Challenging
Consensus, Scientist Says Photos Show Epstein Was Killed
Investigations
have found most evidence in Jeffrey Epstein’s death points to suicide. Michael
Freeman, a forensic scientist who studies homicides, got rare access to the
autopsy file and disagrees.

Dr. Michael
Freeman spent a year analyzing photos and other evidence around Jeffrey
Epstein’s death.Credit...Sam Bush for The New York Times
By Shaila Dewan and Leo Sands
Nov. 16,
2026
Michael
Freeman says he had one thought when he first saw a photo from Jeffrey
Epstein’s autopsy: “Wait a minute, that doesn’t look like a hanging mark.”
The noose
had not left a smooth, consistent line on Mr. Epstein’s neck that slanted to a
peak, as in a textbook hanging. Instead, the mark was deep, ragged and branched
into a Y-shape on one side.
Dr. Freeman,
a forensic scientist who studies bias and error in death investigations, spent
a year examining Mr. Epstein’s autopsy file, which was given to him by the dead
man’s brother.
He is
seeking to publish his findings in a peer-reviewed journal, but has been
rejected so far. On Monday he presented them at the Middle Temple, a London
legal society, where he argued that Mr. Epstein’s injuries are most plausibly
explained by homicidal strangulation. He also asserted that injuries on the
body suggest there was a struggle, contrary to the medical examiner’s findings.
“The pattern
and distribution and multitude of injuries are not explained by a suicidal
hanging,” he said.
The totality
of the circumstances surrounding Jeffrey Epstein’s death in a federal detention
center in 2019 points overwhelmingly
to suicide, and several investigations have failed to produce evidence that
anyone other than Mr. Epstein had a hand in it. Dr. Freeman’s analysis, parts
of which he floated in a New
York Times investigation earlier this year, may rekindle long-smoldering
debates about his death.
Forensic
pathologists who have seen some of the autopsy photos, though not the entire
set, have agreed that the mark on Mr. Epstein’s neck was atypical for a
hanging. Some of those experts said the images could still be consistent with
suicide, but they cautioned that the injuries alone could not tell the full
story, and that a cascade of institutional failures would make it difficult to
ever conclusively determine what happened.
The New York
City medical examiner’s office, which performed the autopsy, said this week
that it “stands by its determination” of suicide.
Much
information that medical examiners would normally use to determine a cause of
death was unavailable; the examiner was not permitted to inspect the cell, for
example. That has left the autopsy photographs as some of the only concrete
evidence.
After being
asked by a journalist to look at the hanging mark, Dr. Freeman asked Jeffrey
Epstein’s brother, Mark, whether he could see the complete file. As next of
kin, Mark Epstein was one of the few people who had access to the autopsy. He
shared the file with Dr. Freeman last November. Dr. Freeman was not paid for
his analysis, they said.
Mark Epstein
said in an interview last week that he had shown the materials to other experts
who asked to see them — but whom he declined to name — and that the results had
been inconclusive. “They were all hemming and hawing,” he said.
Shortly
before Monday’s talk, Mr. Epstein posted the autopsy
photos online for all to see.
Dr. Freeman
said in an interview that he had no idea who might have killed Mr. Epstein, nor
did he care. He was focused only on what he called oversights in the death
investigation and autopsy report. “All I’m interested in is, how did this get
so sideways?” he said.
Jeffrey
Epstein, a wealthy financier and convicted sex offender, is far from a typical
subject for Dr. Freeman. As a consultant and scholar, he has argued that
medical examiners too often ignore the most plausible cause of death in favor
of one that excuses deadly force by the police or reinforces racial
stereotypes.
He is not a
board-certified forensic pathologist, the highest credential for medical
examiners in the United States, but he has doctorates in epidemiology and
forensic medicine and teaches forensic medicine at two universities. Dr.
Freeman, an American, is also a fellow of the Faculty of Forensic & Legal
Medicine at the Royal College of Physicians in the United Kingdom and the
editor of its journal.
In one case,
Dr. Freeman argued on behalf of a Black teenager charged with murder in
Mississippi after a stillbirth, after tests found trace amounts of a cocaine
byproduct in the baby’s blood. The umbilical cord had been wrapped around the
infant’s neck, and the state had the country’s highest infant mortality rate.
The charges were dropped.
In 2020, Dr.
Freeman co-wrote a landmark
metaanalysis on excited delirium, a term often used to explain deaths in
police custody. His methodology and conclusions were hotly disputed, but they propelled
a widespread rejection of excited
delirium as a valid diagnosis or cause of death.
More
recently, he consulted in the prosecution of a police officer who killed George
Floyd in Minneapolis, using statistical probability to counter defense claims
that drug abuse or heart disease had caused Mr. Floyd’s death. Dr. Freeman was
also part of a panel of experts that identified dozens
of deaths in police custody in Maryland that had been misclassified as
natural or accidental.
Forensic
pathology is sometimes said to be more art than science, and disagreements
among experts are common. Medical examiners point out that they must defend
their opinions in court, but Dr. Freeman is among critics who have complained
that there are too few safeguards against bias
and error.
For his
Epstein investigation, he teamed up with two other skeptics, Itiel Dror, a
cognitive neuroscientist whose real-world
experiments have repeatedly embarrassed forensic practitioners, and Anders
Eriksson, a forensic pathologist who led a Swedish
government review concluding that “shaken baby” prosecutions had been based
on flawed reasoning.
They are
continuing to seek a publisher for their analysis. In the meantime, Dr. Freeman
prepared his talk on Monday, which received a flurry of advance news coverage.
The talk was
to be held at the University College London, where reservations quickly reached
capacity. But on Sunday, the school suddenly announced that it would not take
place, citing “well-being implications for our students.” The talk was moved to
the Middle Temple and those planning to attend were told they would have to
watch it online.
Image

An undated
photo released by the Justice Department showing Jeffrey Epstein’s cell after
he died at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Lower Manhattan.Credit...via
Department of Justice
In 2019, the
medical examiner who performed the autopsy, Dr. Kristin Roman, faced
limitations. There were no photos of Mr. Epstein hanging or with the strip of
cloth around his neck. The piece of cloth sent to the medical examiner was not
the one that had been used as a noose. The prison employee who found the body
initially declined to speak to authorities.
Still, Dr.
Roman told federal investigators that she had no doubt it was a suicide. There
were no signs of a struggle and the body was “pristine,” she told them, with no
bruises and no debris under the fingernails.
“This
doesn’t look anything like a strangulation,” she said in a statement she gave
to federal authorities.
Dr. Roman
has since retired from the medical examiner’s office.
When the
jail employee who found the body finally spoke with investigators two years
after the fact, he recalled that Mr. Epstein’s rear end had been suspended
about an inch off the floor.
Dr. Freeman
used the employee’s description to reconstruct the hanging, creating 3-D
computer models based on Mr. Epstein’s physique and the autopsy photos. He then
used illustrations to argue that strangulation from behind was a better
explanation for Mr. Epstein’s injuries, including what he said were fingernail
marks above the ligature line, an abrasion at the base of the neck, and a deep,
fresh hemorrhage in the left shoulder muscle.
He faulted
investigators for not testing Mr. Epstein’s fingernails for DNA.
Dr. Freeman
delivered the presentation in the master treasurer’s office of the legal
society, with his co-authors and Mark Epstein sitting nearby. Toward the end,
he showed a QR code linking to the autopsy photos.
“You will be
able to see them for yourself, so that this is no longer an issue of one person
makes one statement and then everybody has to believe it,” he said, adding,
“This is a time for people to make up their own mind.”
Afterward,
he turned to those in the room. “I tried not to sound like a kook,” he said,
laughing.
If you
are having thoughts of suicide, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide and
Crisis Lifeline or go to SpeakingOfSuicide.com/resources
for a list of additional resources.
Shaila Dewan is a
Times reporter covering criminal justice — policing, courts and prisons —
across the country.
Leo Sands is a
correspondent for the Breaking News Hub of The New York Times based in London.



Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário