U.N.
Climate Talks Collapse in a Bitter Clash Over Fossil Fuels
European
and vulnerable nations rejected a proposed agreement after Saudi Arabia and
other oil producers blocked any mention of phasing out coal, oil and gas.

Saudi delegates onscreen at COP31 on Sunday.Credit...Chris
McGrath/Getty Images
By Chico Harlan and Lisa Friedman
Reporting
from Antalya, Turkey
Nov. 22,
2026Updated 1:20 p.m. ET
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/climate/cop31-climate-summit-ends-climate.html
The United
Nations climate talks broke down on Sunday with no final agreement after
long-building tensions paralyzed the negotiations, pitting nations seeking to
wind down the era of fossil fuels against those aiming to prolong it.
The European
Union, as well as many smaller countries vulnerable to climate disasters and
rising sea levels, rejected a proposed agreement they said stripped out crucial
protections and favored countries that export oil, gas and coal. A group of oil
producers, led by Saudi Arabia and including Russia, had blocked any mention of
fossil fuels, the root cause of global warming.
It was the
first time U.N. climate talks broke down over a final agreement since COP15 in
Copenhagen in 2009
That the
talks were derailed by something so elemental shows the vast challenges facing
the global process for addressing climate change. After nearly two weeks of
jockeying in a conference center in Turkey, sleep-deprived negotiators fought
two days past the talks’ official deadline, rebooking flights and bargaining in
closed-door meetings to see if Russia, Saudi Arabia and other Arab nations
might loosen their opposition to language about fossil fuels.
“It fails to
meet the moment,” said Darragh O’Brien, Ireland’s minister of climate,
environment and energy, speaking on behalf of the European Union.
Image

Darragh
O’Brien, the Irish environment minister, center left, and Wopke Hoekstra, the
European climate commissioner, at the talks on Sunday.Credit...Yasin
Akgul/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
“We will not
accept a COP that greenwashes fossil fuel.”
He said it
was “unconscionable that we would have a climate pact that makes no reference
to fossil fuel.” As diplomats spoke, COP31 became the longest U.N. climate
summit in history, surpassing one held in 2019 that went nearly 45 hours into
overtime.
Negotiators
from more than 190 countries meet every year to advance the goals of the 2015
Paris Agreement. Their failure in Turkey was all the more striking given the
backdrop of recent deadly heat waves in Europe, a glacier collapse in Nepal,
and an El Niño-fueled run of record-breaking ocean temperatures.
There have
been just two previous times in three decades of annual global climate talks
when nations failed to reach agreement, in Copenhagen and at COP6 in The Hague
in 2000. Coming at a low point for global cooperation, the breakdown deepened
doubts about whether the United Nations process is up to the task of
confronting an overheating planet.
Even in its
best moments, that process hasn’t been easy. Many have questioned the viability
of a system marked by lawyerly fights over wording and a long history of
unrealized promises.
It has been
further complicated by the exodus of the United States under President Trump
from the global effort to fight climate change. Some participants say that in
that vacuum, other countries have staked out harder positions, leaving the
process gridlocked. While one big fight centered on fossil fuels, developing
countries also seethed about how much-needed funding to prepare for and deal
with climate change has been slow to materialize.
Countries in
2023 had clinched a celebrated agreement to “transition away” from coal, oil
and gas — what organizers called the “beginning of the end” of the fossil fuel
era. But in three COPs since then, no final agreement has directly mentioned
fossil fuels. Canada is fast-tracking an oil pipeline. Australia has approved
new projects that would last for decades. And the United States, under Mr.
Trump, has used trade policy to promote fossil fuels abroad.
“Fossil
fuel-producing countries are banding together, no matter which part of the
world they come from,” said Lynda Tabuya, Fiji’s climate and environment
minister.
Image

Lynda
Tabuya, Fiji’s climate and environment minister, at the conference venue on
Wednesday.Credit...Yasin Akgul/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
That’s left
countries that favor a transition to wind, solar and other clean energy to work
outside the formal U.N. system, with a series of conferences and domestic
pledges that gained some momentum in Antalya. Denmark, Spain and Portugal were
among the nations that announced new fossil fuel phaseout plans this month.
At the same
time, a proposal in the failed text had called to increase the deployment of
technology to capture and store carbon dioxide emissions.
A group of
Arab countries led by Saudi Arabia that had sought such language argued that it
would be impossible to keep global temperatures at safe levels without this
kind of technology. Critics called it a license for fossil fuel developers to
continue burning coal, oil and gas rather than shift to renewables.
The proposed
text also included a target to expand the reach of electric power.
Mohammad
Ayoub, a Saudi delegate, speaking in a closing plenary, described the proposed
text as a “package of solutions” that would have advanced climate goals.
The talks,
known this year as COP31, came two months after the United Nations acknowledged
failure to meet the world’s most ambitious climate target: limiting temperature
increase to 1.5 degrees Celsius above preindustrial levels. Some diplomats said
the conference’s credibility would depend on mounting a response to that breach
and to the intensifying heat waves, droughts and floods that will come with it.
Holding
temperatures to the “lowest possible overshoot” would require immediate cuts to
greenhouse emissions, the United Nations has said.
Mr. O’Brien
and Wopke Hoekstra, the European climate commissioner, said they and the
leaders of negotiating groups representing about 130 countries repeatedly tried
to incorporate language that acknowledged a global effort to transition away
from fossil fuels but were blocked by oil-producing nations.
“There were
no measures that were going to bridge that gap and get us back down toward
1.5,” Mr. Hoekstra said.
Governments
have been focused on bringing down the soaring costs of fuel, which have been
driven sharply higher by the U.S. and Israeli war in Iran, disruptions in the
Strait of Hormuz and refining bottlenecks.
While
climate negotiators worked in Antalya, Mr. Trump, President Xi Jinping of China
and President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia met at a lakeside villa in Shenzhen,
China, and agreed to “increase the production and supply” of petroleum. The
United States, China and Russia represent three of the four largest emitters.
In an
unusual twist, two countries this year had a hand in running the event, with
Turkey hosting but an Australian minister, Chris Bowen, in charge of
shepherding negotiations. But as talks went past the deadline, it became hard
for delegates to tell who was doing what. Organizers did not call all nations
together to hash things out. Public communication stopped. Groups came in and
out of backrooms. “It’s not effective and it can’t build consensus,” said
Xolisa Joseph Ngwadla, a negotiator from Botswana. “The process is basically
mismanaged.”
Mr. Bowen
said the overshoot of 1.5 degrees Celsius, coupled with concerns about energy
security, had made nations’ “red lines more irreconcilable.”
“The
pressure in the system was very high,” Mr. Bowen said.
The impasse
at COP31 comes amid concerns that the consensus-based process is no longer
functioning. Johan Rockström, the director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate
Impact Research in Germany, wrote in an online post that a requirement for
unanimity was the “real Achilles' heel” of the process and said a handful of
countries were deliberately putting “spanners in the wheel.”
Former Vice
President Al Gore, who was in Turkey for the beginning of the talks, said it
was “insane” that any individual country could “block the entire process.” Mr.
Gore suggested supermajority voting.
Since the
landmark Paris Agreement in 2015, the world has edged away from a worst-case
scenario: a temperature increase of 4 degrees Celsius, or 7.2 degrees
Fahrenheit. But even the current trajectory, of around 2.8 degrees, or 5
degrees Fahrenheit, is a “recipe for catastrophe,” António Guterres, the United
Nations secretary general, has said. Nations have fallen well short of their
emissions-cutting pledges, but have gotten a boost from the plummeting cost of
solar and wind energy, and from Chinese manufacturers supplying the world with
electric vehicles.
Chico Harlan is a
global climate correspondent for The Times.
Lisa Friedman is a
business correspondent covering energy for The New York Times.



Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário