Analysis
Mutual
inconvenience: why Alaska for the Trump-Putin summit on Ukraine?
Dan
Sabbagh
in Kyiv
Remote US
state is not an easy destination for either leader, but the choice of venue
reflects the many factors at play
Mon 11
Aug 2025 07.30 BST
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/aug/11/why-alaska-for-the-trump-putin-summit-on-ukraine
It is
unlikely that Vladimir Putin will arrive in Alaska on Friday to present Donald
Trump with a territorial demand for the 49th state, sold by Tsar Alexander II
to the US for $7.2m (£5.4m) in 1867. The Russian president, after all, has
another land deal on his mind – to persuade Trump of the merits of swapping
parts of Ukrainian territory in return for him perhaps agreeing to the
ceasefire the US president so desperately wants, but does not know how to get.
Putin’s
influential foreign affairs adviser, Yuri Ushakov, said Alaska was an “entirely
logical” location for the summit, as if the hop across the Bering Strait that
divides the countries is a simple trip. The gap between the US and Russian
mainlands may be 55 miles, but it is roughly a nine-hour flight from Moscow to
Anchorage, Alaska’s largest city. Even for Trump, travelling from Washington DC
on Air Force One, it will be not much less than eight hours. Alaska is a
location of mutual inconvenience, which indicates that other factors are at
play.
The
remote state is a long way from Ukraine and its European allies, and risks
pushing both into the distant background. Though Trump seems open, in theory,
to letting Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, attend, it is hard to
imagine Putin being so welcoming. His prize, after all, are private talks with
the occupant of the White House about sanctions, trade, the reach of Nato in
Europe – negotiating tracks far beyond his latest proposals for dominating
Ukraine.
Above
all, Alaska is a safe place for the Russian leader to visit. Putin is still
wanted by the international criminal court, accused of war crimes in relation
to the forced deportation of children from Ukraine to Russia in March 2023.
There is an arrest warrant out, but neither Russia nor crucially the US
recognise the court. Nor are there any unfriendly countries to overfly. A trip
around the top of the globe is unlikely to run into unexpected difficulties
that might make travelling over the Black Sea to Istanbul in Turkey
unattractive.
A casual
recollection suggests US-Russia or, going back further, US-Soviet summits, have
been held in cooler locations, loosely reflecting the two countries’ more
northerly positions. Easily the most notable is Helsinki. It was in the Finnish
capital in 2018, the last time Trump and Putin met while in office, that the US
leader declared that he trusted Putin more than his own intelligence agencies
when it came to allegations of interference in the 2016 US election.
Those
with cold war memories will recall the Reykjavik summit of 1986, where Ronald
Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev discussed eliminating nuclear weapons, but
couldn’t quite agree. Gorbachev wanted Reagan to give up testing on the star
wars missile defence initiative, but the then US president would not agree to
do so and the summit broke up in failure. But in the 1990s when summit meetings
between the two countries were more frequent, Bill Clinton and Boris Yeltsin
even met in Birmingham and Shropshire in 1998, a time when Russia had just
joined what then became the G8.
Today,
however, nuclear disarmament and G8 cooperation are quaint messages from a
different era – one in which the group is again the G7. The Alaska meeting is
only the fourth US-Russia summit since 2010 and, while it remains possible that
the discussions will lead to a ceasefire in Ukraine, there are few grounds for
optimism when the war continues to be fought so bitterly on the frontlines and
in the rear, with Russia repeatedly bombing Ukrainian cities, trying to force
its democratic neighbour into submission.
This article was amended on 11 August 2025. An
earlier version said that Anchorage was the state capital of Alaska. In fact,
that is Juneau.

Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário