Michelle
Goldberg
The
Enraging Hypocrisy at the Heart of the Nvidia Scandal
Nov. 16,
2026
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/16/opinion/nvidia-trump-jensen-huang-lutnick.html

Credit...Jonathan
Ernst/Reuters
Opinion
Columnist
Ever since
Donald Trump returned to the White House, flanked by a phalanx of supplicating
tech billionaires, his administration has emphasized the need to win the A.I.
race with China. Trump and his cronies have claimed repeatedly that we can’t
constrain A.I. development because America needs to maintain an advantage over
its chief geopolitical rival.
Yet the
Nvidia scandal has revealed that the administration at best turned a blind eye
when a leading American company gave an enormous boost to China’s A.I.
industry, all while Trump and his cronies were profiting from it. Though the
scandal started with sex — more precisely, the revelation that Jensen Huang,
head of the company at the center of the A.I. boom, had an affair with a woman
believed to be a Chinese spy — it is really about the administration’s utterly
careless attitude toward American security. And it demonstrates the bad faith
behind its efforts to shove A.I. down our collective throats.
To
understand why Trump’s tech policy has been such a national betrayal, it’s
worth going back to Joe Biden’s administration. Ben Buchanan, who served as
Biden’s White House special adviser for A.I., told me that America’s A.I.
policy under Biden had two, interconnected pillars: slowing China down, and
making sure that American A.I. was developed responsibly.
“It was our
conviction that it would not be possible, or it would be much harder, to
domestically regulate our companies if we were neck and neck with China,” said
Buchanan, the author, along with his former colleague Tantum Collins, of an
extremely well-timed new book about the global battle for A.I. supremacy, “The
Bitter Struggle: Superintelligence, Superpowers, and the Fate of the World.” By
denying China the chips that underpin advanced A.I. — most of which are made by
Nvidia, and which China cannot yet replicate — the United States would try to
maintain some control over the pace of A.I. growth.
When Donald
Trump took over, he set about dismantling efforts to rein in A.I. On the first
day of his second term, he revoked Biden’s executive order requiring the developers of
frontier models to share the results of safety testing with the government. His
administration has tried to block
state-level A.I. regulation and limit the liability of A.I. developers should
their systems harm people. When the N.A.A.C.P. filed a lawsuit accusing Elon
Musk’s xAI of polluting Black neighborhoods in Mississippi with the makeshift
power plants fueling two of his data centers, the Department of Justice intervened on Musk’s behalf.
Often, the
rationale for these policies was the A.I. arms race with China. “There is a
SICK conspiracy going on against AI and Data Centers, and the only one that is
happy about it is China,” Trump wrote on Truth Social in September. In response
to mounting panic about A.I. escaping human control, Trump called the worriers
“negative forces” and insisted that America had to retain its competitive edge.
“Whoever wins AI, wins,” he said.
But even as
Trump was using China as a pretext to undermine A.I. regulation, his
administration tacitly enabled Nvidia as it helped Chinese enterprises dodge
American restrictions on powerful chips.
Initially,
it seemed that Trump would continue Biden’s hawkish attitude toward chip
exports to China. At his confirmation hearing, Howard Lutnick, Trump’s commerce
secretary, promised to crack down on China’s evasion of American export
controls. He later attacked companies attempting to profit from China’s A.I.
industry: “We have had enough of people trying to make a dollar supporting the
people who seek to destroy our way of life,” he said. In April, Trump
restricted the sale of Nvidia’s H20 chips to China.
But in the
late spring or early summer of 2025, Buchanan pointed out, Trump’s posture
flipped. In July, he lifted the restrictions on the H20 chips. Then, in
December, he allowed Nvidia to sell much more powerful H200 chips to China.
“The decision is a major win for Jensen Huang. Nvidia’s chief executive, who
spent months lobbying the White House to ease its export restrictions,” The New
York Times reported.
We now know
that by this time, Trump had already received his first briefing about Huang’s
affair with Alice Huang. That apparently didn’t stop him from letting Nvidia
shape American policy on chip exports. Trump’s policy evolution coincided with
Nvidia’s $25 million donation to his beloved ballroom in October 2025. Further,
as The Washington Post reported on Monday, Trump held $13 million to $62 million
in Nvidia shares as of the end of August, a considerable increase from his
holdings in 2024.
Beyond
selling chips to China directly, we now know that Nvidia has sold billions of
dollars of chips to cutout companies in Southeast Asia that either provide
China with computing power or smuggle equipment into the country. One such
company, Megaspeed, was run by Alice Huang. On Sunday, The Wall Street Journal reported that Megaspeed “arranged to send nearly $12
billion worth of top-of-the-line Nvidia chips to companies in China between
March 2024 and June 2025.”
Lutnick,
despite his belligerent rhetoric at the start of Trump’s term, has been
extraordinarily accommodating of both Nvidia and Megaspeed. “Within the
Commerce Department, Nvidia is treated differently than other firms, current
and former officials say, with its issues given high priority and sent through
specific channels,” reported
The Times. According to Axios, Lutnick refused requests from others in the
administration to add Megaspeed to a list of companies that pose national
security concerns.
Lutnick’s
about-face on chip exports may have simply been his attempt to do Trump’s
bidding. But it’s worth noting that, according
to The Times, Cantor Fitzgerald, a company once led by Lutnick and now run by
his sons, “has had business dealings with several data center companies in
Southeast Asia that cater to Chinese clients, and could be affected by the
regulations Mr. Lutnick is drafting.” (On Monday, in response to the growing
Nvidia scandal, the administration finally took steps to cut
off China’s access to American A.I. chips.)
Those who
believe that Nvidia should sell more chips to China sometimes argue that
America will be better off if China depends on our chips rather than developing
its own. But as Buchanan points out, China is already trying hard to build its
own chip industry — it’s just failing. His book cites U.S. government data
concluding that China could make only 200,000 chips in 2025. If Alice Huang
facilitated the sale of $12 billion in advanced Nvidia chips to Chinese
companies, said Buchanan, that could be more than all the chips produced by
China last year, which are of much lower quality than Nvidia’s.
“The scale
of the smuggling and diversion and remote access is almost single-handedly
propping up the Chinese A.I. ecosystem,” Chris McGuire, a senior fellow for
China and emerging technologies at the Council on Foreign Relations, told me.
It’s the difference, he said, “between us having a six-month lead in A.I. and a
two-year lead in A.I., and it’s all because they’ve been permitted to have this
kind of unfettered access to U.S. chips.”
Remember who
gave them that access the next time Trump or one of his billionaire friends
says we can’t curb A.I. lest China catch up to us.

Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário