Von der Leyen vows to punish Israel’s ‘extremist ministers’ and pause payments

 

Von der Leyen vows to punish Israel’s ‘extremist ministers’ and pause payments

 

“What is happening in Gaza is unacceptable,” EU Commission president tells a noisy European Parliament during State of the Union address.

 

September 10, 2025 10:40 am CET

By Sarah Wheaton, Max Griera, Antonia Zimmermann and Gabriel Gavin

https://www.politico.eu/article/urusla-von-der-leyen-state-of-the-union-punish-israel-extremist-ministers-pause-payments/

 

President Ursula von der Leyen used her annual State of the Union speech to announce the European Commission will take a tougher approach on Israel ― drawing applause and jeers from a divided European Parliament.

 

The EU’s executive will sanction “extremist ministers” and violent settlers, and pause bilateral payments to Israel, von der Leyen said, as she seeks to blast through gridlock in the bloc’s response to the humanitarian crisis in Gaza.

 

The announcement triggered a furious response in Israel, where Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar hit back: “The President of the European Commission’s comments this morning are regrettable. Some of them are also tainted by echoing the false propaganda of Hamas and its partners.”

 

The Commission will also propose a partial suspension of trade aspects of the EU-Israel Association Agreement — even though these are measures that are likely to be stalled by persistent divisions among the capitals over how to restrain the Israeli government’s response to the attacks by Hamas on Oct. 7, 2023.

 

“What is happening in Gaza is unacceptable,” von der Leyen told the Parliament in Strasbourg. “We will propose sanctions on the extremist ministers and on violent settlers.”

 

Von der Leyen acknowledged that disagreement among national governments had blocked more concrete action — including suspending EU research funding — and said that was fueling public anger.

 

“We will put our bilateral support to Israel on hold,” she said, adding that funding for the Holocaust museum Yad Vashem and Israeli civil society would not be affected. She gave no further details than that.

 

Referring to “man-made famine,” she said: “For the sake of humanity, this must stop.”

 

In his response, Sa’ar added: “The President of the Commission errs in yielding to the pressures of elements that seek to undermine Israel–Europe relations. This trend is contrary to the interests of the European states themselves. And mainly: this is not acceptable conduct between partners.”

 

Largest trading partner

The announcement that the EU will sanction key Israeli officials and settlers drew applause and heckles from across the chamber.

 

Many lawmakers, some of whom were wearing red in solidarity with Gaza, welcomed the announcement. But it sparked uproar on the right-hand side of the chamber where some members, including from Germany’s far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD), shouted interruptions, prompting attendants and MEPs to tell them to be quiet.

 

The EU is Israel’s largest trading partner, accounting for 32 percent of its total trade in 2024, so any possible suspension will have a major effect on the Israeli economy. The EU exports machinery and transport equipment, chemicals and other manufactured goods to Israel, with total exports amounting to €26.7 billion in 2024.

 

In long, behind-closed-doors negotiations between the main political groups ahead of von der Leyen’s speech, the Parliament failed to agree on a joint stance on Gaza. Von der Leyen’s center-right European People’s Party (EPP) walked out of a deal as they disagreed with the content of the final text, which means the resolution will not pass Thursday’s vote, three officials, granted anonymity to speak freely, said.

 

The toughened stance of the Commission president’s speech, however, has opened hopes among center-left political groups that the EPP will change course to reflect von der Leyen, their highest-ranking member.

 

“I continue to receive mixed signals from the EPP regarding their support for the Gaza resolution,” liberal Renew lawmaker Hilde Vautmans, negotiating the Gaza resolution, told POLITICO. “But this morning, there was a clear shift in Commission President Ursula von der Leyen’s position by proposing sanctions on Israel and the suspension of the trade pillar of the EU–Israel Association Agreement. She has set a new and important direction.

 

“I hope this momentum will positively influence EPP support for the resolution,” she added.

 

A suspension of the trade aspects of the association agreement with Israel would not amount to targeted sanctions or an EU-wide arms embargo — steps that civil society and some member countries have also called for to exert economic pressure on Israel — but would instead reimpose tariffs.

 

Still, reaching the necessary qualified majority to suspend that wouldn’t be easy. While a majority of countries voted in favor of reviewing the EU’s association agreement with Israel, that doesn’t mean all of them will vote in favor of suspending its trade part. The Commission’s previous proposal to suspend the country’s participation in the research and innovation fund Horizon did not gather enough support among member countries. Large critical countries — such as Italy and Germany — would need to support the suspension. And close Israel allies such as Hungary, Czechia, Austria and Poland are also unlikely to waver in their support.

 

This article has been updated.