano Rajoy, formed a government following 300 days of political paralysis in 2016.

In the run-up to Scotland’s 2014 independence referendum, Rajoy said Scottish independence would be a catastrophe that would risk Europe’s disintegration, but the political calculus in Madrid and Brussels has shifted since Britain voted to leave the EU.

EU leaders are more sympathetic to Scotland, where 62% voted to remain in the EU, while insisting that Scots cannot inherit Britain’s EU membership.

The European commission spelled out earlier this month that an independent Scotland would have to apply to join the bloc, a point reinforced by Dastis. “They would have to join the line of candidates at some point and would have to start negotiations,” he said.

Scotland would have no chance of winning the perks enjoyed by the UK, such as the rebate on EU payments. Current EU law also requires new joiners to sign up to the euro, an issue that would pose fundamental problems for Scotland’s trade with the rest of the UK.

Experts have suggested negotiations could take three to four years, but the timing is uncertain. EU diplomats are reluctant to get into the details of a hypothetical event, especially when the bloc’s energies are being absorbed by Brexit.

Recent polls have cast doubt on the Scottish appetite to abandon the UK for a closer relationship with Europe. A study by the NatCen social research organisation found that Scots wanted similar controls on immigration to people from other parts of the UK.

The Spanish minister was speaking to the Guardian and other European newspapers in the week that Britain’s most senior diplomat in Brussels handed in a letter from Theresa May formally announcing the intention to leave the EU.

Describing the prime minister’s letter as “constructive and respectful”, Dastis disagreed with suggestions that the UK was attempting to use security as a bargaining chip. “I didn’t take it as a threat,” he said. “Security cooperation is good not only for the EU, but also the UK. The fact the UK is leaving raises a challenge, but we [the EU] have to develop security cooperation.”

The Brexit minister, David Davis, hit the phones on Wednesday afternoon, seeking to reassure diplomats across Europe that Britain was not using security as a bargaining chip.

Dastis emphasised his agreement with the EU’s chief Brexit negotiator, Michel Barnier, who insists the UK must agree the divorce settlement before embarking on trade talks. This sequence is likely to be agreed without dispute when the EU’s 27 prime ministers and presidents meet to finalise its negotiating principles on 29 April.

In a separate interview with El País, Dastis said Spain preferred a soft Brexit, although he doubted it would be possible. “Spain is closer to soft Brexit. We regret the UK is leaving. We want a balanced, reasonable agreement. But if they’re leaving the single market and the customs union, it’s difficult to think of a soft Brexit. Spain would like a close relation, as similar as possible to the one we have now.”

In a clear diplomatic victory for Spain, the draft guidelines, which were circulated to national capitals on Friday, come down in favour of Madrid in the centuries-old dispute with Britain over Gibraltar. The text gives Spain an effective right to exclude Gibraltar from any transitional single market access arrangement or future trade deal with the UK if it is not satisfied with the status of the territory.

Spain also has a strong interest in settling the status of EU nationals, a key plank of the divorce agreement. More than 300,000 Britons have settled in Spain and their right to healthcare, employment and social security will be shaped by the Brexit deal. Dastis thought it possible to reach a settlement in a few months.

Leaders on both sides of the Channel have talked up the importance of an early agreement on citizens’ rights, but the issue is laced with complexity. An early political statement aimed at reassuring citizens is possible, but the reality of settling knotty questions of health, employment and social security rights could take longer. “Nothing is agreed until everything is agreed,” states the EU draft text.

Spain and Britain have already clashed since article 50 was triggered earlier this week over the future of Gibraltar. The UK has said it will stand up for the island’s interests after the territory accused Spain of using Brexit to forward its territorial aims. The UK foreign secretary, Boris Johnson, insisted on Friday that Britain remained “implacable and rock-like” in