Commission misses deadline to appeal ‘Pfizergate’ judgment

 

Commission misses deadline to appeal ‘Pfizergate’ judgment

EU court’s finding against executive’s handling of text message exchange between Ursula von der Leyen and Pfizer CEO will stand.

 

July 30, 2025 4:00 am CET

By Mari Eccles

https://www.politico.eu/article/commission-misses-deadline-to-appeal-pfizergate-judgment/

 

BRUSSELS ― The deadline has passed for the European Commission to appeal an EU court judgment over President Ursula von der Leyen's text message exchange with a vaccine-maker at the height of the Covid pandemic.

 

It means the EU's General Court finding in May will stand. The court ruled that the Commission failed to explain why messages shared between von der Leyen and Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla didn't contain important information that would have required retention.

 

In a case that became known as "Pfizergate," reporters asked to see the messages after it was revealed in a 2021 New York Times interview with von der Leyen that she had exchanged texts with Bourla ahead of a multibillion-euro vaccine deal agreed between Pfizer and the EU.

 

The case became a flashpoint for transparency activists who said it demonstrated the lack of accountability in von der Leyen’s Commission ― and for people who opposed the use of the vaccine in the first place.

 

No-confidence vote

The deadline for the EU executive to contest the decision in the EU’s top-tier Court of Justice passed earlier this month without the Commission appealing, a spokesperson for the EU courts confirmed.

 

At the beginning of July, von der Leyen faced a no-confidence vote in the European Parliament over the case, triggered by right-wing Romanian MEP Gheorghe Piperea.

 

While the Commission president easily survived the vote after the majority of MEPs backed her leadership, the debate became the first time she has publicly defended herself over the case. She told lawmakers in Strasbourg that some accusations leveled against her were "simply a lie."

 

Whether the Commission’s non-appeal means that the messages will be released is another matter.

 

The court ruling conceded that retrieving the texts will be difficult, and a spokesperson for the Commission said that in line with the ruling it would provide "a more detailed explanation as to why it does not hold the requested documents."

 

The court "did not put into question the Commission’s registration policy regarding access to documents," the spokesperson said, adding that the EU executive "remains fully committed to maintaining openness, accountability, and clear communication with all stakeholders, including EU institutions, civil society, and interest representatives."