Opinion
Guest
Essay
112
Degrees in Paris, Flames Near Bordeaux. France Can’t Go On Like This.
By
Madeleine Schwartz
Ms.
Schwartz is the editor in chief of The Dial, a magazine of international
writing. She wrote from Paris.
July 29,
2026
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/29/opinion/france-wildfires-heat-air-conditioning.html
This
summer has unleashed a special kind of hell on France: not just several heat
waves with temperatures reaching as high as 112 degrees Fahrenheit, but drought
and forest fires, some right next to Paris. On my street, the leaves have
already turned brown; a once lush lawn now looks like burned straw. Across the
country, farmers are reporting that crops have withered in the blistering
conditions.
The
extreme weather has forced the country in and out of a state of paralysis. Near
Bordeaux, a wildfire has burned some 160 square miles; more than 220,000 people
have been evacuated. Several nuclear power plants were temporarily shut down;
trains were canceled because their route brought them too close to a fire.
Paris landmarks like the Louvre and the Eiffel Tower have had to close early
because of the heat, leaving tourists and the businesses that cater to them
grumbling. As one crisis follows the next, the government has offered only an
incoherent response.
Some
commenters have suggested that the problem, at least when it comes to heat,
lies in France’s supposed aversion to air-conditioning and that the fix must be
a cultural one. The far-right leader Marine Le Pen, whose party has a long
history of opposing climate-friendly policies, announced a plan to roll out
air-conditioning nationwide. On X, right-wing foreigners like Elon Musk mocked
Europeans for their lack of air-conditioning and implied that if residents
simply learned to love it then all would be well. But it will not be easy to
bring cooling to the masses, and it won’t be enough to solve the country’s
problems. France needs to take climate adaptation far more seriously as this
summer’s blazing heat and wildfires become a deadly, recurring reality.
Until
recently, France had rather clement weather. But climate change has hit France
and the rest of Europe very quickly. The continent is warming more than twice
as fast as the global average, and scientists believe that there will be 10
times as many extremely hot days by the end of the century as there are now.
Drought, too, has become a continual problem, leading to failed harvests and
water restrictions.
The
country’s haphazard response has largely left the French in charge of their own
safety. When the second heat wave this year hit in June, many schools closed,
leaving parents struggling to keep their children cool while also keeping their
jobs.
The heat
affects the country in unequal ways. Wealthier people have fled cities for
air-conditioned hotels with pools or cooler locales, while those with fewer
resources in the dense suburbs have sweltered in their homes. France recorded
at least 5,700 more deaths than usual during the heat wave in June; many of the
dead were older people who perished in care homes or overheated apartments.
The
crisis of rapid heating in France — and in Europe more broadly — is daunting in
large part because the housing stock is so poorly adapted to rising
temperatures. More than 40 percent of French homes do not have ways to
sufficiently block out sunlight. Materials like zinc in Paris’s iconic roofs
trap and amplify heat, making homes unbearably hot even after a heat wave has
passed. Air-conditioning without other structural improvements has only a
limited effect — similar to pouring gasoline into a leaky tank, as one expert
told me.
In fact,
for dense French cities like Paris, and even for New York City,
air-conditioning may provide relief indoors while simultaneously making summers
worse. The process of cooling the air indoors heats the outside, aggravating
the situation and worsening what are known as urban heat islands, as Vincent
Viguié, a climate economist, told me. A recent study from China showed how in a
narrow street lined with air-conditioners, the exterior temperature could
increase by as much as 18 degrees Fahrenheit.
A lack of
coordinated action may be pushing French consumers in the wrong direction. The
heat waves have led many to purchase small air-conditioning units, rather than
more eco-friendly (and more expensive) options like heat pumps. Around my Paris
neighborhood, it’s now common to see windows and doors propped open, and the
long tails of portable air-conditioners piping hot air into the street. Even
the government has rushed to buy 30,000 portable air-conditioners for health
care facilities, but since these units are poorly suited to institutional
windows, it’s hard to imagine that they will bring patients much relief.
The
frightening heat and fires this summer should be an impetus to those in charge
to reckon with how quickly the risks are changing. And yet the French
government has hardly addressed the scale of the problem. Even where it has
pushed for adaptation, implementation has been at times disorganized or
misguided. The government is “still fighting the last war, which is how do we
improve energy efficiency in the winter,” said Stéphane Kirkland, an architect
and a president of a sustainable design organization. Programs have stopped and
started, leaving homeowners confused about what they can and cannot be
reimbursed for.
The cost
of real adaptation to climate change is undeniably astronomical. Vivian
Dépoues, a researcher at the Institute for Climate Economics, told me that
renovations to bring France’s buildings in line with its climate goals would
cost an estimated $51 billion a year. And that doesn’t take into account all
the other costs of climate preparedness, like better forest fire management and
figuring out how to bolster the country’s food and water security.
But there
is a cost to doing nothing, too: As a 2024 report from the institute notes, the
costs associated with the health impacts of heat waves from 2015 to 2020 were
estimated at between 22 billion and 37 billion euros (between $25 billion and
$42 billion today). One estimate from an insurance company calculates that
future heat waves could cost the country more than $230 billion over the next
four years. Heat waves could result in 30 times more deaths across Europe by
the end of the century than they have caused in recent years.
France is
suffering at a time when climate change appears to be leaving the political
conversation. This summer, the government shut down a research unit on climate
adaptation and passed a law that critics say could exacerbate drought. But the
problem won’t go away as soon as fall arrives. Even if France is contributing
relatively little to global greenhouse gas emissions, the country needs to
prepare for the fact that future summers will be far worse than this one.
Madeleine
Schwartz is the editor in chief of The Dial. She is the editor, with the staff
of The Dial, of “How We See It: The World Looks at America in the Age of
Trump.”


Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário