How Edward Snowden went from loyal NSA contractor to
whistleblower
He was politically
conservative, a gun owner, a geek – and the man behind the biggest intelligence
leak in history. In this exclusive extract from his new book, Luke Harding
looks at Edward Snowden's journey from patriot to America's most wanted
Luke Harding
The Guardian, Saturday 1 February 2014 / http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/feb/01/edward-snowden-intelligence-leak-nsa-contractor-extract
In late December 2001, someone calling themselves TheTrueHOOHA
had a question. He was an 18-year-old American male with impressive IT skills
and a sharp intelligence. His real identity was unknown. Everyone who posted on
Ars Technica, a popular technology website, did so anonymously.
TheTrueHOOHA wanted to set up his own web server. It was a
Saturday morning, a little after 11am. He posted: "It's my first time. Be
gentle. Here's my dilemma: I want to be my own host. What do I need?"
Soon, regular users were piling in with helpful suggestions.
TheTrueHOOHA replied: "Ah, the vast treasury of geek knowledge that is
Ars." He would become a prolific contributor; over the next eight years,
he authored nearly 800 comments. He described himself variously as
"unemployed", a failed soldier, a "systems editor", and
someone who had US State Department security clearance.
His home was on the east coast of America in the state of
Maryland, near Washington DC. But by his mid-20s he was already an
international man of mystery. He popped up in Europe – in Geneva, London,
Ireland, Italy and Bosnia. He travelled to India. Despite having no degree, he
knew an astonishing amount about computers. His politics appeared staunchly
Republican. He believed strongly in personal liberty, defending, for example,
Australians who farmed cannabis plants.
At times he could be rather obnoxious. He called one
fellow-Arsian, for example, a "cock"; others who disagreed with his
sink-or-swim views on social security were "fucking retards".
His chat logs cover a colourful array of themes: gaming,
girls, sex, Japan, the stock market, his disastrous stint in the US army, his
negative impressions of multiracial Britain (he was shocked by the number of
"Muslims" in east London and wrote, "I thought I had gotten off
of the plane in the wrong country… it was terrifying"), the joys of gun
ownership ("I have a Walther P22. It's my only gun but I love it to
death," he wrote in 2006). In their own way, the logs form a
Bildungsroman.
Then, in 2009, the entries fizzle away. In February 2010,
TheTrueHOOHA mentions a thing that troubles him: pervasive government
surveillance. "Society really seems to have developed an unquestioning
obedience towards spooky types… Did we get to where we are today via a slippery
slope that was entirely within our control to stop? Or was it a relatively
instantaneous sea change that sneaked in undetected because of pervasive
government secrecy?"
TheTrueHOOHA's last post is on 21 May 2012. After that, he
disappears, a lost electronic signature amid the vastness of cyberspace. He
was, we now know, Edward Snowden.
Edward Joseph Snowden was born on 21 June 1983. His father
Lonnie and mother Elizabeth – known as Wendy – were high-school sweethearts who
married at 18. Lon was an officer in the US coastguard; Snowden spent his early
years in Elizabeth City, on North Carolina's coast. He has an older sister,
Jessica. When Snowden was small – a boy with thick blond hair and a toothy
smile – he and his family moved to Maryland, within DC's commuter belt.
As his father recalls, Snowden's education went wrong when
he got ill, probably with glandular fever. He missed "four or five
months" of class in his mid-teens. Another factor hurt his studies: his
parents were drifting apart. He failed to finish high school. In 1999, aged 16,
Snowden enrolled at Anne Arundel community college, where he took computer
courses.
In the aftermath of his parents' divorce, Snowden lived with
a roommate, and then with his mother, in Ellicott City, just west of Baltimore.
He grew up under the giant shadow of one government agency in particular. From
his mother's front door, it takes 15 minutes to drive there. Half-hidden by
trees is a big, green, cube-shaped building. An entrance sign off the
Baltimore-Washington Parkway reads: "NSA next right. Employees only."
The Puzzle Palace employs 40,000 people. It is the largest hirer of
mathematicians in the US.
For Snowden, the likelihood of joining was slim. In his
early 20s, his focus was on computers. To him, the internet was "the most
important invention in all human history". He chatted online to people
"with all sorts of views I would never have encountered on my own".
He wasn't only a nerd: he kept fit, practised kung fu and, according to one
entry on Ars, "dated Asian girls".
The 2003 US-led invasion of Iraq prompted Snowden to think
seriously about a career in the military. "I wanted to fight in the Iraq
war because I felt like I had an obligation as a human being to help free
people from oppression," he has said.
The military offered what seemed, on the face of it, an
attractive scheme, whereby recruits with no prior experience could try out to
become elite soldiers. In May 2004, Snowden took the plunge and enlisted,
reporting to Fort Benning in Georgia. It was a disaster. He was in good
physical shape but an improbable soldier, shortsighted and with unusually
narrow feet. During infantry training, he broke both his legs. After more than
a month's uncertainty, the army finally discharged him.
Back in Maryland, he got a job as a "security
specialist" at the University for Maryland's Centre for Advanced Study of
Language. It was 2005. (He appears to have begun as a security guard, but then
moved back into IT.) Snowden was working at a covert NSA facility on the
university's campus. Thanks perhaps to his brief military history, he had
broken into the world of US intelligence, albeit on a low rung. The centre
worked closely with the US intelligence community, providing advanced language
training.
In mid-2006, Snowden landed a job in IT at the CIA. He was
rapidly learning that his exceptional IT skills opened all kinds of interesting
government doors. "First off, the degree thing is crap, at least domestically.
If you 'really' have 10 years of solid, provable IT experience… you CAN get a
very well-paying IT job," he wrote online in July 2006.
In 2007, the CIA sent Snowden to Geneva on his first foreign
tour. Switzerland was an awakening and an adventure. He was 24. His job was to
maintain security for the CIA's computer network and look after computer
security for US diplomats. He was a telecommunications information systems
officer. He also had to maintain the heating and air-con.
In Geneva, Snowden was exposed to an eclectic range of
views. On one occasion, he gave an Estonian singer called Mel Kaldalu a lift to
Munich. They had met at a Free Tibet event in Geneva; they didn't know each
other brilliantly well, but well enough for Snowden to offer him a lift. They
chatted for hours on the empty autobahn. Snowden argued that the US should act
as a world policeman. Kaldalu disagreed. "Ed's an intelligent guy,"
he says. "Maybe even a little bit stubborn. He's outspoken. He likes to
discuss things. Self-sustainable. He has his own opinions."
The Estonian singer and the CIA technician talked about the
difficulty pro-Tibet activists had in getting Chinese visas. Snowden was
sceptical about the Beijing Olympics. Kaldalu said the Israeli occupation of
Palestine was morally questionable. Snowden said he understood this, but viewed
US support for Israel as the "least worst" option. Kaldalu suggested
a "deconstructive" approach. The pair also discussed how rapid
digital changes might affect democracy and the way people governed themselves.
At the time, the figure who most closely embodied Snowden's
rightwing views was Ron Paul, the most famous exponent of US libertarianism.
Snowden supported Paul's 2008 bid for the US presidency. He was also impressed
with the Republican candidate John McCain. He wasn't an Obama supporter as
such, but he didn't object to him, either.
Once Obama became president, Snowden came to dislike him
intensely. He criticised the White House's attempts to ban assault weapons. He
was unimpressed by affirmative action. Another topic made him even angrier. The
Snowden of 2009 inveighed against government officials who leaked classified
information to newspapers – the worst crime conceivable, in Snowden's
apoplectic view. In January of that year, the New York Times published a report
on a secret Israeli plan to attack Iran. The Times said its story was based on
15 months' worth of interviews with current and former US officials, European
and Israeli officials, other experts and international nuclear inspectors.
TheTrueHOOHA's response, published by Ars Technica, is
revealing. In a long conversation with another user, he wrote the following
messages:
"WTF NYTIMES. Are they TRYING to start a war?"
"They're reporting classified shit"
"moreover, who the fuck are the anonymous sources
telling them this? those people should be shot in the balls"
"that shit is classified for a reason"
"it's not because 'oh we hope our citizens don't find
out' its because 'this shit won't work if iran knows what we're doing'"
Snowden's anti-leaking invective seems stunningly at odds
with his own later behaviour, but he would trace the beginning of his own
disillusionment with government spying to this time. "Much of what I saw
in Geneva really disillusioned me about how my government functions and what
its impact is in the world. I realised that I was part of something that was
doing far more harm than good," he later said.
In February 2009, Snowden resigned from the CIA. Now he was
to work as a contractor at an NSA facility on a US military base in Japan. The
opportunities for contractors had boomed as the burgeoning US security state
outsourced intelligence tasks to private companies. Snowden was on the payroll
of Dell, the computer firm. The early lacunae in his CV were by this stage
pretty much irrelevant. He had top-secret clearance and outstanding computer
skills. He had felt passionately about Japan from his early teens and had spent
a year and a half studying Japanese. He sometimes used the Japanese
pronunciation of his name – "E-do-waa-do" – and wrote in 2001:
"I've always dreamed of being able to 'make it' in Japan. I'd love a cushy
.gov job over there."
Japan marked a turning point, the period when Snowden became
more than a disillusioned technician: "I watched as Obama advanced the
very policies that I thought would be reined in." Between 2009 and 2012,
he says he found out just how all-consuming the NSA's surveillance activities
are: "They are intent on making every conversation and every form of
behaviour in the world known to them." He also realised that the
mechanisms built into the US system and designed to keep the NSA in check had
failed. "You can't wait around for someone else to act. I had been looking
for leaders, but I realised that leadership is about being the first to act."
He left Japan for Hawaii in 2012,
a whistleblower-in-waiting.
Snowden's new job was at the NSA's regional cryptological
centre (the Central Security Service) on the main island of Oahu, near
Honolulu. He was still a Dell contractor, working at one of the 13 NSA hubs
devoted to spying on foreign interests, particularly the Chinese. He arrived
with an audacious plan to make contact anonymously with journalists interested
in civil liberties and to leak them stolen top-secret documents. His aim was
not to spill state secrets wholesale. Rather, he wanted to turn over a selection
of material to reporters and let them exercise their own editorial judgment.
According to an NSA staffer who worked with him in Hawaii
and who later talked to Forbes magazine, Snowden was a principled and
ultra-competent if somewhat eccentric colleague. He wore a hoodie featuring a
parody NSA logo. Instead of a key in an eagle's claws, it had a pair of
eavesdropping headphones, covering the bird's ears. He kept a copy of the
constitution on his desk and wandered the halls carrying a Rubik's cube. He
left small gifts on colleagues' desks. He almost lost his job sticking up for
one co-worker who was being disciplined.
In Hawaii, by early 2013, Snowden's sense of outrage was
still growing. But his plan to leak appeared to have stalled. He faced too many
obstacles. He took a new job with the private contractor Booz Allen Hamilton,
yielding him access to a fresh trove of information. According to the NSA
staffer who spoke to Forbes, Snowden turned down an offer to join the agency's
tailored access operations, a group of elite hackers.
On 30 March, in the evening, Snowden flew to the US mainland
to attend training sessions at Booz Allen Hamilton's office near Fort Meade.
His new salary was $122,000 (£74,000) a year, plus a housing allowance. On 4
April, he had dinner with his father. Lon Snowden says he found his son
preoccupied and nursing a burden. "We hugged as we always do. He said: 'I
love you, Dad.' I said: 'I love you, Ed.'"
"My position with Booz Allen Hamilton granted me access
to lists of machines all over the world [that] the NSA hacked," Snowden
told the South China Morning Post, adding that this was exactly why he'd
accepted it. He was one of around 1,000 NSA "sysadmins" allowed to
look at many parts of this system. (Other users with top-secret clearance
weren't allowed to see all classified files.) He could open a file without
leaving an electronic trace. He was, in the words of one intelligence source, a
"ghost user", able to haunt the agency's hallowed places. He may also
have used his administrator status to persuade others to entrust their login
details to him.
Although we don't know exactly how he harvested the
material, it appears Snowden downloaded NSA documents on to thumbnail drives.
Thumb drives are forbidden to most staff, but a sysadmin could argue that he or
she was repairing a corrupted user profile and needed a backup. Sitting back in
Hawaii, Snowden could remotely reach into the NSA's servers. Most staff had
already gone home for the night when he logged on, six time zones away. After
four weeks in his new job, Snowden told his bosses at Booz that he was unwell.
He wanted some time off and requested unpaid leave. When they checked back with
him, he told them he had epilepsy (a condition that affects his mother).
And then, on 20 May, he vanished.
In December 2012,
a reader pinged an email to Guardian columnist Glenn
Greenwald, one of the more prominent US political commentators of his
generation, based in Brazil. The email didn't stand out; he gets dozens of
similar ones every day. The sender didn't identify himself. He (or it could
have been a she) wrote: "I have some stuff you might be interested
in."
"He was very vague," Greenwald recalls.
This mystery correspondent asked Greenwald to install PGP
encryption software on his laptop. Once up and running, it guarantees privacy
(the initials stand for Pretty Good Privacy) for an online chat. Greenwald had
no objections. But there were two problems. "I'm basically technically
illiterate," he admits. Greenwald also had a lingering sense that the kind
of person who insisted on encryption might turn out to be slightly crazy.
A month after first trying Greenwald and failing to get a
response, Snowden tried a different route. At the end of January 2013, he sent
an email to Greenwald's friend and collaborator Laura Poitras, a documentary
film-maker. She was another leading critic of the US security state – and one
of its more prominent victims. For six years, between 2006 and 2012, agents
from the Department of Homeland Security detained Poitras each time she entered
the US. They would interrogate her, confiscate laptops and mobile phones, and
demand to know whom she had met. They would seize her camera and notebooks.
Nothing incriminating was ever discovered. Poitras became an expert in
encryption. She decided to edit her next film, her third in a trilogy about US
security, from outside America, and moved temporarily to Berlin.
Snowden's email to Poitras read: "I am a senior member
of the intelligence community. This won't be a waste of your time." (The
claim was something of an exaggeration: he was a relatively junior
infrastructure analyst.) Snowden asked for her encryption key. She gave it.
"I felt pretty intrigued pretty quickly," Poitras says. "At that
point, my thought was either it's legit or it's entrapment."
The tone of the emails was serious, though there were
moments of humour. At one point Snowden advised Poitras to put her mobile in
the freezer. "He's an amazing writer. His emails were good. Everything I
got read like a thriller," she recalls.
Then Snowden delivered a bombshell. He said he had got hold
of Presidential Policy Directive 20,
a top-secret 18-page document issued in October 2012. It
said that the agency was tapping fibre optic cables, intercepting telephone
landing points and bugging on a global scale. And he could prove all of it.
"I almost fainted," Poitras says. The source made it clear he wanted
Greenwald on board.
Poitras moved ultra-cautiously. It was a fair assumption
that the US embassy in Berlin had her under some form of surveillance. It would
have to be a personal meeting. In late March, she returned to the US and met
Greenwald in the lobby of his hotel, the Marriott in Yonkers. They agreed that
they needed to get hold of the national security documents: without them, it
would be difficult to rattle the doors on these issues.
Poitras had assumed that Snowden would seek to remain
anonymous, but he told her: "I hope you will paint a target on my back and
tell the world I did this on my own."
By late spring 2013, the possibility of a meeting was in the
air. Snowden intended to leak one actual document. The file would reveal
collaboration between the NSA and giant internet corporations under a secret
program called Prism.
Poitras flew again to New York for what she imagined would
be her meeting with a senior intelligence bureaucrat. The source then sent her
an encrypted file. In it was the Prism PowerPoint, and a second document that
came as a total surprise: "Your destination is Hong Kong." The next
day, he told her his name for the first time.
Poitras knew that if she searched Snowden's name on Google,
this would immediately alert the NSA. Attached was a map, a set of protocols
for how they would meet, and a message: "This is who I am. This is what
they will say about me. This is the information I have."
In mid-April, Greenwald received a FedEx parcel containing
two thumb drives with a security kit allowing him to install a basic encrypted
chat program. Snowden now contacted Greenwald himself. "I have been
working with a friend of yours… We need to talk, urgently." The
whistleblower finally had a direct, secure connection to the elusive writer.
Snowden wrote: "Can you come to Hong Kong?"
The demand struck Greenwald as bizarre. His instinct was to
do nothing. He contacted Snowden via chat. "I would like some more
substantial idea why I'm going and why this is worthwhile for me?"
Over the next two hours, Snowden explained to Greenwald how
to boot up the Tails system, one of the securest forms of communication.
Snowden then wrote, with what can only be called understatement, "I'm
going to send you a few documents."
Snowden's welcome package was around 20 documents from the
NSA's inner sanctuaries, most stamped Top Secret. At a glance, it suggested the
NSA had misled Congress about the nature of its domestic spying activities, and
quite possibly lied. "It was unbelievable," Greenwald says. "It
was enough to make me hyperventilate."
Two days later, on 31 May, Greenwald sat in the office of
Janine Gibson, the Guardian US's editor in New York. He said a trip to Hong
Kong would enable the Guardian to find out about the mysterious source. Stuart
Millar, the deputy editor of Guardian US, joined the discussion. Both
executives agreed that the only way to establish the source's credentials was
to meet him in person. Greenwald would take the 16-hour flight to Hong Kong the
next day. Independently, Poitras was coming along, too. But Gibson ordered a
third member on to the team, the Guardian's veteran Washington correspondent
Ewen MacAskill. The 61-year-old Scot and political reporter was experienced and
professional. He was calm. Everybody liked him.
Except Poitras. She was exceedingly upset. As she saw it, an
extra person might freak out the source, who was already on edge. "She was
insistent that this would not happen," Greenwald says. "She
completely flipped out." He tried to mediate, without success.
However, at JFK airport, the ill-matched trio boarded a
Cathay Pacific flight. Poitras sat at the back of the plane. She was funding
her own trip. Greenwald and MacAskill, their bills picked up by the Guardian,
were farther up in Premium Economy. As flight CX831 took off, there was a
feeling of liberation. Up in the air, there is no internet – or at least there
wasn't in June 2013. Once the seatbelt signs were off, Poitras brought a
present they were both eager to open: a USB stick. Snowden had securely delivered
her a second cache of secret NSA documents. This latest data set was far bigger
than the initial "welcome pack". It contained 3,000-4,000 items.
For the rest of the journey, Greenwald read the latest
cache, mesmerised. Sleep was impossible: "I didn't take my eyes off the
screen for a second. The adrenaline was so extreme." From time to time
Poitras would come up from her seat in the rear and grin at Greenwald. "We
would just cackle and giggle like schoolchildren. We were screaming and hugging
and dancing with each other up and down," he says. Their celebrations woke
up some of their neighbours; they didn't care.
The first rendezvous was in Kowloon's Mira hotel, a chic,
modern edifice in the heart of the tourist district. Poitras and Greenwald were
to meet Snowden in a quiet part of the hotel, next to a large plastic
alligator. They would swap pre-agreed phrases. Snowden would carry a Rubik's
cube.
Everything Greenwald knew about Snowden pointed in one
direction: that he was a grizzled veteran of the intelligence community.
"I thought he must be a pretty senior bureaucrat," Greenwald says.
Probably 60-odd, wearing a blue blazer with shiny gold buttons, receding grey
hair, sensible black shoes, spectacles, a club tie. Perhaps he was the CIA's
station chief in Hong Kong.
The pair reached the alligator ahead of schedule. They sat
down. They waited. Nothing happened. The source didn't show. Strange.
If the initial meeting failed, the plan was to return later
the same morning. Greenwald and Poitras came back. They waited for a second
time.
And then they saw him – a pale, spindle-limbed, nervous,
preposterously young man. He was dressed in a white T-shirt and jeans. In his
right hand was a scrambled Rubik's cube. Had there been a mistake?
The young man – if indeed he were the source – had sent
encrypted instructions as to how the initial verification would proceed:
Greenwald: What time does the restaurant open?
The source: At noon. But don't go there, the food sucks…
Greenwald – nervous – said his lines, struggling to keep a
straight face. Snowden then said simply, "Follow me." The three
walked silently to the elevator. They rode to the first floor and followed the
cube-man to room 1014. Optimistically, Greenwald speculated that he was the son
of the source, or his personal assistant. If not, then the encounter was a
waste of time, a hoax.
Over the course of the day, however, Snowden told his story.
He had access to tens of thousands of documents taken from NSA and GCHQ's
internal servers. Most were stamped Top Secret. Some were marked Top Secret
Strap 1 – the British higher tier of super-classification for intercept
material – or even Strap 2, which was almost as secret as you could get. No one
– apart from a restricted circle of security officials – had ever seen
documents of this kind before. What he was carrying, Snowden indicated, was the
biggest intelligence leak in history.
Greenwald bombarded him with questions. His credibility was
on the line. So was that of his editors at the Guardian. Yet if Snowden were
genuine, at any moment a CIA Swat team could burst into the room, confiscate
his laptops and drag him away.
As he gave his answers, they began to feel certain Snowden
was no fake. And his reasons for becoming a whistleblower were cogent, too. The
NSA could bug "anyone", from the president downwards, he said. In
theory, the spy agency was supposed to collect only "signals intelligence"
on foreign targets. In practice this was a joke, Snowden told Greenwald: it was
already hoovering up metadata from millions of Americans. Phone records, email
headers, subject lines, seized without acknowledgment or consent. From this you
could construct a complete electronic narrative of an individual's life: their
friends, lovers, joys, sorrows.
The NSA had secretly attached intercepts to the undersea
fibre optic cables that ringed the world. This allowed them to read much of the
globe's communications. Secret courts were compelling telecoms providers to
hand over data. What's more, pretty much all of Silicon Valley was involved
with the NSA, Snowden said – Google, Microsoft, Facebook, even Steve Jobs's
Apple. The NSA claimed it had "direct access" to the tech giants'
servers. It had even put secret back doors into online encryption software –
used to make secure bank payments – weakening the system for everybody. The spy
agencies had hijacked the internet. Snowden told Greenwald he didn't want to
live in a world "where everything that I say, everything that I do,
everyone I talk to, every expression of love or friendship is recorded".
Snowden agreed to meet MacAskill the next morning. The
encounter went smoothly until the reporter produced his iPhone. He asked Snowden
if he minded if he taped their interview, and perhaps took some photos? Snowden
flung up his arms in alarm, as if prodded by an electric stick. "I might
as well have invited the NSA into his bedroom," MacAskill says. The young
technician explained that the spy agency was capable of turning a mobile phone
into a microphone and tracking device; bringing it into the room was an
elementary mistake. MacAskill dumped the phone.
Snowden's own precautions were remarkable. He piled pillows
up against the door to stop anyone eavesdropping from outside in the corridor.
When putting passwords into computers, he placed a big red hood over his head
and laptop, so the passwords couldn't be picked up by hidden cameras. On the
three occasions he left his room, Snowden put a glass of water behind the door
next to a bit of tissue paper. The paper had a soy sauce mark with a
distinctive pattern. If anyone entered the room, the water would fall on the
paper and it would change the pattern.
MacAskill asked Snowden, almost as an afterthought, whether
there was a UK role in this mass data collection. It didn't seem likely to him.
MacAskill knew that GCHQ had a longstanding intelligence-sharing relationship
with the US, but he was taken aback by Snowden's vehement response. "GCHQ
is worse than the NSA," Snowden said. "It's even more
intrusive."
The following day, Wednesday 5 June, Snowden was still in
place at the Mira hotel. That was the good news. The bad news was that the NSA
and the police had been to see his girlfriend, Lindsay Mills, back at their
home in Hawaii. Snowden's absence from work had been noted, an automatic
procedure when NSA staff do not turn up. Snowden agonised: "My family does
not know what is happening. My primary fear is that they will come after my
family, my friends, my partner." He admitted, "That keeps me up at
night."
But the CIA hadn't found him yet. This was one of the more
baffling aspects of the Snowden affair: why did the US authorities not close in
on him earlier? Once they had spotted his absence, they might have pulled
flight records showing he had fled to Hong Kong. There he was comparatively
easy to trace. He had checked into the $330-a-night Mira hotel under his own
name. He was even paying the bill with his personal credit card.
That evening, Greenwald rapidly drafted a story about
Verizon, revealing how the NSA was secretly collecting all the records from
this major US telecoms company. Greenwald would work on his laptop, then pass
it to MacAskill. MacAskill would type on his computer and hand Greenwald his
articles on a memory stick; the sticks flowed back and forth. Nothing went on
email.
In New York, Gibson drew up a careful plan for the first
story. It had three basic components: seek legal advice; work out a strategy
for approaching the White House; get draft copy from the reporters in Hong
Kong. She wrote a tentative schedule on a whiteboard. (It was later titled The
Legend Of The Phoenix, a line from 2013's big summer hit, Daft Punk's Get
Lucky.)
Events were moving at speed. MacAskill had tapped out a
four-word text from Hong Kong: "The Guinness is good." This code
phrase meant he was now convinced Snowden was genuine. Gibson decided to give
the NSA a four-hour window to comment, so the agency had an opportunity to
disavow the story. By British standards, the deadline was fair: long enough to make
a few calls, agree a line. But for Washington, where journalist-administration
relations sometimes resemble a country club, this was nothing short of
outrageous. In London, the Guardian's editor-in-chief, Alan Rusbridger, headed
for the airport for the next available New York flight.
The White House sent in its top guns for a conference call
with the Guardian. The team included FBI deputy director Sean M Joyce, a Boston
native with an action-man resumé – investigator against Colombian narcotics,
counter-terrorism officer, legal attaché in Prague. Also patched in was Chris
Inglis, the NSA's deputy director. He was a man who interacted with journalists
so rarely, he was considered by many to be a mythical entity. Then there was
Robert S Litt, the general counsel to the Office of the Director of National
Intelligence. Litt was clever, likable, voluble, dramatic, lawyerly and prone
to rhetorical flourishes. On the Guardian side were Gibson and Millar, sitting
in Gibson's small office, with its cheap sofa and unimpressive view of
Broadway.
By fielding heavyweights, the White House had perhaps
reckoned it could flatter, and if necessary bully, the Guardian into delaying
publication. Gibson explained that the editor-in-chief – in the air halfway across
the Atlantic – was unavailable. She said: "I'm the final
decision-maker." After 20 minutes, the White House was frustrated. The
conversation was going in circles. Finally, one of the team could take no more.
Losing his temper, he shouted, "You don't need to publish this! No serious
news organisation would publish this!" Gibson replied, "With the
greatest respect, we will take the decisions about what we publish."
Over in Hong Kong, Snowden and Greenwald were restless.
Greenwald signalled that he was ready and willing to self-publish or take the
scoop elsewhere if the Guardian hesitated. Time was running out. Snowden could
be uncovered at any minute.
Just after 7pm, Guardian US went ahead and ran the story.
That evening, diggers arrived and tore up the sidewalk
immediately in front of the Guardian's US office, a mysterious activity for a
Wednesday night. With smooth efficiency, they replaced it. More diggers arrived
outside Gibson's home in Brooklyn. Soon, every member of the Snowden team was
able to recount similar unusual moments: "taxi drivers" who didn't
know the way or the fare; "window cleaners" who lingered next to the
editor's office. "Very quickly, we had to get better at spycraft,"
Gibson says.
Snowden now declared his intention to go public. Poitras
recorded Greenwald interviewing him. She made a 12-minute film and got the
video through to New York. In the Guardian US office, the record of Snowden
actually speaking was cathartic. "We were completely blown away,"
Millar says. "We thought he was cool and plausible." When the moment
arrived, with the video ready to go live, the atmosphere in the newsroom was
deeply emotional.
Five people, including Rusbridger, were in the office. The
video went up about 3pm local time on Sunday 9 June. "It was like a bomb
going off," Rusbridger says. "There is a silent few seconds after a
bomb explodes when nothing happens." The TV monitors were put on different
channels; for almost an hour they carried prerecorded Sunday news. Then at 4pm
the story erupted. Each network carried Snowden's image. It was 3am in Hong
Kong when the video was posted online. It was the most-viewed story in the
Guardian's history.
Snowden had just become the most hunted man on the planet.
The chase was already on. Greenwald, in one of his many TV interviews, had been
captioned by CNN as "Glenn Greenwald, Hong Kong" – a pretty big clue.
The local Chinese media and international journalists now studied every frame
of the video for clues. One enterprising hack used Twitter to identify the Mira
from its lamps.
And then Snowden vanished.
• © Luke Harding 2014
This is an edited extract from The Snowden Files: The Inside
Story Of The World's Most Wanted Man, by Luke Harding, published in the UK on Monday
by Guardian Faber at £12.99; and in the US on 11 February by Vintage Books
(excerpted by permission of Vintage, a division of Penguin Random House LLC.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted
without permission in writing from the publisher). To order a copy for £8.99,
including free mainland UK p&p, call 0330 333 6846 or go to
guardianbookshop.co.uk.
Watch the video of the day GCHQ came to the Guardian at
theguardian.com/video.
In G2 on 3 February, what happened next: Edward Snowden in
exile.
Sem comentários:
Enviar um comentário