How do
you solve a problem like Elon Musk?
The
“chameleon” tech billionaire is one of the most powerful politically connected
people in the world. Europe’s governments are still working out how to deal
with being on his bad side.
Elon Musk
has no compunction about lambasting serving administrations and throwing his
weight behind opposition movements on the populist right.
January 3,
2025 6:10 pm CET
By Emilio
Casalicchio, James Angelos, Eliza Gkritsi and Joshua Berlinger
https://www.politico.eu/article/solve-problem-elon-musk-uk/
LONDON —
He’s a billionaire firebrand at the forefront of green tech, owns a powerful
political media platform — and has the ear of the incoming president of the
United States.
So it’s
little wonder governments across Europe are in turmoil over how to navigate
Elon Musk, while dodging his erratic and often ill-informed criticisms about
their domestic politics.
The Tesla
and X owner — tapped up to lead a government efficiency drive in Donald Trump's
second U.S. presidential term — has no compunction about lambasting serving
administrations and throwing his weight behind opposition movements on the
populist right. That's despite him complaining about foreign interference when
others attempt to get involved with U.S. politics.
His biggest
beef appears to be with the British Labour government under Prime Minister Keir
Starmer. But he has sharply criticized German Chancellor Olaf Scholz too and
endorsed hard-right movements in both nations.
Other
European leaders have attempted to court Musk in the hope of avoiding his ire
and smoothing their relations with Trump, who Musk helped into office via
millions of dollars in campaign funding.
French
President Emmanuel Macron invited the Tesla and Twitter owner to the re-opening
of Notre-Dame cathedral and wants him at an upcoming tech summit.
Italian
Prime Minister Georgia Meloni has built her own bond with Musk. And Ukrainian
President Volodymyr Zelenskyy was forced to play nice with him during a
post-election call with Trump, despite sharp disagreements over the response to
Russia's full-scale invasion.
Leaders from
further afield, including Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Indian
Prime Minister Narendra Modi, also increased their dealings with the
businessman as the U.S. election loomed, to avoid the kind of harsh treatment
meted out to Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. Musk appeared to endorse
Trudeau's Conservative rival this week to boot.
Those who
put the time in are being vindicated.
Trump
rewarded the SpaceX mogul with his cost-cutting government appointment and has
rarely been seen without Musk at his side since the election, cementing his
influence on the coming administration.
Among his
political allies and enemies, a consensus has formed that Musk is one of the
most powerful people in the world — if not the most powerful. Getting on his
bad side can have dire consequences.
"As a
chameleon, you never know which version of Elon Musk is showing up," said
one former U.K. government adviser who dealt with Musk and was granted
anonymity to speak candidly about him. "He's a dangerous figure. And it's
in no one's interests to have him as an enemy."
Just ask
Keir Starmer
Musk
launches social media attacks at Starmer with near-obsessive routine.
He has
backed the Reform U.K. movement led by Brexit campaigner Nigel Farage — a
long-standing friend of Trump who met Musk last month and discussed a potential
overseas donation.
In recent
days, Musk has also thrown his weight behind far-right rabble-rouser Tommy
Robinson — a step too far even for Farage. He did so while peddling claims
Starmer failed to take the issue of child grooming gangs seriously while he was
head of the British prosecution service.
The latest
Musk musings on X earned a rebuke from Labour minister Andrew Gwynne. “Elon
Musk is an American citizen and perhaps ought to focus on issues on the other
side of the Atlantic,” he told LBC radio.
But Gwynne’s
boss, Health Secretary Wes Streeting, offered the Tesla chief an olive branch
in a later interview — demonstrating the tension in the British government over
whether or not to rile the billionaire further.
Streeting
said Musk's criticisms were “misjudged and certainly misinformed,” but stressed
the British government is keen to cooperate with tech giants to tackle child
sexual exploitation, Musk's latest crusade and a campaign point for Farage.
“We’re
willing to work with Elon Musk, who I think has got a big role to play with his
social media platform to help us and other countries to tackle this serious
issue,” Streeting told ITV News. “If he wants to work with us and roll his
sleeves up, we'd welcome that.”
But Musk
shows no signs of backing down and the U.K. government's refusal to invite him
to a crucial investment summit last October may have sealed its reputation with
the tech mogul.
For its
part, Starmer's Downing Street studiously avoided commenting on Musk's latest
attacks, even as Musk branded the prime minister “complicit in the RAPE OF
BRITAIN" and demanded a fresh election.
Starmer's
MPs — nervously eyeing a challenge from Farage's party — were less circumspect.
One, also
granted anonymity to speak candidly, lamented that "at a time when
communities need to come and work together, we have someone with a lot of
influence sowing divisions and spreading hate."
Germany
gives the middle finger
In Germany,
mainstream political leaders are increasingly concerned about what Musk’s
endorsement of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) could mean for
relations between the Trump administration and Germany’s next coalition
government.
And they
have been less shy than the U.K. government about taking on Musk directly.
The
center-left Chancellor Scholz — a Musk bête noire — called a snap election for
Feb. 23 and has found himself in a struggling campaign against the entrepreneur
as well as his domestic political opponents.
In an
interview with Funke Mediengruppe published in recent days, Social Democratic
co-leader Lars Klingbeil compared Musk’s interventions in the German election
to the influence operations backed by the Kremlin and Russian President
Vladimir Putin.
“Both want
to influence our elections and specifically support the AfD's enemies of
democracy,” said Klingbeil. “They want Germany to be weakened and plunged into
chaos.”
The
conservative candidate in pole position to be Germany’s next chancellor,
Friedrich Merz, has portrayed himself as a leader who will be able to make
“deals” with Trump — at a moment when German exports are exposed to the
president-elect’s repeated threats of a trade war with Europe.
Many German
mainstream politicians worry that, at the very least, Musk and the incoming
administration will further undermine German centrist parties by normalizing
the AfD and playing down its radicalism.
Those
worries grew more pronounced when U.S. Vice President-elect JD Vance reposted
an English-language translation of Musk’s controversial tribute to the AfD in
Germany’s Welt am Sonntag newspaper.
“I’m not
endorsing a party in the German elections, as it’s not my country and we hope
to have good relations with all Germans,” Vance wrote on X.
“But this is
an interesting piece,” he added.
Musk hasn’t
yet thrown his endorsement behind Marine Le Pen and the French far right. But
President Macron — who, like Scholz in Germany, is politically fragile and
facing domestic turbulence — is desperate to get him onside.
He has been
urging the tech entrepreneur, alongside Trump, to attend a major artificial
intelligence summit in Paris next month. The duo's appearance at the recent
Notre-Dame reopening was a diplomatic coup for Macron.
“Trump
doesn’t seem to hold Paris in the same contempt he holds the EU or Germany,”
said a Republican foreign policy expert working with Trump’s transition team,
who spoke on condition of anonymity in order to discuss the team’s internal
thinking. “Macron can take solace in the fact that he’s not Scholz.”
Making life
difficult for Macron, however, is the European Commission, which continues
investigations into whether X complies with its information rules.
It has found
the microblogging site in breach of the Digital Services Act, the EU’s landmark
content moderation law, for the deceptive design of “verified” badges and a
lack of transparency to researchers.
The jury is
still out on X's potential violations around the dissemination of illegal
content and measures to fight information manipulation, and the Commission is
mulling whether it could slap Musk with a mega-fine.
A back and
forth between Musk and former European Commissioner for digital policy Thierry
Breton became increasingly hostile. Breton resigned from his post shortly after
their war of words, prompting glee from his nemesis.
European
leaders are waiting to see where Musk turns his attention next once Trump takes
office later this month.
The one
certainty is the old rules of diplomacy are out the window.
"While
his behavior is dubious, business and trade is fickle," said the former
U.K. government adviser. "Governments should never rule out a significant
opportunity to do business with him."
Noah Keate
in London and Sue Allan in Ottawa contributed to this report.
Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário